CHAPTER ONE âOne of Himmlerâs Most Brutal and Most Ruthless Henchmenâ
âYou said your father was morally compromised. Where do you think he first went wrong?â
âImpossible to say, donât you think?â
âinterview of Jörg Kammler
âIâm thrilled to report I met with Jörg,â my email to Keith and Colm began. âI thought he was going to shut me out, but he didnât. We talked for over an hour. More to follow.â
I was on the return train from OsnabrĂŒck, Germany, home of Jörg Kammler, son of SS general Hans Kammlerâthe man Nazi armaments minister Albert Speer had called a âmost brutal and most ruthless henchmanâ to SS chief Heinrich Himmler.1 I had just interviewed Jörg and was headed back to the Radisson Blu Hotel in Hamburg, my base of operations in Germany, which was two hours away. After sending the quick email to my colleagues, I began to furiously type a summary of the extraordinary encounter that had just concluded while all the details were still fresh in my mind. I would share my full notes with Keith Chester and Colm Lowery later. Before I could get three sentences into my summary, though, my computer chimed with an incoming email.
âWell done. Youâve played it just right, obviously. Canât wait for the details.â It was Colm, emailing me from his home in Northern Ireland. Before I finished reading Colmâs email, I heard another chimeâthis time an email from Keith: âOMG! Youâre killing it!â Then another insistent chime, again from Keith, âTELL US!!â I spent the next two hours writing up the interviewâafter turning off the notifications on my laptop so I could work in peace.
That morning I had walked to the Hamburg train station, just steps from my hotel, to travel to OsnabrĂŒck, which is southwest of Bremen. After having purchased a round-trip ticket at the kiosk, I found myself alone on the platform. I had come to the station not knowing the schedule, and the next train was twenty-five minutes out. I waited. I admit to being on my heels. I hadnât been in Germany since I was a young child and it felt, well, foreign. I was also planning to show up at Jörg Kammlerâs home unannouncedâan uncharacteristic move for me, as I tend to be risk-averse. This could be a giant waste of time, or even lead to some sort of ugly confrontation, walking in on the surviving child of a Nazi madman. I had just one shot at interviewing him, so I did everything I could to be prepared. It was nerve-racking carrying my own high expectations and the hopes of my colleagues with me.
Sitting on a bench on the platform, oblivious to those around me, I reviewed what I knew, switching back and forth between a fistful of papers and information logged on my laptop. I was relying on a combined thirty years of research handed over to me by my colleaguesâwith a couple years of my own spare time thrown in.
âSome of the most heroic and dastardly acts in human reckoning occurred during the war,â Colm, our historian, had reminded me when I first got involved in this venture. âAt its end, the geopolitical world had been reshaped, new superpowers had emerged, millions of people had perished, and tens of millions more people were maimed, or homeless, or refugees. Over the course of six years, almost everyone on the globe had their life changed, if not devastated, in some very personal and important way.â
I have always been perplexed by itâthe whole world turned upside down when one of the most highly civilized cultures known to man went screamingly off the rails. All of this is recorded by historians and widely understood. But within this colossal landscape, one man is largely unknown to history, despite his war crimes: SS general Hans Kammler, the target of our investigation. Kammler had avoided scrutiny, apparently because of his death at the end of the war. But we had turned up evidence that Kammler was alive after the date of his supposed suicideâand that American authorities were involved in the cover-up.
Kammlerâs character is as irresistible to me as it is loathsome. He became a remarkably powerful man in the Nazi hierarchy, playing a central role in some of the most violent and despicable parts of the Holocaust, ultimately ruling over Germanyâs slave labor trade and its ultra-secret weapons programs. Documents compiled by Keith and Colm tell tales of Kammlerâs deeds that are, frankly, so horrific that they are hard to absorb. Kammlerâs rank, ObergruppenfĂŒhrer, was the highest possible commissioned rank in the SS. From 1942 to 1944, an extremely select group of just seventy-five Nazis was elevated to that honor. And one man alone achieved that distinction in the final year of the war: Hans Kammler. To me, that was striking.
These were my thoughts on the platform, even as the crowd grew around meâa mixture of locals and tourists, I thought. Much of our information on Kammlerâs early years and career came from original documents, but some of it was from Kammlerâs descendants. Colm had been in touch with various Kammler family members and associates for years, and they had been able to provide useful information, helping paint a full picture of this mysterious man. As the primary author of our book project, I was eager to meet Jörg, Hans Kammlerâs son; I felt I had an obligation to hear his story before we published.
