PART ONE
Periods and Movements
1
Italian Silent Film
Antonio Costa
For a long time in Italy, little was done to deepen and spread the knowledge of silent film. Italians have neglected to set a serious policy for the recovery, conservation, and restoration of the film heritage from that era. In general, film critics seem more focused on interpretive issues, discussing, say, how Giovanni Pastrone’s Cabiria (1914) influenced D. W. Griffith’s Intolerance (1916). And while much has been written on how neorealism was anticipated by such works as Nino Martoglio’s Sperduti nel buio (Lost in the Dark, 1914) or Gustavo Serena’s Assunta Spina (1915), the original copies of those films have been lost. Fortunately, the situation has changed in recent decades. Film libraries and major festivals have done great recovery work on lost or forgotten films, or on films that are now close to disappearing.1 The possibility of viewing under optimal conditions many works that had long fallen out of historical memory now enables us to revisit long-held critical clichés. The bibliography on Italian silent film has become truly impressive, and at the same time there are various editions of silent films on restored versions in DVD format.
1 The Invention of Italian Cinema
Italian cinema was born in Rome, one evening in the late summer of 1905. On September 20, the thirty-fifth anniversary of the Breach of Porta Pia, the military capture of Rome and a decisive event in the decadelong process of Italian unification known as the Risorgimento. Filoteo Alberini, cofounder and artistic director of the Primo Stabilimento di Manifattura Cinematografica Alberini and Santoni, had the idea of projecting his first film, La presa di Roma (The Capture of Rome), on a large screen set up at the site where soldiers had entered the Papal State, forcing Pope Pius IX to surrender.2 In the very place where the final event of the Risorgimento took place, the film commemorating it was shown. Cinema, which was then still considered a vaudeville sideshow, thus evolved into an instrument capable of capturing an episode that had produced lacerations in the social conscience. Although the Porta Pia breach evoked “memories of an outrage” for the church, for the Italian state it was “a sign of victory.”3 Italian cinema was born, therefore, as a public event that called into question historical memory, social conscience, and opposing passions that were lived in a collective dimension, in the “public square.”4
Many of the hallmarks of Italian cinema, which would gather momentum over time, were present in this inaugural event, from its technical means of production to its mix of public ritual, scenic installation, and publicity stunt. In the wake of this “media event” that the historian Aldo Bernardini (Cinema muto, 26) defined as the true masterpiece of Alberini, his production company realized that they were on to something. The following year, thanks to new financial contributions, the company became a joint stock venture called Cines, destined to become one of the most prestigious and enduring brands in the history of Italian cinema. But at the time it was only one of several production companies of the nascent film industry.
2 The Production System
What we can call polycentrism was a characteristic feature of Italian filmmaking in the era of silent film. Unlike what would happen with the centralizing policy of Fascism, which culminated in the creation of Cinecittà in 1937, the Italian film industry’s origins were shaped by the presence of several production centers located in various cities, even small ones, in a kind of productive federalism. This situation would attenuate, if not disappear altogether, in the 1930s. But before then, many cities of differing cultural and economic characteristics contributed to the growth of Italian film: Turin, Naples, Milan, and naturally Rome, but also such smaller urban centers as Genoa and Catania. Yet at the same time this disjointed polycentrism was also a weakness of the Italian economy because of the fragmented nature of the investments held by a myriad of small companies with limited business skills. In the beginning of the century, it was actually Turin, and not Rome, that had the largest film production center, which was aided by the entrepreneurial activism of a city that also developed the first Italian car industry. Fiat was created in Turin in 1899, and its rapid growth would soon intertwine with the rising fortunes of the city’s film industry. If Turin achieved its international success through large, spectacular films that reached their apex with Cabiria in 1914, Naples rose to prominence as a film center with strong regionalist and “vernacular” traits.5 Naples was also the home of Gustavo Lombardo, future founder of the important production company Titanus.6 Cultured and progressive, Lombardo developed a coherent promotion policy for cinema through his magazine Lux and distributed films such as Dante’s Inferno (1911) as well as Futurist works including Vita futurista (Futurist Lifestyle, 1916) by Arnaldo Ginna (now lost) and Thaïs (1917) by Anton Giulio Bragaglia.
