Free Speech, The People's Darling Privilege

Struggles for Freedom of Expression in American History

Michael Kent Curtis, Neal Devins, Mark A. Graber, Neal Devins, Mark A. Graber

• Publisher: Duke University Press Books
• Year: 2000
• Print ISBN: 9780822325291
• eBook ISBN: 9780822381068
• Topic: History
• Subtopic: North American History
• Index: History

Modern ideas about the protection of free speech in the United States did not originate in twentieth-century Supreme Court cases, as many have thought. Free Speech, "The People's Darling Privilege" refutes this misconception by examining popular struggles for free speech that stretch back through American history. Michael Kent Curtis focuses on struggles in which ordinary and extraordinary people, men and women, black and white, demanded and fought for freedom of speech during the period from 1791—when the Bill of Rights and its First Amendment bound only the federal government to protect free expression—to 1868, when the Fourteenth Amendment sought to extend this mandate to the states. A review chapter is also included to bring the story up to date.
Curtis analyzes three crucial political struggles: the controversy that surrounded the 1798 Sedition Act, which raised the question of whether criticism of elected officials would be protected speech; the battle against slavery, which raised the question of whether Americans would be free to criticize a great moral, social, and political evil; and the controversy over anti-war speech during the Civil War. Many speech issues raised by these controversies were ultimately decided outside the judicial arena—in Congress, in state legislatures, and, perhaps most importantly, in public discussion and debate. Curtis maintains that modern proposals for changing free speech doctrine can usefully be examined in the light of this often ignored history. This broader history shows the crucial effect that politicians, activists, ordinary citizens—and later the courts—have had on the American understanding of free speech.
Filling a gap in legal history, this enlightening, richly researched historical investigation will be valuable for students and scholars of law, U.S. history, and political science, as well as for general readers interested in civil liberties and free speech.

Table of contents

• Contents
• Acknowledgments
• Introduction
• 1 The English and Colonial Background
• 2 The Debate over the Sedition Act of 1798
• 3 Sedition in the Courts: Enforcement and Its Aftermath
• 4 Sedition: Reflections and Transitions
• 5 The Declaration, the Constitution, Slavery, and Abolition
• 6 Shall Abolitionists Be Silenced?
• 7 Congress Confronts the Abolitionists: The Post Office and Petitions
• 8 The Demand for Northern Legal Action Against Abolitionists
• 9 Legal Theories of Suppression and the Defense of Free Speech
• 10 Elijah Lovejoy:Mobs, Free Speech, and the Privileges of American Citizens
• 11 After Lovejoy: Transformations
• 12 The Free Speech Battle over Helper’s Impending Crisis
• 13 DanielWorth: The Struggle for Free Speech in NorthCarolina on the Eve of the Civil War
• 14 The Struggle for Free Speech in the Civil War:Lincoln and Vallandigham
• 15 The Free Speech Tradition Confronts the War Power
• 16 A New Birth of Freedom? The Fourteenth Amendment and the First Amendment
• 17 Where Are They Now? A Very Quick Review of Suppression Theories in the Twentieth Century
• Conclusion
• Notes
• Index