Part I
The theory
Chapter 1
Understanding value
Most people are interested in what their home is worth, and the topic of making money via residential housing is a popular one to discuss. As opposed to other forms of investment (for example, shares or term deposits), housing provides the rare opportunity of also living in your investment. It also gives you some control over how much you can sell for, with any improvement that you make often being reflected in a higher sale price. Property gives you a high degree of control over your destiny.
There are other reasons for the hype about property value. Housing in some form or another affects everyone every day of their lives. Most people sleep somewhere for around eight hours every night, which requires the use of a safe and sheltered location for a preferably uninterrupted period. Think for a moment about how much time you spend inside your home â although it varies from person to person, usually most of your life is spent inside your dwelling. And like most things in life, there is a cost attached to having this level of access and exclusivity.
Depending on your current situation, you will have a particular level of interest in your home. A propertyâs value can be viewed from the perspective of:
- a homeowner who has a long-term mortgage and wants to feel like they are âgetting aheadâ financially. This is often achieved when the value of their home rises and their loan value decreases.
- a renter or tenant who is hoping to eventually leave the rental market and buy a home, and therefore needs to keep abreast of the current cost of housing in order to save a sufficient deposit.
- a homeowner who owns their property outright and may be looking to relocate.
- a family that has reduced in size because the children have grown up and left home â the parents now have an âempty nestâ and would like to downsize.
- a younger family that may expand in size in future and therefore need to âupsizeâ their property to a larger home with extra bedrooms.
Clearly, each of the households briefly described above has a vested interest in the future value of their current home. They need to know what it is worth and how to increase its value. People rarely stay in their home forever â eventually most properties are sold and the asset is converted into a cash amount.
It is obvious then that this fascination with real-estate values is linked to the sale or transfer of property over both the short term and the long term. Every household is on a different part of a life cycle with varying degrees of urgency in regards to house-selling â some would like to sell tomorrow while others are looking towards selling in a few years time. And of course, everyone would rather sell their property for more rather than less, if given the choice.
Another of the main attractions of property is the ability to decrease how much tax you pay. In order to provide an incentive for households to buy their own home (and therefore not rent when entering retirement), homeownership is promoted by the government as a low-tax environment. Under normal circumstances, your principal place of residence (PPR) is 100 per cent exempt from capital gains tax (CGT), so you donât have to pay tax on any profit you make after selling the property. This is different to what happens if you buy and sell shares, where tax must be paid on any profit you make when they are sold (after deducting costs). In some regions there are other concessions for residential property, such as lower stamp duty (payable on purchase) if you are an owner-occupier, and the possibility of receiving money through the governmentâs First Home Owner Grant (FHOG).
Another attraction of residential property is that the family home, which is most often in the form of a detached house, townhouse or unit, has a flexible level of tenure (use). This advantage allows its use to be easily converted from owner-occupier use to a rental property, or vice versa.
Other people are interested in housing values because they would like to increase their investment in their home as an indirect form of superannuation, or because they want to provide a secure, safe and happy environment for their household to grow up in. Many people arenât out for the money all the time â they just want to feel like they are âgetting aheadâ and living a comfortable lifestyle.
The value of your home is affected by a practically endless list of factors; sustainability is just one of the variables. Before trying to understand the relationship between sustainability and housing values, we need to have a better understanding of some of the theories that affect property. Housing can be thought of as a good that is traded between buyers and sellers, just like any other good or service. However, there are many special considerations that affect house prices.
While a detailed discussion of economic theory is beyond the scope of this book, a basic understanding of the economy can help you to grasp the complexities of the sustainable housing market. Remember, though, that property is subject, at times, to other influences, for example legal restrictions such as zoning and heritage controls.
Property value
It is important to understand what property value actually is and what it means to different people. The term âproperty valueâ refers to how much a parcel of real estate (usually including an improvement such as a building or a house) is considered to be worth today if sold.
The concept of value is complex, and many people are confused with what it actually means. This is partly due to the many different types of value that exist in relation to property, including:
- for sale value. This can sometimes be negotiated lower depending on how firm the seller is on their asking price.
- special value. A type of value that is unique to someone and usually much higher than the normal value, for example the special value of a particular good such as a high-profile sustainable house. Also, âspecial valueâ refers to the value of a parcel of land to an adjoining owner.
- insurance value. The amount of money required to restore property back to its original state in the event of destruction (for example, by fire), including clean-up costs.
- future value. How much something should be worth in the future (based on todayâs present value currency), due to the combined effect of inflation and risk.
