The Guyana Court of Appeal
eBook - ePub

The Guyana Court of Appeal

  1. 234 pages
  2. English
  3. ePUB (mobile friendly)
  4. Available on iOS & Android
eBook - ePub

The Guyana Court of Appeal

About this book

This book is one of the few studies of how the rule of law has fared in a developing country since it achieved independence.

CHAPTER 1
THE ROLE OF THE GUYANA COURT OF APPEAL

INTRODUCTION

Guyana has been independent since 1966 and by the turn of the century the Guyana Court of Appeal had three and a half decades of experience. As the highest court in the land, the Guyana Court of Appeal outranks in importance any other constitutional institution. In the final analysis the liberties and rights of Guyanese are in its hands. If necessary, the court must be willing to uphold the Constitution even against Parliament itself. For the future of Guyana, therefore, the Court of Appeal warrants the closest study. This chapter will offer an initial assessment of the court. Such an assessment is important not only for the legal history of the country, but might also help pave the way for the eventual entry onto the scene of a Caribbean Court of Appeal.

The role of the courts

The role of the highest court of any country is especially important. The role of the highest court of a developing country takes on added significance. The court must help steer the country towards a path of development grounded in democracy, the rule of law and respect for human rights. The role of the highest court in a multi-ethnic country is even more crucial still; for it is the court that must help stitch together the national fabric with the threads of the rule of law and respect for human rights.
In today’s world the first responsibility of a judge is to seek to uphold constitutionally and legally guaranteed human rights, guided by the internationally proclaimed human rights norms. A judge should know, apply and promote international human rights norms. A judge, in the words of the famous Indian Chief Justice, Mr Justice Bhagwati, should seek to ‘fashion new tools’, to ‘invent new strategies’ and to ‘develop a human rights jurisprudence’ bringing human rights within the reach of the citizen.1 A judge should always be independent and impartial, and refuse to submit to any form of political pressure.
Law in a free and moral society, according to Lord Justice Sedley, is concerned centrally with the abuse of power wherever it resides. Justice is a process of principled negotiation of interests through law on the basis of constitutionally and legally guaranteed human rights grounded in international norms.2 International laws and, in particular, human rights jurisprudence can greatly assist domestic courts in interpreting a Bill of Rights or human rights provisions in a constitution. It can also help expand the scope of a Bill of Rights, making it more meaningful and effective. Judges should adopt a generous and purposive approach in interpreting a Bill of Rights. This is particularly important in countries which are in the process of building democratic traditions.3 Judges have a vital part to play in developing and maintaining a vibrant human rights environment.

Post-independence justice in Guyana

At a welcoming ceremony for the Chancellor of the Guyana Court of Appeal on 2 May 1984, the then President of the Guyana Bar Association, Mr Miles Fitzpatrick, told the court: The task of the courts in Guyana is to establish a jurisprudence that responds to the needs of our people and our times and in so doing to recognize the ascendancy of none but the law.’ ‘The courts’, he added, ‘have a long way to go in carrying out this task’. He warned the assembled judges, lawyers, diplomats and guests of the need for continuity of the law:
However revolutionary and progressive the changes may be, if we lose sight of the basic verities of the common law, we would cast ourselves adrift on the rocks of dictatorship and intolerance…We can either go forward to a new flowering of the law, where the courts cast their protective cloak over the ordinary citizen, upholding his fundamental rights against ever-increasing encroachment by an ever more powerful authority, or we can go backwards, to an authoritarian system, in which the power and interests of the establishment take precedence over the freedom, integrity and welfare of the underprivileged citizen.4
The President of the Bar Association was addressing a chancellor of the judiciary who would later resign his position to move across to the political arm of government and become its principal legal adviser as Attorney General. The incoming chancellor was succeeding one who, as Chancellor, had addressed the Bar on 28 October 1981 in the following terms:
In Guyana the rule of law is very necessary so as to provide the right environment for socialist orientation and nation building, which are the dominant preoccupations of Parliament and the Government of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana. The judiciary is now a necessary and integral part of the political, economic and social system, and the judiciary must look upon itself as having a crucial role to play in this task by ensuring that in the all-important field of socialist development, basic values like the rule of the law and, consequently, justice, are to be maintained. This is, without any doubt, one of the most important of the judiciary’s functions in contemporary Guyana.
He added:
The high point of the present day arrangement is that while he maintains his judicial independent conscience, the Guyanese judge works in cooperation with the administration for the advancement of socialism.5
The peaks and valleys of the Guyanese courts led an eminent Guyanese scholar, Professor Clive Thomas, to submit to the Constitutional Reform Commission of the Parliament of Guyana in 1996:
The past three decades have been littered with breaches in, and the erosion of, the rights of the citizens of Guyana, as they are traditionally recognized in democracies. The courts have played no small role in this unfortunate situation, despite the catalogue of entrenched fundamental rights in the 1980 Constitution, which were carried over from the original Independence Constitution. The provision of ‘exceptions’ to these rights under the 1980 Constitution have also helped to pave the way for this outcome. Emergency legislation has been invoked without the prior declaration of a State of Emergency and has been used as a weapon clearly aimed at regime survival as distinct from protection of the State against serious security threats. The National Assembly has also failed to make any noticeable progress in the provision of court practice and procedures, for the enforcement of fundamental rights. These matters, essential to the fundamental rights of all citizens, should receive a clear delineation in the new Constitution.6
This harsh but fair judgment would need to be kept in mind in any assessment of the Guyana Court of Appeal. There is surely much that can be said that would be critical of the court and of the judiciary in Guyana. The purpose of critical assessment of the court should, however, in our view, be to draw lessons with a view to strengthening judicial independence in the future and to build upon the positive aspects of the work of the court in helping to set in place a jurisprudence inspired by the highest standards of national and international human rights law. The rest of this chapter will seek to distill some of the key doctrines of the Guyana Court of Appeal that might represent the juristic philosophy of the country and provide the basis for a strengthened judiciary of the future.

