p.1
1
A CUT ABOVE
Itâs all about the âlittleâ things!
In This Chapter
B-Roll: A Subtle Difference
A Directorâs Command
The Power of Subtlety and Nuance
B-ROLL: A SUBTLE DIFFERENCE
Quite a few years ago, when I was working as a new director for a large company, I was given a challenging project that included a significant budget. It was a program on the subject of quality that was to be shown to thousands of employees. Since the development and production schedule were tight, while I concentrated on shooting the program host and primary material, I hired a videographer to travel to various company locations and shoot B-roll footage for me. I hadnât worked with this person before, but he came highly recommended by a good friend.
To be sure I was perfectly clear with him about what I wanted, including the types of focal lengths and angles I preferred, I created a fairly detailed shot list, complete with a few simple drawings, and we sat down to discuss it over coffee. He seemed comfortable with what I was after, and very professional. Though he was displaying all the right signals, I was somewhat anxious, simply because I knew how important the program was, and to some degree I was relinquishing directorial control to a stranger.
p.2
A few days later, when I had a chance to look at the footage he had shot, I noticed something immediately. For some reason it looked better than most of the B-roll footage I was used to getting from other camera operators. At first I wasnât sure exactly what it was about the footage that made it look so pleasing and professional. But soon I began to notice subtleties. First, I realized he had shot a good deal of footage (in this case mostly trucks moving on highways and airplanes taking off, landing and taxiing on runways) using long focal lengths. While most operators I knew would almost certainly have gotten in as close as possible to the subjects, he chose to shoot some of the footage from a distance, while keeping a tight, steady frame. This had the effect of âsquashingâ the foreground and background, giving the overall image a pleasing, almost film look which, in those days was the Holy Grail for those of us in video production. I also noticed that some of the angles he had chosen were not typical. Some were lowâat ground level, and others were high. He had also shot some segments with the camera slightly tilted as possible alternates of the shots I had asked for. So when the trucks and planes moved past, toward and away from the camera, as observers we were either looking up at them or slightly down, and at times slightly off kilterâagain, resulting in fresh, interesting perspectives. It occurred to me that the combination of these subtleties made for some very nice-looking footage that added a noticeably professional look to my program.
A DIRECTORâS COMMAND
Another experience shortly after this reinforced my belief that subtle techniques could have a significant effect. In this case, it was a seasoned, highly respected director I had the good fortune of working with. Watching him audition, cast, set up and direct a series of short vignettes became a wonderfully instructional experience for me.
p.3
One thing I noticed quickly was that he always seemed calm and courteous. Though at times I knew there were significant pressures on himâin one case an extreme time crunchâyou would never have known it. I watched him converse comfortably with his videographer, crew and actors and move with a kind of subtle command through each scene. As I watched him work, I realized that when directing, I was not often so composed. I also noticed that he worked with actors in a subtly understated and collaborative way instead of being âdictatorialâ (as I often was in those early days). In one case, when I could see that he was not getting the performance he wanted from an actor, he approached her and said, âIâm not really sure about this one, Anna. I guess we need to both feel clear on what weâre after. How do you see this interaction?â He and the actor then had a discussion about the motivation driving the scene and this led to a suggested change in how the actor delivered it. Instead of playing it âbig,â the actor toned down her delivery and I could see this version was much more to the directorâs likingâand a more sincere, credible performance. After a rehearsal in front of the camera the director smiled and said, âGreat! I think thatâs it. You good with it?â
âIt feels right on,â the actor said, beaming with satisfaction.
âGood. Then letâs get this one on tape.â
BREAKOUT 1.1Â Â âTHE EXCITABLE DIRECTORâ
I taught a producing and directing workshop for a number of years and was privileged to work with talented students from all over the world. In our week-long classes, each of my students would get a two-page script to direct. We had an excellent group of actors in residence, good equipment and plenty of crew members (the other students in the class).
I remember one young man in particular with an excitable personality. Prior to his turn, we discussed his scene, how and why he had cast and blocked it as he had, what kind of performance he was after and any questions he might have had. I noticed as we talked that he was dying to show his stuff, and when he finally did start directing, he was nearly manic with excitement. He hurried from one spot to another, instructing the camera operator, prepping the actor, discussing sound with the boom operator, eyeballing his master shot and just generally landing all over the set in a kind of whirlwind of positive movement.
p.4
Though his energy was upbeat and confident, I could see it was irritating a few of the other crew membersâand the actor. As the crew began working on some lighting adjustments, I quietly pulled him aside and said, âEverything looks good. How are you feeling about the scene?â
âGreat!â he said. âItâs going to be Dynamite!â
âGood,â I said, âBut do me a favor and remember something. One of your jobs as a director is to set the tone and pace. Everything you do and say emanates to the crew and your actor, and I think you may want to show them a bit more of a composed temperament. We can all see youâre pumped and very positive about the scene, and thatâs great. But try bringing the excitement down a notch. I think it will pay off for you in terms of the actorâs focus and performance and gaining the respect of the crew.â
He took my advice and the crew and actor followed suit. The scene played well and although I could see that he was close to bursting at the seams with pride, he projected a composed, professional tone and earned a good deal of respect from the group.
