PART ONE
STRATEGIC
MARKETING
1
Building Profitable Businesses Through World-Class Marketing
There are three kinds of companies: those who make things happen; those who watch things happen; and those who wonder whatâs happened.âAnonymous
If we do not change our direction, we are likely to end up where we are headed.âOld Chinese proverb
AS THE WORLD spins into the next millennium, both citizens and businesses wonder what is ahead. There is not only change, but the rate of change is accelerating. A twelve-year-old girl said of her nine-year-old sister, âShe is of a different generation.â Her younger sister listens to different music, plays different video games, knows different movie stars, has different heroes.
Companies often fail to recognize that their marketplace changes every few years. The book Value Migration documents how customer requirements and competitive forces have changed significantly every few years in such industries as steel, telecommunications, health care, and entertainment.1 Last yearâs winning strategy may become todayâs losing strategy. As someone observed, there are two kinds of companies: those who change and those who disappear.
Todayâs economic landscape is being shaped by two powerful forcesâtechnology and globalization. The technological landscape today is dotted with new products that President John Kennedy in the early 1960s would not have seen, such as satellites, VCRs, camcorders, photocopiers, fax machines, answering machines, digital watches, e-mail, cellular phones, and laptop computers. Technology is the ultimate shaper not only of the material substructure of society but also of human thought patterns. As Marshall McLuhan observed, âThe medium is the message.â2
One revolutionary technological force is digitalization, where information is being encoded in âbits,â namely series of zeros and ones. The bits are massaged by computers, encoded into music and videos, and sent over phone lines at incredible speed. Nicholas Negroponte, leader of MITâs famous Media Lab, sees âbitsâ as replacing âatoms.â3 No longer does a software company need to manufacture a set of floppies, put them into a printed package, and ship them on a truck to various outlets, where consumers would have to go to buy them. All this work can be saved by sending the software over the Internet to be downloaded on the customerâs computer.
Technology drives the second major force, globalization. McLuhanâs vision of a âglobal villageâ is now a reality. A Bangkok executive who wants to buy this book can type âwww.amazon.comâ on his keyboard, enter his credit card number, and receive it in a few days thanks to Federal Express. A Cologne, Germany, florist wholesaler who is short of red roses can order and receive a planeload of red roses the next morning from Tel Aviv.
Besides technology and globalization, other forces are reshaping the economy. Deregulation is occurring in many economies. Protected companies, often monopolies, suddenly confront new competitors. In the United States, long distance telephone companies such as AT&T can now enter local markets; and regional Bell telephone companies have the corresponding right to enter long distance markets. And electrical utilities can now sell and ship their electricity into other communities.
Another strong force is privatization, where former publicly held companies and agencies have been turned over to private ownership and management, in the belief that they would be better managed and more efficient. This happened when British Airways and British Telecom were privatized. Today many public goods and services are being outsourced to private companies, including the building and management of prisons, school systems, and the like.
Yogi Berra, the legendary Yankee catcher, summed it up when he said, âThe future ainât what it used to be.â He might have added: âDo you feel your company is being chased by wild animals. If not, you should!â Markets are pitiless. Jack Welch, chairman of General Electric, would start his management meetings with the admonishment, âChange or die.â Richard Love of Hewlett-Packard observes: âThe pace of change is so rapid that the ability to change has now become a competitive advantage.â The ability to change requires an ability to learn. Peter Senge and others have popularized the notion of a âlearning organization.â4 Not surprisingly, companies such as Coca-Cola, General Electric, and Skandia have appointed vice presidents of knowledge, or learning, or intellectual capital. Those vice presidents have the task of designing knowledge management systems to enable rapid company learning about trends and developments affecting consumers, competitors, distributors, and suppliers.
As the pace of change accelerates, companies can no longer rely on their former business practices to sustain prosperity. Exhibit 1â1 compares business assumptions and practices that were practiced then with the ones being increasingly practiced now. Those in the right column are viewed as more effective contemporary approaches to profitability. Your company can almost tell how much it has adopted contemporary business practices by placing a check in each row on either the left or the right. If most of the checks are on the left, your company is locked in traditional practices.
