Not Written in Stone

Learning and Unlearning American History Through 200 Years of Textbooks

Kyle Ward

• Publisher: The New Press
• Year: 2010
• ISBN:
  9781595586049
• Topic: Education
• Subtopic: Teaching Social Science

A teaching edition of the "thought-provoking study" History in the Making, which explores how our view of the history changes over time ( Library Journal ). Kyle Ward's celebrated History in the Making struck a chord among readers of popular history. "Interesting and useful, " according to Booklist, the book "convincingly illustrates how texts change as social and political attitudes evolve." With excerpts from history textbooks that span two hundred years, History in the Making looks at the different ways textbooks from different eras interpret and present the same historical events. Not Written in Stone offers an abridged and annotated version of History in the Making specifically designed for classroom use. In each section, Ward provides an overview, questions for discussions and analysis, and then a fascinating chronological sampling of textbook excerpts which reveal the striking differences between textbooks over time. An exciting new teaching tool, Not Written in Stone is destined to become a staple of classroom teaching about the American past. "Students, teachers, and general readers will learn more about the past from these passages than from any single work, however current, that purports to monopolize the truth." —Ray Raphael, author of Founding Myths

PART I

Discovery and Colonization

1

Images of Native Americans

Native Americans have occupied a unique position in U.S. history textbooks. Starting with history textbooks published in the late 1700s, up until the early 1900s, Native Americans were usually seen as being brutal savages who blocked the progress of white settlers. In the late 1800s to the mid-1900s, textbooks began to refer to Native Americans as “noble savages”—uncivilized people who were part of nature. This story stayed the same until the civil rights movement, and the American Indian Movement in the 1970s, when Native Americans began to demand a more historically accurate version of their ancestors’ history.

1832

Noah Webster, History of the United States: To Which is Prefixed a Brief Historical Account of our [English] Ancestors, from the dispersal at Babel, to their Migration to America, and of the Conquest of South America by the Spaniards

Habitations and Furniture

The dwellings of the savages were huts called wigwams, made with poles fixed in the ground, bent together, fastened at the top, and covered with mats of bulrushes. Their fire was in the middle of the hut, and an opening was left at the top for the smoke to escape. Their beds were mats or skins spread on boards a little raised, for cooking they used pots made of clay; their dishes and spoons were of wood, hollowed and made very smooth. Pails were formed of birch bark, made square, and furnished with a handle. Baskets were made of the same material, or of rushes, bents, husks of the maize, silk grass, or wild hemp, curiously wrought and ornamented.

Dress

The natives of the northern parts of America had no clothing, when the English first came among them, except the skins of wild beasts, and a few mantles made of feathers curiously interwoven. But all the natives of this country were very fond of beads and trinkets, for ornaments; fasten them to their arms, legs, nose and ears. When the Europeans began to trade with them, they exchanged their skins for blankets, and other cloths, and these are their principal dress to this day: all savage nations are very fond of feathers.

Virtues and Vices

The good and bad qualities of Indians are few, or confined to a few objects. In general, a savage is governed by his passions, without much restraint from the authority of his chiefs. He is remarkably hospitable to strangers, offering them the best accommodations he has, and always serving them first. He never forgets a favor or an injury; but will make a grateful return for a favor, and revenge an injury whenever an opportunity offers, as long as he lives; and the remembrance is hereditary for the child and grandchild have the same passions, and will repay a kindness, or revenge wrong done to their ancestor.

Government and Religion

The tribes of Indians were under a government somewhat like a monarchy, with a mixture of aristocracy. Their chiefs, called sagamores, sachems, or cazekes, possessed the powers of government; but they usually consulted the old men of the tribe, on all important questions.