3 Birth of the Feature Film and the Epic-historical Genre
The first Italian feature film was Dante’s Inferno, produced by Milano Films and directed by Adolfo Padovan, Francesco Bertolini, and Giuseppe de Liguoro. It was inspired by the first canticle of Dante’s Divine Comedy and had a decisive impact on the artistic and industrial development of Italian cinema. At the very moment it started to undertake complex and challenging productions, the early film industry turned to Dante’s text, a work that was surrounded like no other by an aura of prestige and classicism, while also being deeply rooted in the popular imagination. In the film version of Dante’s Inferno, Italian cinema found an original way to access the themes and iconography of the fantasy genre, imbuing it with a unique civil and political dimension. Dante’s Inferno, which premiered at the Teatro Mercadante in Naples on the fiftieth anniversary of the proclamation of the Kingdom of Italy (1861–1911)—and which was projected in the presence of such prestigious intellectuals as Benedetto Croce and Matilde Serao—ended with an image of the monument to Dante in the city of Trento, then still under Austrian rule. This evocation of Dante’s universe acquired a great political significance: the screening took place on the eve of the outbreak of the First World War, at the end of which would come the annexation of Trento and Trieste to Italy.7
Though it broke away from current productions, Dante’s Inferno had some affinity with the historical costume genre. From Gli ultimi giorni di Pompei (The Last Days of Pompeii), directed by Luigi Maggi in 1908 for Ambrosio Film of Turin and based on the novel by E. G. Bulwer-Lytton, Italian cinema achieved great success abroad, reaching its peak with Cabiria. Other titles that contributed to the great fortune of the epic-historical genre include: L’Odissea (The Odyssey, 1911), Giuseppe de Liguoro’s adaptation of the Homeric epic (Milano Films); La Gerusalemme liberata (Jerusalem Delivered, 1911), a Cines production by Enrico Guazzoni, who also directed Quo vadis? (1913) based on the eponymous novel by Henryk Sienkiewicz; and La caduta di Troia (The Fall of Troy, 1911), an Itala Film production also by Pastrone.
There are various reasons for the good fortune and strategic importance of this popular genre in the development of Italian film. The genre had its roots in a past rife with historical, artistic, and literary riches, traces of which are still evident in the Italian cultural landscape today. The increasing length of films made cinema competitive with the more established media of theater and opera. Moreover, early cinema’s iconographic references, literary sources, and artistic ambitions attracted a large middle- and upper-class audience, which had originally rejected the supposed lowbrow of film spectacle. Filmgoers were seduced by the magnificent scenic innovations, accuracy of the productions, and technical innovations of the historical cinematic blockbusters. Among these films, the most important techniques were the expressive use of light and the systematic use of camera movements that enhanced the impressive scenery and crowd scenes, and which also gave the sequences a rhythmic and spatial organization. Such were the extraordinary artistic and spectacular results of Cabiria, for example, that the film exerted great influence in the United States in scenes like the Babylonian episode of Intolerance by D. W. Griffith in 1916.
In Italy, the epic-historical genre was a rather composite phenomenon. On the one hand, it brought together literary aspects that were exploited with entrepreneurial flair, drawing on the success of a very popular narrative genre. But the epic-historical film also contained an educational and pedagogical intent, as it reflected the basic classics of the Italian school curriculum. So the cinematic historical blockbuster became a kind of experimental laboratory as well as a lucrative cultural product for mass consumption, which undoubtedly explains the involvement of the poet Gabriele D’Annunzio in the making of Cabiria.
4 D’Annunzio and Pirandello
The presence of the larger-tha...