THE POWER OF SUBTLETY AND NUANCE
Over a period of quite a few years and hundreds of experiences like these, Iâve become more and more attuned to the idea that these kinds of subtle nuances can have a great impact on a writerâs, directorâs or producerâs work. Iâve also noticed that as powerful as they may be, these subtleties usually have a few interesting characteristics. In many cases, they are simple techniques instead of what some might expect to be creative ârocket science,â and they are often overlooked. I believe this is at least partly due to the fact that the production process, especially for those new to the field, is often glamorized, with a good deal of attention focused on the technical and hardware aspects of the business. For many newcomers itâs all about the cameras, the lights, the dollies or Steadicams. Itâs about shooting on location where passers-by stop to look for celebrities and ask if itâs a commercial or a sitcom youâre working on. Or itâs about some new special effect in postproduction thatâs âReally, incredible, man!â
p.5
Those who decide to make writing, directing or producing a career and who invest a good deal of time and elbow grease into that aspiration, find that the real âmagicâ comes not through flash or technical wizardry, but as a product of plain old hard work and the less-than-glamorous skill sets we will explore in this book.
And with that, letâs get to it.
p.6
2
SENSIBILITIES
âCan you feel the love?â
In This Chapter
Empathy: The Key Ingredient
Other Influences
I hate to admit it but I often tear up in sad movies. My wife calls me the Kleenex King because I never fail to ask her for a tissue (or three) if there is a poignant birth scene, a heart-wrenching war movie, anything having to do with harming animals or just general emotionally charged situations.
Why? Iâve been told Iâm a sensitive person. Good? Bad? Iâd say some of both. Empathizing and being considerate of othersâ feelings are both very important to me, and somehow, it seems, imprinted on my genes. Dealing with people who show a lack of consideration is one of my pet peeves. If I hold a door open for someone at a store and they walk past me without acknowledging my gesture of thoughtfulness, or at least offering a simple nod of thanks, I become irritated. If I get what I consider polite, thoughtful service from a person helping me, (often in a telephone service conversation) I make it a point to ask if I can offer kudos to his or her supervisor. And though Iâm hardly wealthy, I usually tip generously when someone goes out of their way to offer good service.
p.7
EMPATHY: THE KEY INGREDIENT
You could say I empathize to a fault, often trying to sense how the people I encounter are feeling and thinking, and why. Many times my intuitions about them are correct, but sometimes not. In any case, the bottom line is this: For better or worse, Iâm one of those people who cares about how others feel.
I tell you this not to gain your sympathy, pity or admiration, but to make what I believe is a very important point about the creative process:
If you have an empathetic understanding of, say, how a person who continually breaks the rules and regulations thinks and feels, the performance of a talented actor playing this type of role in one of your programs will almost certainly be ârealâ and convincing. And that ârealityâ will have come about as a result of two interdependent elements: the actorâs talent and your empathetic sensibilities.
I once worked with a director who seemed to have no sense of empathy whatsoever. He was very terse, at times even rude, and often gave his actors directions like âNo. You start here and end here.â Or, âI need more pace on this. Letâs move it along.â I canât say that I actually saw him lose work or have to deal with actorsâ rebellions. I do know, however, that his sets and shoot locations often seemed tense and his dictatorial manner left little room for exploring other options in performances that might have benefitted him and his projects. On the other hand, I have seen directors work in very collaborative ways and when channeled properly (a skill we will discuss shortly), not only do they often seem to get better results, their crews and actors are typically more content and motivated to go the extra mile for them.
When you apply the idea that sensibilities affect performances, it makes perfect sense. When you write a scene about a seasoned truck driver who gets ticked off when he is disciplined by his boss, the writing will most likely ring true and audience members will identify with it. Why? Because youâve been able to empathize with that driver and sense why he might be saying to himself, âIâve been on the road for all these years and youâve been behind a desk. Now youâre going to tell me how to drive? Give me a break!â
p.8
If an on-camera host in one of your programs is talking to your viewing audience about safety on the job of a telephone installer who frequently climbs poles and crawls into attics, your sense of what it might be like to do that work will influence the way you direct the host and what he might say.
Now this is not to say that you have to be a cry-baby to be a good director, producer or writer. You may not have shed a tear in years. Regardless of how you react to your sensibilities, whether it be emotionally or perhaps with more self-control than I can sometimes muster, the fact that those sensibilities are a part of your makeup, I believe, has an influence on your creative decision-making. And if Iâm right on that, what should it mean to you as a creative person reading this book? I think two things: