Ethnography and the Corporate Encounter
eBook - ePub

Ethnography and the Corporate Encounter

Reflections on Research in and of Corporations

Melissa Cefkin, Melissa Cefkin

Share book
  1. 262 pages
  2. English
  3. ePUB (mobile friendly)
  4. Available on iOS & Android
eBook - ePub

Ethnography and the Corporate Encounter

Reflections on Research in and of Corporations

Melissa Cefkin, Melissa Cefkin

Book details
Book preview
Table of contents
Citations

About This Book

Businesses and other organizations are increasingly hiring anthropologists and other ethnographically-oriented social scientists as employees, consultants, and advisors. The nature of such work, as described in this volume, raises crucial questions about potential implications to disciplines of critical inquiry such as anthropology. In addressing these issues, the contributors explore how researchers encounter and engage sites of organizational practice in such roles as suppliers of consumer-insight for product design or marketing, or as advisors on work design or business and organizational strategies. The volume contributes to the emerging canon of corporate ethnography, appealing to practitioners who wish to advance their understanding of the practice of corporate ethnography and providing rich material to those interested in new applications of ethnographic work and the ongoing rethinking of the nature of ethnographic praxis.

Frequently asked questions

How do I cancel my subscription?
Simply head over to the account section in settings and click on “Cancel Subscription” - it’s as simple as that. After you cancel, your membership will stay active for the remainder of the time you’ve paid for. Learn more here.
Can/how do I download books?
At the moment all of our mobile-responsive ePub books are available to download via the app. Most of our PDFs are also available to download and we're working on making the final remaining ones downloadable now. Learn more here.
What is the difference between the pricing plans?
Both plans give you full access to the library and all of Perlego’s features. The only differences are the price and subscription period: With the annual plan you’ll save around 30% compared to 12 months on the monthly plan.
What is Perlego?
We are an online textbook subscription service, where you can get access to an entire online library for less than the price of a single book per month. With over 1 million books across 1000+ topics, we’ve got you covered! Learn more here.
Do you support text-to-speech?
Look out for the read-aloud symbol on your next book to see if you can listen to it. The read-aloud tool reads text aloud for you, highlighting the text as it is being read. You can pause it, speed it up and slow it down. Learn more here.
Is Ethnography and the Corporate Encounter an online PDF/ePUB?
Yes, you can access Ethnography and the Corporate Encounter by Melissa Cefkin, Melissa Cefkin in PDF and/or ePUB format, as well as other popular books in Social Sciences & Anthropology. We have over one million books available in our catalogue for you to explore.

