Discourse, Use of Military Force and Role of State

A Role-theoretic Discourse Analysis of German Parliamentary Debates on Mission in Afghanistan

Ni, Xiaoshan

• Publisher: Cuvillier Verlag
• Year: 2022
• eBook ISBN:
  9783736966857
• Print ISBN:
  9783736976856
• Edition: 1

As the prototype of the "civilian power", Germany has always stressed the importance and necessity of diplomatic means to resolve crises. The participation of the Bundeswehr in the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) in Afghanistan was a significant exercise of the new security policy after German reunification. Given that linguistic actors construct knowledge through their personal actions, security policy is necessarily reflected in the relevant discourses of political elites. This publication attempts to combine Linguistic Discourse Analysis and Role Theory to construct a role-theoretic discourse analysis approach for German security policy study: The parliamentary debate is a prerequisite for the legitimizing mandate for the use of the German military abroad; the topos/topoi and (pro-and contra-) arguments construct the parliamentary debate discourse and influence decisions on military action abroad; the use of the topos/topoi and arguments is constructed by the role perceptions of the German political elite, and the final decisions are the result of behavioral preferences influenced by role perceptions.

Table of contents

• Figures and Tables
• I. Introduction
• 1.1 Research Background and Research Questions
• 1.2 ISAF and Parliamentary Debates
• 1.3 Literature Review
• 1.4 Significance and Structure of Research
• II. Theoretical Foundations
• 2.1 Political Linguistics (Politolinguistics)
• 2.2 Discourse and Discourse Analysis
• 2.3 Discourse Analysis at Argumentative Level
• 2.4 Role Theory and International Relations Research
• III. Research Methodology
• 3.1 Construction of Research Corpus
• 3.2 Pre-study
• 3.3 Argumentation Analysis Framework of ISAF Discourse
• IV. Argumentation Analysis of ISAF Discourseunder Schröder (2001-2005)
• 4.1 Schröder I (26/10/1998-17/10/2002)
• 4.2 Schröder II(22/09/2002-18/10/2005)
• V. Argumentation Analysis of ISAF Discourseunder Merkel (2005-2014)
• 5.1 Merkel I (18/10/2005-27/10/2009)
• 5.2 Merkel II(27/10/2009-22/10/2013)
• 5.3 Merkel III(22/10/2013-31/12/2014)
• VI. Diachronic Comparison of Discoursesfrom Schröder to Merkel
• 6.1 Comparison of Use of Topoi and Arguments
• 6.2 Comparison of ISAF Discourse
• 6.3 Comparison of Role Perceptions in ISAF Discourse
• VII. Conclusions and Discussion
• 7.1 Conclusions
• 7.2 Innovations, Limitations and Further Research
• References
• List of Minutes of Plenary Proceedings in Corpus