I was momentarily distracted as an eastbound train entered the station, idled for a moment, and then carried on, leaving the platform on the far side of the tracks empty of people. I had already been in touch with Jörg by email, introduced by Colm, but he had shown no interest in meeting me. So I had decided to roll the dice and show up unannounced. Jörg could provide a unique angle on his father, but I was also interested in his own story. I had read riveting accounts of the surviving children of infamous Nazis, always wondering how they dealt with the sins of their father, and I admit to some morbid curiosity: What was it like to grow up with a surname like Eichmann, Höss, or Himmler? I was lost in thought when my train pulled into the station. This was my point of no return, I thought, as I boarded and found a seat. It was only a two-hour ride, and I spent most of it with my head buried in documents, furiously scrawling questions I thought I should ask, organizing and reorganizing. I was sitting across the aisle from a young family who broke out an authentic German picnic of pickled fish, potato dishes, and some sort of slaw. The only difference from what I might have been expecting was that they werenât costumed in Sound of Music garb, but were dressed just like I was. They spoke quietly among themselves as I continued my work, the children well-behaved, smiling at me when I looked up. I felt a little âwatched,â or at least pegged as an outsider, and wondered what they were saying with their quiet voices. I wasnât quite myself; I knew that from the way I couldnât help asking myself questions about this innocent family. Every person I had met or even seen in Germanyâfrom the hotel clerk, to the waiter, to the train staff and passengersâI had unfairly dropped into my war paradigm: Who were they? Did their fathers fight in the war? Were their ancestors Nazis? SS? Are they sympathizers? I was making everyone a suspect. Could it be that I was too far down the World War II rabbit hole? I needed to settle down.
Then, perhaps from nerves, I waffled a bit, changing plans midstream, using the trainâs Wi-Fi to send Jörg an email, though I had planned on arriving completely unannounced. Before I had more time to agonize, we pulled into the station. I exchanged pleasant nods with the German family as I disembarked. They were traveling on. I caught a cab outside the station, amazed to see so many Mercedes taxis. The driver wouldnât take U.S. dollars, but he would take a credit card. This was the point of no return, I thought, entering the cabâand realized that this was my second self-identified point of no return!
Without the constant distraction of my materials, which I had stowed away, I found myself getting ever more anxious in the cab as I made the final approach to the home of Kammlerâs son. This was becoming real: the man I was going to accost was the offspring of a genuine Nazi sociopath. It would be an extraordinary opportunity to meet him, even a privilege to get that close to history. If I could.
Thinking I might have the door slammed in my face or that Jörg, who hadnât responded to my email, might not even be home, I asked the cab driver to wait. The house was a modest two-story in the inner suburbs on a lot that couldnât have been more than a quarter acre and was overgrown with bushes and foliage to the extent that I couldnât see the door from the curb. As I approached, I realized the address was one half of a small duplex. Coming up the walk, I saw a woman in the picture window, felt as if I was stepping out of civilization, and regretted not having left a trail of bread crumbs. I admit that I may have looked over my shoulder to confirm the cab was staying. I had a momentary concern that I might never be heard from again. What was I thinking?
I rang the bell on the side door, the main entrance, and waited for what seemed like too long. The woman I had seen in the window, in her sixties or seventies, answered the door, and I identified myself, telling her that I had been in touch with Jörg and had him sent an email that I was nearby and hoping to chatâtrying to minimize the intrusion. She disappeared, closing the door firmly behind her. I waited on the doorstep. She returned and asked me for my name again, then disappeared again after holding up one fingerâwhich could mean, please wait one moment, or possibly, I only need one reason not to let you in. She was gone a long time, and I realized she didnât even need the one reason not to let me in; she just didnât have to come back. But she did reappear, and cautiously bade me enter. I asked for one minute to dismiss the cab. Back at the curb, I paid the driver and got my overnight bag (I was prepared to spend the night locally, if need be). When I turned around, the woman was right behind me, giving me a start. Like a ghost.
âOn second thought, my husband canât see you. Heâs ill. Too ill.â Her English was good. Her thin arms crossed in front of her. âToo ill,â she repeated. So this was Mrs. Kammler. âYou must go.â
âCan I just see him? Just a question or two? Iâve come all the way from the United States. Can I just say âHelloâ?â This was totally out of character for me. As a lawyer, I can be insistent on behalf of a client, to the point of being a perfect ass. Advocating for myself, I do less well.
But I suppose in this moment I thought of myself as representing Keith and Colm. I became insistent. âIâve come a long way. Just a minute or two, a question or two,â I repeated. Then I waited.
âFor a minute or two,â she relented, her arms still crossed.
We went back up the walk and then into the kitchen where, with a silent tilt of her head, without breaking stride or looking back at me, Mrs. Kammler indicated I could leave my bag. I confirmed that Jörg wasnât well when I saw him lying atop a hospital bed, side rails up, in the darkened parlor, which had been converted to an in-home hospital room. It was very warm and permeated with a heavy, sour odor I could not identify. Jörg had had a stroke, but he was able to sit up without raising the back of the bed, and to speak clearlyâEnglish with a heavy German accent.