Information

Year
2009
ISBN
9780857455352
Subtopic
Anthropology
Edition
1
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
Business, Anthropology, and
the Growth of Corporate Ethnography
image
Melissa Cefkin
A relentless quest for innovation, improvement, and change—in short, “the new”—characterizes the steady march of corporate and organizational efforts of all kinds. In the latter part of the twenty-first century, a confluence of social, economic, and cultural dynamics, glossed by such terms as globalization, the new economy, knowledge work, customer-centered business, mass customization, and the information age, cast a particular hue on that quest. A pursuit desiring of a more nuanced grasp on the varieties of human experience both exposed by and driven through these dynamics, within this context anthropological perspectives and the application of ethnography to business and organizational actions have emerged as a favored source for this understanding. Ethnographic researchers, many of them anthropologists, have “entered the corporation,” invited there to influence the organizations' understandings, and effectiveness and profits, to be sure, of their customers, their employees, and the social and cultural worlds they inhabit. Attesting to this interest, a steady stream of journalistic reportage on the phenomena of ethnographic work in corporate and public sector enterprises has appeared, going so far as to suggest that “anthropologists are now regarded as a necessity at such firms” (“Off with the Pith Helmets” 2004).
Growing out of an intermittent history of prior interactions between anthropology and the business world, I believe that a confluence of recent developments points to the emergence of a nascent canon of corporate ethnography. The drive anthropologically oriented researchers feel to work deep within the engines of the business sector is now being matched by corporations who seek to actively engage ethnographic work as a part of their strategic and operational efforts. This interest is not restricted to for-profit businesses. Not-for-profit and governmental enterprises are getting into the act as well.
The experiences of practitioners who perform this work promises valuable insight on these dynamics and on the cultural, social, and economic worlds the organizations they work with produce and inhabit. Practitioners' experiences also provoke consideration about the effect of ethnography in business, about the role those who engage in and with it play, and about the value, practice, impact, and quandaries of producing particularly situated ethnographic understandings as the basis for action in the corporate sector. As described below, numerous sites for this deliberation are beginning to emerge. And yet, answering the questions raised by this realm of work will be neither simple nor straightforward, requiring evaluation through both the kind of perspective afforded by an ethnography of the ethnography in and of industry as well as through the reflections of practitioners themselves. The contributors to this volume engage, in bits and pieces, in both such examinations. Our aim is to identify and sharpen the questions raised by this realm of work and to advance an understanding of the role of ethnographic work in industry and its effect on both organizations and in intellectual traditions of cultural analysis.
This book explores anthropological relations within organizations for whom, and with whom, ethnographic work is conducted. Examined from the perspective of anthropological researchers engaged to influence organizational decisions and actions, the volume explores how sites of research are construed and experienced as well as how practitioner-researchers confront questions of their own positioning. The authors reflect on their struggles to prompt different ways of thinking, knowing, and doing in these organizations. Proceeding by way of descriptions of particular projects, practices, and subjects of the researchers' work, the volume also broadens the aperture to consider how ethnographic work in industry is in dialogue with broader social and cultural discourses. Aware that their anthropologically inspired work is positioned within powerful sites of socio-economic production, the authors commit to exploring the meanings of their work within traces of traditions of critical inquiry. Neither a “how-to” book in applied anthropology, nor one of angst-ridden hand wringing about practitioners' moral and political complicity, the aim of this volume is, nonetheless, to explore and expose the very complex conditions of this work.
At a time when cultural analysts, perhaps anthropologists in particular, are voicing renewed concern for the value, impact, and representation (or lack thereof) of their work to matters of social import, this volume contributes to ongoing explorations of the positioning of cultural researchers vis-Ă -vis those they work with and through as well as in regard to broader forces of social production. That the contexts of inquiry are business and organizational settings is, on this front, simply a matter of locating the work; the thoughts contained in these explorations can be productively engaged by anyone interested in issues of anthropological relations in contexts of ethnographic study and their implications to knowledge production. Readers particularly interested in business and organizational sites and applications of ethnography (including those currently or potentially participating in it) can additionally expect to gain insight onto contemporary business practices, epistemologies, and ideologies (see especially chapters 2 and 7) and can expect to learn about corporate anthropology and the many ways it is performed (see especially chapters 3 and 4 for descriptive accounts.) Indeed, the business and organizational contexts of these examinations and the fact that the authors are themselves active participants in them adds a significant set of dimensions to these concerns. Accordingly, the volume invites more incisive examination and discussion about issues of representation, efficacy, and positioning among the growing community of ethnographic practitioners directly involved in corporate and organizational worlds. Finally, the many interested (and non-anthropologically trained) business colleagues of such ethnographic practitioners may expect to find value in these discussions as well, both broadening and deepening their understanding of the perspective of ethnographic work in industry and the hopes and worries their ethnographic collaborators bring to it.