Their religion was idolatry, for they worshiped the sun, the moon, the earth, fire, images and the like. They had an idea of the Supreme Being, whom they called the Great Spirit; and they believed in an evil spirit. They had priests, called powwows, who pretended to arts of conjuration, and who acted as their physicians.1

1860

Benson J. Lossing, A Primary History of the United States

The Indians were tall and straight. They had straight black hair, fine teeth, and black eyes. They were seldom sick, because they had plenty of exercise and ate simple food. They lived in a sort of huts or tents, made of poles covered with the bark of trees or the skins of wild beasts. These were called wigwams.

The men went to war, hunted and fished; and the women planted corn and other things, and did all the hard work. They did not have good tools to work with, for these were made of stones, shells, and bones. Their food was the flesh of the deer, buffalo, and bear, roasted or boiled, with beans, peas, potatoes, and melons.

The Indians had money, but it was not like ours. It was made of shells in the shape of long beads which they strung on threads or fastened upon belts. So many of these pieces were worth a penny, and so many more were worth a shilling or a dollar. This money they called wampum.

The Indians had no schools, and the little children never had pleasant picture books to read. Their mothers taught them to make wampum, mats, skin and feather-clothing, and shell and bone ornaments. But I dare say they did not work much, but played nearly all day in the woods and by the pleasant brooks. They went to bed when the birds did, at sunset, and were up before the sun, and so they kept their eyes bright.

The Indian men loved to fight, for they sometimes felt like tigers. Forty or more of one nation would go and fight those of another nation; and sometimes there would be hundreds on both sides. They fought with bows and arrows, war clubs, scalping-knives, and tomahawks.

When the men were tired of fighting, they would sometimes become good friends, as we white people do. Then they would build a great fire in the woods, and the head men of both nations would meet around it and smoke a pipe which was handed from one to the other. This was called a calumet, or pipe of peace.

The Indian men played ball, fired at the mark, danced, leaped, played games, and had other amusements, but they would never let the women join them. They were not at all polite to the women. I am sure that no right-minded boy, when he gets to be a man, will let his mother, or sister, or wife, do all the hard work, while he hunts, or fishes, or plays; and then not let them have any of the fun.

The Indians did not always bury their dead in the ground. When they did, they wrapped them in skins, and want to use them in the spirit land. They often folded the body in skins, and laid it upon a high scaffold, where wild beasts could not get at it.

The Indians had no churches, yet they believed in God, prayed to Him, and worshiped Him. They called Him the Good Spirit; and they believed in an Evil Spirit. Instead of churches and meeting-houses, they had the sky for a roof; and the wind and the thunder, the singing of birds, and the roar of the storm, was their music. Then they would look up to the sun, the moon, and the stars, and believe that they saw God, for they knew of nothing greater. The Indians knew nothing of the Bible, and the religion of Jesus. They all had one belief, never quarreled about it, and were happy.

The Indians were governed by sachems, and chiefs. The sachems were general rulers; the chiefs were the commanders of the Indian armies. Only wise men were made sachems, and only brave men were made chiefs. These could not govern nor lead if they were not wise and brave.

Such, my young friend, were the copper-colored people who lived in this country hundreds of years ago, and some of whom live here yet. Unless you live beyond the Mississippi river, you seldom see any of them now. They are nearly all beyond that river, and are becoming fewer every year.

The time will come when there will not be an Indian on the earth. You may live to see that time, because they are passing rapidly away. The white man, from the beginning, has used the poor Indians badly. He has cheated and oppressed them, given them rum to take away their senses, and with swords and guns has driven them far into the wilderness.

God, in his wise providence, has permitted the white man to take the Indian’s land away from him. The Indian would not cut down the trees and raise grain, except here and there a little patch; but the white man, as the Bible says, has made “the wilderness to blossom as the rose.” 2

1885

Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Young Folks’ History of the United States

The Indians had great courage, self-control, and patience. They were grave and dignified in their manners, on important occasions, in their councils they were courteous to one another, and discussed all important questions at great length. They were often kind and generous, and sometimes even forgiving; but they generally thought that sternness was a virtue, and forgiveness a weakness. They were especially cruel to captives, putting them to death with all manner of tortures, in which women took an active part. It was the custom among them for women to do most of the hard work, in order that the bodies of the men might be kept supple and active for the pursuits of the chase and war.