Are There Winning Marketing Practices?
Besides winning business practices, is there a set of winning marketing practices? One frequently hears of one-liner formulas that promise marketing success. Here are nine of the more prominent one-liners:
1. Win Through Higher Quality
Everyone agrees that poor quality is bad for business. Customers who have been burned with bad quality wonât return and will bad-mouth the company. But what about winning through good quality? There are four problems.
First, quality has a lot of meanings. If an automobile company claims good quality, what does it mean? Do its cars have more starting reliability? Do they accelerate faster? Do the car bodies wear better over time? Customers care about different things, so a quality claim without further definition doesnât mean much.
Second, people often canât tell a productâs quality by looking at it. Consider buying a television receiver. You go into Circuit City and see a hundred different sets with the picture on and the sound blaring. You look at a few popular brands that you favor. The picture quality is similar with most receivers. The casings may differ but hardly tell you anything about the setâs reliability. You donât ask the salesperson to open the back of the set to inspect the quality of the components. In the end, you have at best an image of quality without any evidence.
EXHIBIT 1â1
Business Firms in Transition
Then | Now |
| |
Make everything inside the company | Buy more things outside (outsource) |
Improve on oneâs own | Improve by benchmarking others |
Go it alone | Network with other firms, collaborate |
Operate with functional departments | Manage business processes with multidiscipline teams |
Focus domestically | Focus globally and locally |
Be product-centered | Be market- and customer-centered |
Make a standard product | Make adapted and/or customized products |
Focus on the product | Focus on the value chain |
Practice mass marketing | Practice target marketing |
Find a sustainable competitive advantage | Keep inventing new advantages |
Develop new products slowly and carefully | Speed up the new product development process cycle |
Use many suppliers | Use few suppliers |
Manage from the top | Manage up and down and across |
Operate in the marketplace | Operate also in the marketspace |
Third, most companies are catching up to each other in quality in most markets. When that happens, quality is no longer a determinant of brand choice.
Fourth, some companies are known to have the highest quality, such as Motorola when it touts its 6 sigma quality. But are there enough customers who need that quality level and will pay for it? And what were Motorolaâs costs of getting to 6 sigma quality? It is possible that getting to the highest quality level costs too much.
2. Win Through Better Service
We all want good service. But customers define it in different ways. Take service in a restaurant. Some customers would like the waiter to appear quickly, take the order accurately, and deliver the food soon. Other customers would feel that this is rushing them on what otherwise should be a leisurely evening out. Every service breaks down into a list of attributes: speed, cordiality, knowledge, problem-solving, and so on. Each person places different weights at different times in different contexts on each of the service attributes. Claiming better service isnât enough.
3. Win Through Lower Prices
A low price strategy has worked for a number of companies, including the worldâs largest furniture retailer, IKEA; the worldâs largest general merchandise retailer, Wal-Mart; and one of Americaâs most profitable airlines, Southwest. Yet low-price leaders must be careful. A lower-price firm might suddenly enter the market. Sears practiced low prices for years, until Wal-Mart beat it on prices. Low price alone is not enough to build a viable business enterprise. The Yugo automobile was low in price; it was also lowest in quality and disappeared. A measure of quality and service must also be present, so that customers feel they are buying on value, not price alone.
4. Win Through High Market Share
Generally speaking, market share leaders make more money than their lamer competitors. They enjoy scale economies and higher brand recognition. There is a âbandwagon effect,â and first-time buyers have more confidence in choosing the companyâs products. But many high market share leaders are not that profitable. A & P was Americaâs largest supermarket chain for many years and yet made pathetic profits. Consider the condition of such giant companies as IBM, Sears, and General Motors in the 1980s, a time when they were doing more poorly than many of their smaller competitors.
5. Win Through...