Just as ethnographic practitioners in industry contexts are particularly situated within the everyday sites of their work, this work emerges as well out of particular histories. Below I provide a fuller account of recent developments and situate these developments in both disciplinary and social historical trajectories. I conclude by outlining the structure and contents of the volume more fully.
Recent Developments: Convergences
Toward a New Corporate Ethnography
Refractive of the online communities, user-driven content sites, and digital social-networking forums many business anthropologists are hired to research and advise on, numerous blogs, user groups, and websites have emerged to join and service the growing set of people engaged with corporate ethnography. Indicative of the increased energy invested in and attention to corporate ethnography is the vibrant Yahoo discussion group, Anthrodesign. Started in 2002,1 Anthrodesign has grown by word of mouth from its original six members to over fifteen hundred by the autumn of 2008. In addition to regular calls for advice and information seeking, participants on the list frequently engage in active and lengthy discussions and debates around the nature of the ethnographic enterprise in commercial and organizational settings and its relationship to other fields of practice and academic disciplines. Similar forums exist within social networking sites such as Facebook and Linked In.
The flourishing interest and activity in the area of corporate ethnography is also mirrored in institutional placements. Figures indicate that more than half of anthropology PhDs are employed in ways other than traditional higher-education teaching positions (Bennett et al. 2006; Rylko-Bauer, Singer, and Willigen 2006). Many maintain membership in professional associations such as the American Anthropological Association (AAA), who estimates that more than 20 percent of its membership in 2005 was employed outside academia (Bennett et al. 2006), the Society for Applied Anthropology (SfAA), the European Association of Social Anthropologists (EASA), and the Association for Social Anthropology (ASA) in the United Kingdom. At the same time, a large number of scholars and practitioners from other fields—not just from within the social sciences and humanities (such as sociology or cultural studies) but also design and technical fields—are developing expertise in ethnographic research.
Stirrings of Corporate Ethnography
Where are all these ethnographically oriented practitioners employed? Many can be found in the numerous management consultancies, design firms, market research companies, marketing agencies, and small think tanks that were established and grew in the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s. Firms focusing on everything from strategy consulting to product and system design to market research to change management boast of their ethnographic and anthropological approaches and capabilities. They may employ anthropologists, include various forms of ethnographic research techniques in their tool kits, and articulate their guiding perspectives in terms at least partially derived from ethnography and anthropology.2
Mid-sized and large corporations also participate in this dynamic. In the US,3 the hiring of Eleanor Wynn and then Lucy Suchman in the late 1970s into Xerox's famed research lab, the Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), is commonly pointed to as the initiation of an active pursuit by companies to hire anthropologically trained ethnographers directly into research and product development labs. Xerox stood out into the 1990s for its concentration of ethnographic researchers across its research labs in California, New York, and Great Britain (employing about eleven researchers engaged in and capable of ethnographic studies, nine of them PhD anthropologists or sociologists4), as well as for the notable output of anthropological research publications which continues to this day.5 Other large corporations, too, began hiring anthropologists and others with ethnographic research expertise. General Motors, Hewlett Packard, Kodak, Motorola, Sun Microsystems, and others have had or continue to have anthropologists on their payrolls. In the late 1990s, the “fast five” internet consulting firms such as Scient, Viant, and Razorfish were in a race to bring ethnographers in-house. Sapient Corporation triumphed in this competition by acquiring eLab, a research and design consultancy profoundly guided by anthropological and ethnographic methods and sensibilities6 in 1999. After the acquisition, Sapient's Experience Modeling function grew to employ (prior to the dot-com bust of 2001) no fewer than 23 PhDs in anthropology and closely aligned disciplines, and over 120 people worldwide with ethnographically informed research capability. In the 2000s, Intel has similarly been notable for its large concentration of anthropologists, some of whom hold significant strategic and