I said I was sorry to disturb him and thanked him for seeing me, âespecially after I had come so far,â I emphasized. âIâm sorry you didnât see my email.â Or I may have said âemails,â making it sound as if I had given him multiple warnings of my arrival.
The house was simple but functionalâaustere, with the well-worn look of a lived-in home. Not a stick of new furniture in the place. When Colm told me, much later, that surviving Nazis had stashed stolen money and valuables away in preparation for a planned-for Fourth Reich, I recalled this scene and thought, The hidden money didnât reach the second generation.
Mrs. Kammler brought in a straight-back chair from the kitchen for me and positioned it at the foot of the bed, at an odd distance, too far away. I scooched a foot or two closer as I sat down. She may have noticed. She sat in an armchair, to my right, now further from Jörg than I was, a bit outside our conversation. After introductions, Jörg seemed much more at ease and open than his wife, who repeatedly interrupted his responses and once or twice spoke to him sharply in German. When I was sure Jörg was about to consent to recording our conversation, she quickly said, âNo.â
âNo recordingââa short statement, punctuated by a single arched eyebrow. She repeatedly tried to call the interview to a close along the way. Again, it was unlike me, but I essentially subtly ignored her, asking âJust one more questionâ several timesâmoving forward in my chair as if I were about to rise, or just sitting mum for what seemed like too long (an old investigatorâs trick) until Jörg, unable to bear the prolonged silence, began speaking again. It was positively exhilarating, like back in my government days when I was interviewing someone suspected of embezzling or outright theft. Not that Jörg or his wife had done anything remotely improper, I just saw him as a challengeâquarry, even. I thought Mrs. Kammler might be trying to protect the reputation of Hans Kammler, the family patriarch, but then wondered whether Jörg might want to publish his own book, so that she didnât want him to share any of his exclusive information with me, at least not without something in return. In my summary later to Keith and Colm, I said, âI wonder whether his wife, and not Jörg, had been responding to all my emails over the past several months. Perhaps Jörg knew about me for the first time when I walked into his parlor. She was definitely the gatekeeper.â
I had a long list of questions, carefully sequenced, that I had planned to put to Jörg. But given the tension his wife created, I decided to rely on my memory. I have done interviews of all sorts over my career, but this one was differentâan absolute rush. It felt as if I were sitting with a living relic, a talking piece of history, a true unvarnished (if not unbiased) original source. It was as if I was able to reach out and touch history directlyâlike holding tattered, musty documents, but being able to pose questions and expect and receive answers. Oh, how I wished it were just the two of us in the room.
To begin, Jörg confirmed for me that his father, Hans Friedrich Karl Franz Kammler, was born the son of Franz and Marie Kammler on August 26, 1901, in Stettin, in what is now northwest Polandâless than a two-hour drive from Berlin. Stettin, more a city than a town, was a major seaport at the time of Kammlerâs birth with a population of just over two hundred thousand. All but a small handful of its citizens were Protestants, with fewer than 5 percent Catholics and Jews. Hans Kammler had the good fortune to be born into the majority.
âYour grandparentsâ choice of name for your father is interesting: Hans Friedrich Karl Franz Kammler. Franz obviously follows from your grandfatherâs name. Does the âFriedrich Karlâ refer to Karl Friedrich Schinkel, the famous German architect?â
âNo,â Jörg said firmly and quickly, as if he had anticipated the question, âthat is a mere coincidence.â He seemed mildly offended by the question, though I donât know why. No one but Colm could have been so thoroughly immersed in our materials as to catch this possible Kammler-Schinkel connection. Schinkelâs most noteworthy buildings, found in Berlin, were created in the early 1800s. He had also famously been commissioned by Frederick William III of Prussia to design the original Iron Crossâevoking the cross borne by the Teutonic Knights of the fourteenth century. Created in 1813, Schinkelâs Iron Cross was adopted as the symbol of the German army from 1871 to early 1918, then reintroduced in 1939 with a Swastika in the center. Issued in two grades, First Class and Second Class, the Iron Cross was awarded for bravery in battle. Hans Kammler would distinguish himself by earning both.
âYour fatherâs earliest years are something of a mystery to us,â I said next, âa problem for us in our book.â
âUnfortunately, I have no personal memories of my father.â Jörg was himself born in February 1940, so he was just five years old when the war ended and his father vanished. âTimes were certainly hard growing up without a father. The hardest part for the Kammler family,â Jörg said, almost as if he werenât a member, âwas not knowing whether or not your father was dead. It was truly a mystery. There were many rumors that the Americans had him, that the Russians had him.â I knew Jörg was speaking of rumors of then, not now. For more than seventy years the world has believed that Kammler died at the end of the war.
âWe constantly sought out soldiers and other people returning from America or Russia to get information. Other people came to us and said he was alive.â It sounded to me as if the Kammler family had sought and received information on his fate well beyond the 1948 adjudication of his deathâindicatin...