1
Critical Thinking
At its heart, âcritical thinkingâ is the act of asking yourself difficult questionsâvery difficult questions. Over your academic and professional career, youâll often hear the term âcritical thinking,â and youâll hear it used in many ways, but in whatever context you hear it, critical thinking is always going to be about difficult questions and the sometimes disconcerting answers to those questions. Your job as a writer (and as a professional, even as a parent!) is to ask those difficult questions, and then to answer themâwith uncomfortable honesty.
As I wrote the paragraph above, I had to use critical thinking to ask and answer my own set of difficult questions. Here are some examples:
Question 1: Is my coauthor going to be comfortable with my definition of âcritical thinkingâ?
Answer 1: Sheâs probably going to say: âI like it, but have you gone too far?â
Question 2: Are the publishers going to accept my less than formal writing style? After all, why use such an informal style to discuss how to write formally?
Answer 2: I can see myself having to do a lot of rewriting for those very reasons. But right now, Iâm saying what I think needs to be said. Letâs see what the coauthor and publisher think.
Question 3: I started this chapter with a definition, but wouldnât Sentence 2 of the paragraph be a better sentence to begin the paragraph?
Answer 3: Under normal circumstances, Iâd agree. But âcritical thinkingâ is such an important concept that I want the reader to know exactly what the idea means from the very first sentence.
Question 4: I understand the final sentence, but doesnât it run the risk of scaring some students?
Answer 4: Yes. It should scare them. But I also want it to be honest, and I think students appreciate honesty.
As I was writing the critical thinking questions above, I had to face another round of critical thinking. That is, I was critically thinking about my own critical thinking. For example, consider my answer to Question 1: My answer might be right or wrong as to what my coauthor thinks, but I then had to ask âWould my coauthor actually want me to be writing what I thought she might be thinking?â And, yes, I then had to critically think about the question in this paragraph that questions the question in the previous paragraph. In short, the process just goes on and on and on. The point is: We ask the difficult questions, and we answer them with uncomfortable honesty.
Note here that none of the questions that Iâve raised so far have been questions that I wanted to ask. And none of my answers have been easy. Truth be told, I wanted to finish writing this section today as I was really hoping to see a movie in the next hour or so. But all of these questions had to be asked and, guided by their answers, I have had to edit my work accordingly. Itâs hard, and I can see now that I wonât be watching that movie today.
We Are Already Experts in Difficult Questionsâ(Kind Of)
The good news about critical thinking is that every one of us already knows a lot about it! That is, we already ask ourselves difficult questions and we already face our own uncomfortable answers. The bad news is that we all do this questioning and answering with other aspects of our livesâbut not necessarily with our writing.
Letâs look at an example: It is not hard to imagine some people in the morning, getting ready to go out into the world, and endlessly asking themselves questions about their hair, their makeup, their choice of purse, their shoes, etc. And itâs not hard to imagine people endlessly asking the cutting-edge questions regarding last nightâs refereeing or coaching decisions, or questions regarding the wisdom of any given recent American presidential decision. And for some reason, most of us are seemingly quite expert on raising these difficult questions when they concern our younger siblings. So, yes, we all know how to raise these questions, and we all know how to answer them with simple, honest truths. But asking ourselves these questionsâabout our own writingâis much harder.
What We Need to Be Asking
So, what are the critical thinking questions you need to be asking about writing? Here are a few:
1 What is the purpose of this paragraph?
2 Is the purpose of this paragraph clear from the first sentence of this paragraph?
3 What is the function of this sentence? (and all sentences in the paragraph)
4 Does this sentence facilitate the purpose of this paragraph?
5 Why is this sentence in this position in the paragraph?
6 Does this sentence follow logically from the last sentence?
7 Does this sentence lead logically into the next sentence?
8 Are the words in this sentence appropriate for my purpose?
9 Are the words in this sentence appropriate for my readers?
10 Does the ending of this paragraph help my readers to better understand my purpose?
Now, letâs use these above-mentioned questions to address the first paragraph of this chapter. Hereâs that first paragraph one more time:
At its heart, âcritical thinkingâ is the act of asking yourself difficult questionsâvery difficult questions. Over your academic and professional career, youâll often hear the term âcritical thinking,â and youâll hear it used in many ways, but in whatever context you hear it, critical thinking is always going to be about difficult questions and disconcerting answers to those questions. Your job as a writer (and as a professional, even as a parent!) is to ask those difficult questions, and then to answer themâwith uncomfortable honesty.
Question 1: What is the purpose of this paragraph?
Answer 1: The purpose of this paragraph is to introduce readers to what is meant by critical thinking.
Question 2: Is the purpose of this paragraph clear from the first sentence?
Answer 2: Yes, I think it is. The first sentence actually defines âcritical thinking.â The statement should make the paragraphâs purpose clear.
Question 3: What is the function of [for example] Sentence 2?
Answer 3: I defined the term âcritical thinkingâ in Sentence 1; however, a quick Google search of this term will easily reveal how broadly it is applied. As such, I want readers to understand that there is no universal agreement as to its definition.
Question 4: Does this sentence [Sentence 2] facilitate the purpose of the paragraph?
Answer 4: Yes, as the paragraph is an introduction to critical thinking, Sentence 2 facilitates the paragraphâs purpose of explaining that critical thinking is a broadly used term.
Question 5: Why is this sentence [Sentence 2] in this position in the paragraph?
Answer 5: Critical thinking is not an easy concept. As such, I wanted to start the paragraph with a definition so that readers knew immediately the topic under discussion. However, as soon as that task was complete, I wanted readers to know that my definition was not the only definition.
Question 6: Does this sentence [Sentence 2] follow logically from the last sentence?
Answer 6: Truth be told, Iâm not 100 percent happy about it. In some ways, I seem to be contradicting myself. That is, if I start by saying that critical thinking is this one thing, then why am I following that up by saying that critical thinking can actually be something else too?
Question 7: Does this sentence [Sentence 2] lead logically into the next sentence?
Answer 7: Yes, and I think the third sentence solves the potential problem of Sentence 2. In fact, I rather like how Sentence 3 makes the previous potential confusion of Sentence 2 into something of an answer to a riddle. Yes, Iâm even a little smugly satisfied about Sentence 3. (Although, Iâm not altogether sure how my coauthor will feel about itâwe shall see.)
Question 8: Are the words in this sentence [Sentence 2] appropriate for my purpose?
Answer 8: Yes, sort of. Well, actually, after reading the sentence again, I moved the word often from the end of the clause to its current position. Iâm also not 100 percent sure of the phrase Over your academic and professional career. I donât really like the part âprofessional career,â because I wanted to keep the whole thing to college work. But critical thinking applies throughout life, so I actually wanted to include something like âand even when youâre a parent!â but that was going too far. No, wait. I do actually like the part about being a parent. So, Iâll change that. (And this is how the process works!)
Question 9: Are the words in this sentence [Sentence 2] appropriate for my readers?
Answer 9: I think so. My readers are college students, and college students know very well that they should be doing work in college thatâs going to help them after college. Thatâs why Iâm trying to slip in the fact that critical thinking is a life skill, not just a writing skill.
Question 10: Does the ending of this paragraph help my readers to better understand my purpose?
Answer 10: I want my readers to know that critical thinking is vital, but that itâs really hard! My readers are students. They already know that things are hard, and theyâre probably sick of hearing instructors say that such-and-such is easy! Saying something is âeasy,â doesnât actually make it easy! And one of the reasons as to why critical thinking is so hard is thatâfranklyâitâs pretty boring (at least, at first). After all, writing the first draft of a paragraph is hard enough, and then having to ask a bunch of questions about it makes i...