When discussing property markets with reference to value or money, there are three main areas for consideration: price, cost and value.
The focus of this book is on value (with relation to sustainability), but we need to distinguish between these three terms, which are often confused with each other. Letâs look at each term in further detail.
What is price?
âPriceâ refers to the sale or transaction price of a good, and implies an exchange. Remember that the âpriceâ of a good may or may not equal to its âworthâ in the open market â this is an important concept when thinking about a sustainable home. For example, if a household has purchased a good (for example, a house), the amount that it sold for (its âworthâ to that household) may or may not represent the price the majority of people would pay for it. Just because you paid a certain amount doesnât mean it is worth that much to sell. Therefore a particular property may only relate to a certain purchaser and they may have special reasons for paying that price.
What is cost?
Before we can work out what your home is worth and how to improve its value, letâs look at what âcostâ means. The term âcostâ is often confused with price, although they have two different meanings.
The term âcostâ actually refers to the phase to which it is related, such as the new cost. When we are talking about residential property, this can be either:
- the actual construction costs; that is, the direct cost of labour and building materials, plus indirect costs such as taxes
- the overall development cost; that is, all the costs involved in creating a property (including purchasing the land), and bringing it into an efficient operating state.
Due to their actual cost, many new buildings do not proceed because they would cost too much to build in comparison to what they would be worth after they are finished. For example, if a new house and land cost $600 000 before construction but when completed was then worth $500000, it would not be economically viable. This is one of the reasons why most cities have vacant parcels of land or disused buildings â because the land owner has weighed up the âcostâ of a new building and found it does not add up to how much the open market would pay for the finished product. Note that there is a distinct gap between âcostâ and âworthâ, which applies to a proposed renovation of a sustainable property as well as new construction. If you undertake a renovation it may cost more that you could sell the house for â therefore the renovation may not be a good idea over the long-term from a financial cost-benefit perspective.
Remember that at other times when the sums do add up (that is, the financial benefit exceeds the financial costs), the construction will commence and the land is no longer vacant. In these cases the cost of the completed building will have âadded valueâ to the original property, plus some profit if the developer (or homeowner) is seeking to make money. This example shows that, simply because a good or service actually âcostsâ a certain amount to purchase, it doesnât mean it is actually worth that much after it is completed. This is an important concept when considering spending money on your home to make it more sustainable, if the emphasis is placed on increasing its value. It is important to strike the balance between the cost of being more sustainable and what the actual value of the property is.
What is value?
The term âvalueâ means different things to different people, depending largely on context and usage. Think of the saying âone manâs trash is another manâs treasureâ â this illustrates that the âvalueâ of a good can differ from person to person or from household to household. Imagine the type of property a larger family (say with five children) would value as opposed to a single-person household. In this example, the larger household would value the larger property more because of their need for extra accommodation space.
Now letâs look at how the property professionals use the term âvalueâ when talking about your property. The concept of value is relatively broad and there are many different types of value, therefore it is vital to make sure from the beginning that there is agreement about what type of value is being assessed. The most common form for sustainable housing is âmarket valueâ, which the Australian Property Institute (API) defines as âthe estimated amount for which a property should exchange on the date of valuation between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an armâs length transaction after proper marketing wherein the parties had each acted knowledgably, prudently and without compulsionâ. Market value is assessed by undertaking a valuation, such as by a property valuer who is a member of the API or the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS). This process is what you do if you wanted to sell your house or take on a mortgage to buy a house.
The concept of value is not an exact science. The market might place a value of $500 000 on a house today, but $490 000 tomorrow. Another person might put a value of $510 000 on that same house today and $515 000 tomorrow. This often frustrates someone who seeks to understand and make clear sense of the property market. The same goes for sustainable items: water tanks may add value to a house in one area but not add value to a house in another area, and water tanks are more valuable when there are water restrictions than when there are not.
Added value
The best way to think about the decision to spend money on your home is to think about the amount of âadded valueâ your spending will bring. For each potential addition it is recommended that you determine what the actual added value to your home will be. To do this accurately (or as accurately as possible!), you need to assess the value of your property pre- and post-improvement.
Letâs look at water tanks as an example. The added value of a water tank would normally be greater if a house has no water tanks, than if a house already has, say, four water tanks. There reaches a point where every extra water tank actually lowers the value of the property; this is commonly termed âover-capitalisationâ. Imagine the value of a property with 20 water tanks: you would have too much land given over to water tank sto...