Fortune and the Cursed
eBook - ePub

Fortune and the Cursed

The Sliding Scale of Time in Mongolian Divination

Katherine Swancutt

Share book
  1. 284 pages
  2. English
  3. ePUB (mobile friendly)
  4. Available on iOS & Android
eBook - ePub

Fortune and the Cursed

The Sliding Scale of Time in Mongolian Divination

Katherine Swancutt

Book details
Book preview
Table of contents
Citations

About This Book

Innovation-making is a classic theme in anthropology that reveals how people fine-tune their ontologies, live in the world and conceive of it as they do. This ethnographic study is an entrance into the world of Buryat Mongol divination, where a group of cursed shamans undertake the 'race against time' to produce innovative remedies that will improve their fallen fortunes at an unconventional pace. Drawing on parallels between social anthropology and chaos theory, the author gives an in-depth account of how Buryat shamans and their notion of fortune operate as 'strange attractors' who propagate the ongoing process of innovation-making. With its view into this long-term 'cursing war' between two shamanic factions in a rural Mongolian district, and the comparative findings on cursing in rural China, this book is a needed resource for anyone with an interest in the anthropology of religion, shamanism, witchcraft and genealogical change.

Frequently asked questions

How do I cancel my subscription?
Simply head over to the account section in settings and click on “Cancel Subscription” - it’s as simple as that. After you cancel, your membership will stay active for the remainder of the time you’ve paid for. Learn more here.
Can/how do I download books?
At the moment all of our mobile-responsive ePub books are available to download via the app. Most of our PDFs are also available to download and we're working on making the final remaining ones downloadable now. Learn more here.
What is the difference between the pricing plans?
Both plans give you full access to the library and all of Perlego’s features. The only differences are the price and subscription period: With the annual plan you’ll save around 30% compared to 12 months on the monthly plan.
What is Perlego?
We are an online textbook subscription service, where you can get access to an entire online library for less than the price of a single book per month. With over 1 million books across 1000+ topics, we’ve got you covered! Learn more here.
Do you support text-to-speech?
Look out for the read-aloud symbol on your next book to see if you can listen to it. The read-aloud tool reads text aloud for you, highlighting the text as it is being read. You can pause it, speed it up and slow it down. Learn more here.
Is Fortune and the Cursed an online PDF/ePUB?
Yes, you can access Fortune and the Cursed by Katherine Swancutt in PDF and/or ePUB format, as well as other popular books in Ciencias sociales & Antropología cultural y social. We have over one million books available in our catalogue for you to explore.