The position of the Court of Appeal under the 1980 Constitution

As a preliminary comment, it should be noted that the 1980 Constitution is widely acknowledged to have been brought in by a government that took power in massively fraudulent elections. The Constitution itself was approved in a referendum also widely acknowledged to have been a massive fraud. The architect of the Constitution during this process was Dr M Shahabuddeen, who was later elected to the International Court of Justice.
Chapter IX of the 1980 Constitution of Guyana provides for a Supreme Court of Judicature consisting of a Court of Appeal and a High Court, with such jurisdiction and powers as are conferred on them by the Constitution or any other law.7 Each of these courts is a superior court of record. The Judges of the Court of Appeal are the Chancellor, who is President, the Chief Justice and such number of Justices of Appeal as may be prescribed by Parliament. The Chancellor and the Chief Justice are appointed by the President acting after consultation with the ‘Minority Leader’. Judges other than the Chancellor and the Chief Justice are appointed by the President acting in accordance with the advice of the Judicial Service Commission.
In the closing months of 2000 a controversy arose over the role of the President in appointing judges to the Court of Appeal and whether it was mandatory for the President to follow the letter of the advice of the Judicial Service Commission. The facts are that at a meeting held on 1 September 2000, the Judicial Service Commission decided to recommend three persons to act as Justices of Appeal. The Commission further recommended that a fourth judge be appointed a Justice of Appeal after she had given decision in an election petition, the hearing of which had been completed. Following her appointment, the first three judges should be confirmed. The aim of the Commission was to preserve the seniority of the judge whose decision in the election petition was pending. Instead of proceeding as the Commission recommended, the President proceeded to appoint all four persons as Justices of Appeal. Members of the legal profession and the Guyana Bar Association contended that the President was bound to accept all of the recommendations of the Commission. If he had reasons to do so he should have referred their advice back to the Commission for reconsideration. Thereafter the President would be bound by the advice tendered by the Judicial Service Commission. On this view the four judges were improperly appointed.
The issue gave rise to protests by the Guyana Bar Association. Reportedly the Guyana Bar Association wrote to the Judicial Service Commission asking for clarification of the advice tendered to the President. The subject was much debated in the local media and was the focus of a public conference by the Guyana Bar Association. At that conference Senior Counsel strongly advocated more stringent rules to ensure judicial independence.8
Article 130 of the Constitution provides that Parliament may make provisions for the exercise of the jurisdiction and powers of a Justice of Appeal by such puisne judge as may be requested by the Chancellor to sit as an additional Justice of Appeal at sittings of the Court of Appeal.9 Parliament may also make provision for the exercise of the jurisdiction and powers of a puisne judge by such Justices of Appeal as may be requested by the Chancellor to sit as an additional puisne judge.
Under Art 133 of the Constitution, an appeal to the Court of Appeal lies as of right from decisions of the High Court in the following cases:
(a) final decisions in any civil or criminal proceedings on questions as to the interpretation of the Constitution; and
(b) final decisions given in exercise of the jurisdiction conferred on the High Court by Art 153 of the Constitution, which relates to the enforcement of fundamental rights and freedoms.10
Article 153 of the Constitution provides that if any person alleges that any of the provisions of Arts 138 to 151 has been, is being, or is likely to be contravened in relation to him (or, in the case of a person who is detained, if any other person alleges such a contravention in relation to the detained person), then, without prejudice to any other action with respect to the same matter which is lawfully available, that person (or that other person) may apply to the High Court for redress. The High Court has original jurisdiction to hear and determine any application made by any person in pursuance of this competence. It may make such orders, issue such writs and give such directions as it may consider appropriate for the purpose of enforcing or securing the enforcement of any provisions of Arts 138 to 151. However, the High Court may not exercise its powers under this paragraph if it is satisfied that adequate means of redress are or have been available to the person concerned under any other law.
If in any proceedings in any court subordinate to the High Court any question arises as to the contravention of any of the provisions of Arts 138–51 (inclusive), the person presiding in that court is required to refer the question to the High Court unless, in his or her opinion, the raising of the question is merely frivolous or vexatious. Where any question ...