organizational roles in the company. As of the fall of 2006, fifteen of the twenty-four or so researchers with ethnography as a part of their training and responsibilities held PhDs in anthropology, and Technology Review gleefully (and over-ambitiously, as it turned out) reported in 2006 that Intel was “in the process of hiring more than 100 anthropologists and other social scientists to work side by side with its engineers” (Fitzgerald 2006). Microsoft, too, has brought on numerous anthropologists and ethnographic researchers in both their research and product divisions, with about twenty practitioners as of the fall of 2006 (seven with PhDs in anthropology). Other high-tech firms such as IBM, Yahoo, and Google have hired anthropologists (albeit in single-digit numbers) and developed ethnographic capability in-house. Similarly, several government research labs, such as NASA and Sandia, have brought anthropologists in-house to work in labs or in organizationally focused roles as ethnographers and scholars, while others, such as the Department of Veterans Affairs, actively work with ethnographic consultancies on organizational matters.
Independent research firms, often operating from a mix of grant funding and contracted research, have also participated in this growth of corporate and organizational ethnography over the last several decades. Notable among them and paralleling the history of anthropology and ethnography at Xerox PARC was the not-for-profit Institute for Research on Learning (IRL). Founded in 1986 through seed funding from The Xerox Foundation, IRL's aim was to rethink learning by providing a deeper understanding and appreciation of the sociality of learning contexts and practices. The methodological and epistemological foundations of IRL's approach were strongly informed by ethnographic and anthropological principles, most evidently through the work of the anthropologist and social-learning theorist Jean Lave done in conjunction with the IRL researcher Etienne Wenger (1991). Many of IRL's full-time and contract members over the decade and a half of its existence were anthropologists and the institute maintained a strong connection to PARC throughout this time.7
Emerging Institutionalization
The nascent institutionalization of a new corporate ethnography is also being signaled from within the academy. In the United States, several departments of anthropology have formulated specializations responsive to this current confluence of events. Wayne State University offers a doctorate with a concentration in business and organizational anthropology (BOA),8 while San Jose State University launched a master's degree in applied anthropology in 2006 to prepare people as researchers, administrators, and program developers for public- and private-sector organizations.9 The anthropology department at the University of North Texas also has a concentration in business anthropology.10 Yet further academic groups are forming throughout Europe and the UK with a focus on anthropology and ethnography for enterprises. Among these are the User Centered Design group at the Mads Clausen Institute for Product Innovation at the University of Southern Denmark, which offers a concentration in design anthropology, and the London-based Incubator for Critical Inquiry into Technology and Ethnography (INCITE) program. Founded in 2001 in the sociology department at the University of Surrey in the UK and now housed at Goldsmiths University, INCITE actively works across anthropology-, cultural-, and gender-study programs as well as with researchers in the private sector.11 Moreover, anthropologists worldwide have been actively hired into or affiliated with other university departments with strong relations to the corporate world such as business,12 computer science and informatics,13 and design.14
Scholarly production in the form of conferences and publications further signals the emergence of a canon of new corporate ethnography. A number of books that address aspects of this growing field have been published since the early 2000s, including Susan Squires and Bryan Byrne's Creating Breakthrough Ideas: The Collaboration of Anthropologists and Designers in the Product Development Industry (2002), Ann Jordan's Business Anthropology (2003), Sarah Pink's Applications of Anthropology (2006), and Brian Moeran's The Business of Ethnography (2005) and Ethnography at Work (2006). Patricia Sunderland and Rita Denny's Doing Anthropology in Consumer Research (2007) is a notable recent contribution to the field. Sunderland and Denny provide a valuable primer for clients and others (among them anthropologists and aspiring practitioners themselves) for gaining a deeper understanding of what cultural analysis is and what it offers (resonating in particular with Martin Ortlieb's contribution in this volume in teasing out notions of culture at play in corporate contexts). By way of description of an awareness-building exercise they use with clients, and more generally throughout the essays and examinations offered in the book, they elegantly demonstrate how the very foundations and approaches of the questions being asked and the understandings being sought in anthropologically informed ethnographic studies differ from those motivated through psychology, the discipline and orientation more well-entrenched in organizational settings.
A larger, longer-standing core of anthropological works, much of it done at the cusp of research and consulting or applied projects, addresses related themes and topics and informs today's practitioner-oriented ethnography in and of industry. These include studies of organizations and workplaces (Aneesh 2006; Baba 1991; Batteau 2000; Dubinskas 1988; Garsten 1994; Hamada 2000; Kunda 1992; Traweek 198...

Table of contents