Information

Year
2012
ISBN
9780857454836
image

Chapter 1

A Race Against Time:
Mongolian Fortune and
the Anthropology of Magic

The lunar New Year celebrations of February 2000 marked a turning point for three shamanic households in Bayandun, a Buryat Mongol district in rural northeast Mongolia. After several days of visiting extended relatives and friends for feasts and the exchanging of gifts, Yaruu, the shaman whose household I lived in, became ill. As she relaxed on her bed, she suddenly retracted her limbs tightly against her body (in an illness reflex known as ‘tatasan’) and called out that she was dying from a curse. Her two daughters started crying, and her mother, Ölzii, who had overheard the commotion in an adjacent wing of the house, rushed in to find her daughter writhing on the bed. Immediately, Ölzii instructed Yaruu’s older daughter, Tuyaa, to hand her the shamanic implements. Running these across Yaruu’s limbs, Ölzii tried to remove the curse symptoms with the latent strength (chadal) of the shamanic spirits (ongon). Although she was not a shaman, Ölzii summoned the spirits to intervene, requesting that they descend upon her daughter’s home from their residences in the heavens – residences which are so synonymous with the Buryat shamanic spirits that she repeated them rapidly, as mantra-like invocations, with the formulaic phrase: ‘the fifty-five western heavens, the forty-four eastern heavens’ (‘baruuni tavin tavan tenger; züüni döchiin dörven tenger’). Ölzii’s act of desperation was considered risky. As a layperson, she could have been blinded or struck dead for wielding shamanic implements without the necessary training or connection – roots (ug) – to the spirits. Eventually, though, her actions calmed Yaruu, who, in the following days, divined and held numerous ceremonies with her shamanic pupils. Their divinations confirmed that Yaruu’s group of shaman friends had been cursed by three rival shamanic households in Bayandun. The curses were not entirely surprising, since Yaruu’s group had suspected a growing shamanic rivalry for two full months, during which they had faced persistent business difficulties and illnesses. Originally, Yaruu’s group ascribed these misfortunes to their own blunders of having offended the shamanic spirits with broken taboos and insufficient offerings, but this attack confirmed that their rivals had been cursing them and making their fortunes (khiimor’) decline. So Yaruu’s group started their new year by embarking on a series of counter-curse measures, which lasted for several months until they hit upon an innovative curse-blocking remedy. Some months later I observed a similar but unrelated episode three hundred kilometres to the east, in Shinekhen Baruun Sum, a Buryat district of northeast China, in which a curse victim obtained an innovative remedy for recovering her money losses and raising her fallen fortune.
By a stroke of fortune, during my first fieldwork on Mongolian divination I found case studies on cursing and innovative magical remedies that changed people’s lives. Anthropologists have been captivated with the production of magical innovations since the inception of the discipline, because these innovations cut straight to the heart of the human condition, revealing how people fine-tune their ontologies, live in the world and conceive of it as they do. Looking back now, I realize how pivotal it was for me to have been located precisely where I was, when I was, within specific Buryat episodes of cursing, haunting and innovation-making. Like the witchcraft in the Bocage region of western France described by Jeanne Favret-Saada, Buryat cursing and innovation-making revolves around a ‘system of positions’ or alliances between specific people, in which ‘the first point to grasp is whom each “informant” thinks he is speaking to, since he utters such radically different discourses depending on the position he thinks his interlocutor holds’ (1980, 16–17). Magical innovation is common nowadays among Buryats, especially where there are shamans who regularly provide face-to-face dialogues with the spirits. But these innovations are usually contained within just one or a few households, bringing about small-scale social changes through the covert resolution of local rivalries and family breakups. Thus while the Buryat invention of new magical practices is common enough, information about them is, at least initially, kept secret, allowing the practices to be known only within the households that generate them. Moreover, due to the secrecy and extreme novelty of these remedies, there is no established parlance for them. Buryat innovative remedies may be referred to by the euphemism ‘the thing which the shamanic spirits instructed to be done’ (ongon zaasan khiikh yüm) or by the even vaguer turn of phrase ‘that thing’ (ter yüm). Each of these euphemisms – although not conventional terms – sets innovative remedies conceptually apart from the conventional ‘correcting’ or ‘repairing’ rituals (zasal) that pervade everyday Buryat life. Still, I should underscore that while the phrase ‘innovative remedy’ accurately captures the Buryat propensity for innovation-making, it is my own analytical category, not a Buryat vernacular term.
By tracing the rise of several innovations over a four-year period, I offer penetrating ethnography on cursing rivalries and family crises among Buryats in rural Mongolia and China. I take the reader to the inside of the curse and the households affected by it, showing how curse ‘victims’ initially detected their curse symptoms, how they witnessed the curse castings, how they detected and deflected curses through divinations or shamanic ceremonies and, finally, how they resolved their rivalries with innovative remedies obtained from the spirits. Additionally, I give an account of how, four years later, Ölzii obtained further innovations, which resolved her family crisis, expunging her ex-husband and his vampiric imps from the patriline. Each of these innovations did more than simply add to the existing magical and religious repertoires: they changed the livelihoods of those people who implemented them and protected them within their homes so that their fortunes (khiimor’) would rise in an unconventionally short span of time. These innovations thus altered the time-space dimensions of a rural Buryat district, as well as the relations between victims and their rivals there.