When employed on these pursuits, the Indian men seemed incapable of fatigue; but in the camp, or in traveling, the women carried the burdens, and, when a hunter had carried a slain deer on his shoulders for a long distance, he would throw it down within sight of the village, that his squaw might go and bring it in.

Most of the Indian tribes lived in a state of constant warfare with one another. When there was a quarrel between tribes, and war seemed ready to break out, strange ceremonies were used. Some leading chief would paint his body black from head to foot, and would hide himself in the woods or in a cavern. There he would fast and pray, and call upon the Great Spirit; and would observe his dreams, to see if they promised good or evil. If he dreamed of a great war-eagle hovering before him, it was a sign of triumph.

After a time he would come forth from the woods and return among his people. Then he would address them, summon them to war, and tell them that the Great Spirit was on their side. Then he would bid the warriors to a feast at his wigwam. There they would find him no longer painted in black, but in bright and gaudy colors, called “war-paint.” The guests would be also dressed in paint and feathers, and would seat themselves in a circle. Then wooden trenchers containing the flesh of dogs would be placed before them; while the chief would sit smoking his pipe, and would not eat anything.

After the feast, the war-dance would follow, perhaps at night, amid the blaze of fires and lighted pine-knots. A painted post would be driven into the ground, and the crowd would form a wide circle round it. The warchief would leap into the open space, brandishing his hatchet, and would chant his own deeds and those of his fathers, acting out all that he described, and striking at the post as if it were an enemy. Warrior after warrior would follow, till at last the whole band would be dancing, shouting, and brandishing their weapons, striking and stabbing at the air, and filling the forest with their yells.

Much of the night would pass in this way. In the morning the warriors would leave the camp in single file, still decorated with paint and feathers and ornaments; and, as they entered the woods, the chief would fire his gun, and each in turn would do the same.

Then they would halt near the village, would take off their ornaments and their finery, and would give all these things to the women, who had followed them for this purpose. Then the warriors would go silently and stealthily through the forest to the appointed place of attack. Much of their skill consisted in these silent approaches, and in surprises and stratagems, and long and patient watchings. They attached no shame to killing an unarmed enemy, or to private deceit and treachery, though to their public treaties they were always faithful. They were desperately brave, and yet they saw no disgrace in running away when there was no chance of success. Their weapons were at first, the bow and arrow, and a sort of hatchet called a “tomahawk”; and they had shields of bison-hide, and sometimes breastplates of twigs interwoven with cord. Afterwards they learned the use of fire-arms from the whites, and became skilful with these weapons, losing much of their skill with the bow and arrow. Some tribes built strong forts, with timber walls, palisades, banks, and ditches. In these forts they had magazines of stones to hurl down upon those who attacked them; and there were gutters by which to pour down streams of water, should the fort be set on fire.

When first visited by Europeans, the Indians along the coast were already diminishing in number, through war and pestilence; and they have diminished ever since, in the older parts of the country, till many tribes have wholly disappeared. At first they were disposed to be friendly with the white men; but quarrels soon arose, each side being partly to blame. The savages often burned villages, carried away captives, and laid whole regions waste. In return, their villages and forts were destroyed, and their tribes were driven westward, or reduced to a mere handful. Some of these wars will be described farther on in this history; and to this day some of the western settlements of the United States live in constant fear of attack from Indians. But the wilder tribes are passing away; and in another century there will hardly be a roving Indian within the limits of the United States. Only those tribes will survive which have adopted, in part, the habits of civilization.

Of the Indians now within the limits of the United States, more than 150,000 are wholly or partly civilized. About half of these live on what are called “reservations,” in the Indian Territory; while the rest are scattered through various Territories and ...