Des W. Connell
II. Historical Development of Knowledge on Absorption, Bioaccumulation and Related Effects of Xenobiotic Compounds
The basis of our understanding of bioaccumulation was developed by scientists working in the 1870's who discovered some of the principal phenomena governing the behavior of chemicals in gases, water, and other phases. Some of these principles are now used in contemporary investigations of the behavior of chemicals in the environment and in organisms. For example, Berthelot and Jungfleisch2 in 1872, and Nernst3 in 1891, discovered that a constant partition coefficient, or “distribution ratio”, controlled the partitioning of a single pure chemical between two different phases. This knowledge marks an important step forward, since once the partition coefficient is known for a compound, its distribution between the same phases in other situations can then be calculated. The bioaccumulation of a chemical by an organism can be seen, in many situations, as a partition process.
During this early time period, interest was not only developing in aspects of chemical behavior, but also in the behavior of drugs, poisons, and narcotics in organisms. Thus, during this pioneering period, others were building on the basic physicochemical knowledge available, and utilizing this in attempting to elucidate the factors governing the physiological properties of chemical compounds. Probably the earliest among these were Crum-Brown and Fraser,4,4,3 who in 1868-1869 proposed that the physiological action of a compound was a function of its chemical constitution. Later in 1893, this found practical expression in the work of Richet,6 who found that the toxic effects of certain ethers, alcohols, aldehydes, and ketones were inversely related to their solubility in water.
A few years later, interest was first kindled in the partition behavior of nonelectrolyte chemicals in relation to their physiological effects on organisms. The English born and Swiss-trained Charles Ernest Overton commenced his research program into the relationship of physicochemical properties of compounds to their narcotic effect on organisms virtually single-handedly. Also about this time, Hans Meyer and his collaborator Fritz Baum were active in the same field. A series of papers7,8,9 were published by these gifted researchers culminating in 1901 with the publication of Overton's book, Studien Uber Die Narkose10 (Studies of Narcosis). This book is a landmark in studies of how physicochemical properties of chemicals influence their physiological effects on organisms. It sets out many of the basic principles which have been continually refined and expanded up to the present day.
One of the major discoveries of these researchers was that the narcotic action of a nonelectrolyte is correlated with the compound's lipoid substance-to-water partition coefficient. Overton's studies were carried out with 130 compounds including alcohols, hydrocarbons, nitriles, nitroparaffins, aldehydes, and ketones, and with a variety of test animals including tadpoles, fish, Crustacea, and Daphnia.
In 1904, Traube11 extended the physicochemical properties of interest from the partition coefficient to surface tension when he established a linear relationship between surface tension and activity for a series of narcotics. Aspects of structural organic chemistry were introduced by Fuhner,12,13 who noted a possible relationship between narcotic activity and the number of carbon atoms in a compound.
A considerable volume of data was accumulated in the following years, confirming the general accuracy of the previously developed relationships. However, during the 1950s and 1960s further significant refinements and developments occurred. Hansen and Leo,14 together with a variety of co-workers, suggested the use of the octanol to water partition coefficient (Kow) as the most suitable partitioning phase pair for studying the relationship between partition coefficient and the biological properties of compounds. They systematized much of the information available into quantitative structure activity relationships (QSAR).
Initially, this group developed the following equation for toxicity:
where C is the molar concentration of a compound producing a standard response in a constant interval; k1 k2, and k3 are empirical constants; ir is log Px — log PH, where Px is the octanol-to-water partition coefficient of a derivative and PH is that of a parent molecule; and σ is the Hammett constant.
When k2 is equal to zero, this equation is equivalent to the Meyer-Overton relationship, which predicts a linear relationship between log(l/C) and the octanol to water partition coefficient. When k2 has an empirical value, the Hammett constant is included in the relationship and provides a much better correlation for many compounds with toxicity than the Meyer-Overton relationship mentioned above. It is noteworthy that the relationship between the Hammett constants alone and toxicity is not particularly strong. Later, this linear relationship was developed by Hansch15 into a parabolic form expressed by the following equation:
where kow is the octanol to water partition coefficient and k1, k2, k3 and k4 empirically developed constants. This relationship has been extensively and successfully used to explain the toxicity of a variety of compounds.
Up to the period of these developments, studies of the uptake and behavior of xenobiotic chemicals in organisms was principally concerned with relatively short-term effects, such as toxicity and narcosis. The applications were mainly concerned with pharmaceuticals and their effectiveness in relationship to human health. In the 1960s widespread concern developed regarding the use of persistent chemicals in the environment. Much of this related to the chlorinated hydrocarbons, particularly DDT. These substances tend to have little effect in the short term, but trace residues bioaccumulated within organisms over long periods have had adverse effects, in many cases. As a result of this, there was a developing interest in the presence of persistent chemical residues in organisms, and the routes and mechanisms of entry of these substances. Accumulation through steps in the ecological food chain, with progressive increases in concentration, was initially proposed as the mechanism of entry for many organisms. With terrestrial ecosystems the presence of contaminants in food must be the principle source of residues in organisms. However, in aquatic ecosystems water to organism partitioning has been found to be a significant influence on the presence of residues in organisms within the system. In principle, it could be expected that the biological response of bioaccumulation with environmental xenobiotic compounds would be related to the factors generating the biological response observed with pharmaceutical xenobiotic compounds such as drugs, narcotics, and so on. Thus, it could be expected that the bioaccumulation of environmental xenobiotics would be related in some way to the octanol-to-water partition coefficient of the compounds involved.
The general characteristics of the interaction of xenobiotic chemicals with organisms can be seen in simplifie...