Table of contents

  1. COVER PAGE
  2. TITLE PAGE
  3. COPYRIGHT PAGE
  4. PREFACE
  5. INTRODUCTION
  6. THE CHALLENGES
  7. THE GUYANA COURT OF APPEAL
  8. SELECTED DECISIONS OF THE COURT OF APPEAL
  9. TABLE OF CASES
  10. CHAPTER 1: THE ROLE OF THE GUYANA COURT OF APPEAL
  11. CHAPTER 2: THE LEGAL PROFESSION
  12. CHAPTER 3: THE RULE OF LAW
  13. CHAPTER 4: FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS
  14. CHAPTER 5: SOURCES OF LAW
  15. CHAPTER 6: CRIMINAL LAW
  16. CHAPTER 7: LAW OF TORTS
  17. CHAPTER 8: LAW OF CONTRACTS
  18. CHAPTER 9: PROPERTY LAW
  19. CHAPTER 10: CONCLUSION
  20. BIBLIOGRAPHY

Trusted by 375,005 students

Access to over 1.5 million titles for a fair monthly price.

Study more efficiently using our study tools.

Information

Edition
1
Year
2013
Topic
Law
Print ISBN
9781859416860
Subtopic
Courts
eBook ISBN
9781135338398
Index
Law

Frequently asked questions

Yes, you can cancel anytime from the Subscription tab in your account settings on the Perlego website. Your subscription will stay active until the end of your current billing period. Learn how to cancel your subscription
No, books cannot be downloaded as external files, such as PDFs, for use outside of Perlego. However, you can download books within the Perlego app for offline reading on mobile or tablet. Learn how to download books offline
Perlego offers two plans: Essential and Complete
  • Essential is ideal for learners and professionals who enjoy exploring a wide range of subjects. Access the Essential Library with 800,000+ trusted titles and best-sellers across business, personal growth, and the humanities. Includes unlimited reading time and Standard Read Aloud voice.
  • Complete: Perfect for advanced learners and researchers needing full, unrestricted access. Unlock 1.5M+ books across hundreds of subjects, including academic and specialized titles. The Complete Plan also includes advanced features like Premium Read Aloud and Research Assistant.
Both plans are available with monthly, semester, or annual billing cycles.
We are an online textbook subscription service, where you can get access to an entire online library for less than the price of a single book per month. With over 1.5 million books across 990+ topics, we’ve got you covered! Learn about our mission
Look out for the read-aloud symbol on your next book to see if you can listen to it. The read-aloud tool reads text aloud for you, highlighting the text as it is being read. You can pause it, speed it up and slow it down. Learn more about Read Aloud
Yes! You can use the Perlego app on both iOS and Android devices to read anytime, anywhere — even offline. Perfect for commutes or when you’re on the go.
Please note we cannot support devices running on iOS 13 and Android 7 or earlier. Learn more about using the app
Yes, you can access The Guyana Court of Appeal by Bertrand Ramcharan in PDF and/or ePUB format, as well as other popular books in Law & Courts. We have over 1.5 million books available in our catalogue for you to explore.