One simple explanation for innovation in places such as rural Mongolia and China, which have undergone recent religious oppressions, is that people are likely to produce new knowledge when they are not working with a repertoire that has been intact for generations. Among Buryats, this new knowledge is most readily accessible in ceremonies where the shaman adopts the perspective of a shamanic spirit and then holds a ‘spirit-human’ dialogue with one or more laypersons, who then may use these dialogues as divinatory sessions for uncovering innovative remedies which could resolve their problems. Both Buryat divinations and spirit-human dialogues are practised on a partly improvisational basis, without the extremely codified elements that anthropologists often associate with shamanic repertoires, such as the recitation of epic myths. Instead, divinations and dialogues only require that Buryats organize their interactions around the purpose of gathering information from the divinatory implements, the spirits, other people and anything else which may pertain to the questions at hand. Not surprisingly, then, these divinations and shamanic dialogues recently appear to have become the central feature of the Buryat religious repertoire in Mongolia and China (Buyandelgeriyn 2007, 130–32, see also 134–42; Højer 2009, 580–86; Shimamura 2002, 92–106; 2004, 203–10), which, in moments of crisis, revolves around the production of innovative magical remedies (Swancutt 2006, 346–50; 2008, 858–61).
Another significant impetus behind Buryat innovation-making is the rhetoric on keeping order, which is espoused at the official and popular levels in Mongolia, China and Russia (see chapter 2, on cosmology). Humphrey has shown that the sense of order which pervades social life in provincial Russia, including in the Buryat Republic, is traceable to the Soviet influence, with its state management of production, as well as the recent forms of trade and protection rackets that have developed since the early 1990s after perestroika (1999, 22, see also 42–43). Significantly, Humphrey’s study highlights the provincial Russian view of trade in the 1990s, where ‘uncontrolled movement violates the sense of order pertaining to bounded wholes’, because ‘Trade brings in desirable goods, but it also carries out valuables’, such that ‘Markets and border crossings are places where “disorder” (bezproyadok) is feared’ (1999, 22). A similar emphasis on order has been prevalent throughout China for centuries, where personal relations and commerce have worked in tandem through different modes of production, such as the ‘tributary’ or ‘petty capitalist’ modes highlighted by Hill Gates (1996, 7–9). More recently, Stephan Feuchtwang has shown that Chinese efforts to promote ‘an economy decollectivized and removed from direct state control’ have effectively exchanged the ‘realm of organized fairness and unfairness’ from the collectivization period for ‘a set of obligations [to the Party-state or state-run units] beyond whose seclusion an ocean of fortune, instrumentality and exploitation – regulated or not – is continuously expanding’ (2002, 202). In this newer milieu, rural Chinese find that ‘beyond human responsiveness is the realm of gain, which comes either through luck (fuqi) or fairness, or through the unfair deployment of personal connections or the amoral skills of instrumental networking’, the positive side of which is that ‘from this amoral economy reserves flow into the more sphere’ (ibid.). Of course, the Buryat ethnic minority living in remote corners of China, who are officially classed as a ‘small nationalities’ (shaoshu minzu) group, make their own permutations on the notions of order espoused by the Chinese state. But the dynamic impact made by the tide of change in Chinese policy is unmistakable, especially among Buryats who link improvements in fortune to the orderly production of innovative magical remedies.
Revealingly, the Buryats with whom I worked have a historical connection to the Buryat Republic in Russia and nostalgically consider it to be their homeland (nutag). The earlier generations lived through periods of collectivization in either Mongolia or China and were thus concerned about their roles in the uncontrolled movement of larger spheres, such as trade. Nonetheless, amid the larger public spaces of fluctuating order, these Buryats seek to produce innovative remedies which combat persistent problems whilst being contained secretly within the private sphere of the home. Indeed, as we will see, their innovative magical remedies afford a hyperorderly means of resolving problems, which is highly desirable because – unlike trade – it is not open to public scrutiny. This preference for order even tallies with Buryat notions about the kind of personality which is suited to the shamanic vocation. According to Ölzii, the most successful ceremonies are held by shamans who are calm people (nomkhon khün), such as her daughter Yaruu, since their orderly demeanour helps them to readily adopt spirit perspectives. Ölzii felt that neither she nor Yaruu’s younger daughter could become shamans, because they became angry (uurlaj baina) easily, whereas Yaruu and her older daughter, Tuyaa, who (according to Ölzii) could become shamans, were calm and suited to the vocation. Ölzii’s explanation corresponds with my observation that Buryat shamans who exhibit the more ‘ecstatic’ performances, in the sense given to the term by Eliade (1964, 182–84) or Lewis (1971, 38–39), such as bombastically beating the drum and singing loudly, usually do so because they find it difficult to take on spirit perspectives. These shamans exert themselves in exhausting performances, and when they fail to adopt the necessary spirit perspectives, they fall short of their own expectations – as well as the expectations of their inquirers.
Against this backdrop of preferred orderliness, Buryats I met in northeast Mongolia often reflected upon the disorder which pervaded their religious life, telling me that because their ancestors had not been allowed to practice openly as shamans during the oppressions, no Buryat shaman nowadays knows entirely what he or she is doing when holding ceremonies. Even those shamans who secretly practised abbreviated rituals during the oppressions were not considered able to have transferred their full knowledge across the generations, once they started practising regularly again, from the 1990s onwards. Many Buryat shamans and laypersons thus felt that much of their religious practices were undertaken in ad hoc procedures, including cases where practitioners referred to written lists used by senior practitioners which specified the proper order for invoking the spirits. Moreover, Buryats often cited their lack of knowledge about past modes of religious practice as the reason why they could not gauge how their current practices are evolving. I received similar accounts when travelling throughout Mongolia from July to November 1999, where every religious specialist I interviewed linked the endemic lack of knowledge to religious oppressions.1
And yet, as this book will show, Buryats in northeast Mongolia and China regularly produce innovative magical remedies in a calm, orderly manner, when carrying out their shamanic or divinatory practices. Buryats use these innovations to organize the apparently ‘unknown’ or ‘disordered’ elements of their cosmologies and social settings. In this sense, Buryat innovation-making sheds significant light on the production of order more generally and falls into step with Roy Wagner’s ‘dialectical approach’ to the invention of culture, where conventions and inventions mutually evolve so as to continuously produce new variations upon each other (1981, xviii). At the same time, Buryat innovation-making echoes the production of hyperorderly results in scientific experiments, which ironically fall under the heading of ‘chaos science’. Anthropologists already have drawn analogies between social phenomena and elements of chaos science, as early as in Wagner’s study of ‘The Fractal Person’ (1991) and more recently within Mosko and Damon’s volume (2005), a work I have borne especially in mind when discussing the tendency for any given Buryat innovation to elicit follow-up innovations. I give only a brief background to the comparison between Buryat magical innovations and chaos science here, since I develop this comparison throughout the book.
Scientific studies actually use the term chaos ‘to refer to deterministic kinds of order – not “disorder” as the term is understood popularly – arising from the generalized properties of complex dynamical systems; or simply, order within apparent disorder’ (Mosko 2005, 7; emphasis in original). Thus while so-called chaos experiments take place under fast-changing conditions that may give the appearance of disorder, those changes, in fact, are hyperorderly responses which can, to some extent, be predicted in advance. One of the trademark features of chaos science is that its experiments involve numerous bifurcations from an original source, which have the effect of rapidly introducing irreversible changes, on multiple levels, into the experimental milieu (Mosko 2005, 11–17). I argue that, in a similar way, Buryats who produce innovations irreversibly alter their social and cosmological settings.
The lack of order, or ‘chaos’, which seems to pervade Buryat life in Mongolia or China could be said, as with any ethnographic setting, to take place on a variety of levels. Among rural Buryats, an everyday indeterminacy about how to obtain basic necessities amid extreme poverty and the scarcity of resources – especially water and cash – is the most notable form of chaos. Moments of crisis are even endemic in Bayandun, where the sudden lack of state subsidies in the 1990s bequeathed a very chaotic means of gathering everyday life provisions. To combat these difficulties Buryats produce innovations which – like chaos-science experiments – alter their lives (and not just a given course of events) by introducing irreversible new starting points from which they can carry out social relations and from which they can increase their fortunes, business prospects, well-being, success and so on. For instance, the magical Buryat innovation that blocks curses and dangerous gossip from the home, discussed at length in this book, does more than simply deflect curses – it offers a fresh platform for resolving the local interpersonal rivalries which initially lead to the cursing. Although never popularized as a conventional correcting ritual, this innovation helped to restore the pre-curse ‘convention’ of good neighbourly relations between Yaruu’s group and their rival shamans – and in this narrower sense I propose that it triggered a dialectical shift, in Wagner’s sense of the term, from invention (blocking curses) back to convention (sociable relations between district residents) ([1975] 1981, 52–53).
I recall being struck by the initial impression that rural Buryats produced innovations with a remarkable efficiency which paralleled the ‘efficiency’ found among some urban businessmen or scientists – or, given the lack of regular electricity and other modern technology in their areas – even could be said to have outstripped them. These similarities between the Buryats and business or scientific efficiency at innovation-making remained apparent to me throughout my fieldwork and, indeed, to some degree, appeared to have been the outcome of seventy years of Socialist indoctrination, as well as the Buryats’ association to the Russians. The Buryats I came to know often devoted their days to obsessively exchanging information about their rivals’ curses, regularly observing their rivals and holding several hours-long divination sessions to confirm or refute speculations about the cursing. In my view, the constant attention these Buryats gave to curses resembled the detailed observations of scientists in lengthy laboratory experiments. Revealingly, Buryats even stressed the importance of following the proper divinatory or soul-loss checking methods when uncovering curses – much in the same way that scientists stress the accurate implementation of their methods – so that they would not distort the divinatory results (see chapters 3 and 5).

Strange attractors: innovative shamans and fortune

If we take the analogy to chaos science further, a parallel arises between Buryat shamans (or other powerful religious practitioners) who produce innovations and the ‘strange attractors’ of chaos theory (Mosko 2005, 18–20). In chaos science...

Table of contents