1
What types of young mathematical learners do we want?
I think that we need more bricks. Hundreds and hundreds to go up to the sky.
—Nursery child recreating the Three Little Pigs’ house outdoors
There is an increasing focus on the potential for more outdoor play experiences for children at a time when many may have limited access and possibly more restricted learning indoors. With greater awareness of the importance of young children’s health and well-being, the outdoor environment has had recent increased focus on its potential for children’s overall development (Bilton, 2010). The Characteristics of Effective Learning in the Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS) Statutory Framework in England (2012), Building the Ambition: National Practice Guidance on Early Learning and Childcare, Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Scottish Government, 2014), the revised Foundation Stage in Wales (2008) and Northern Ireland Curriculum (CCEA, 2006) clearly identify the importance of young children’s learning on the need for play-based learning, exploration, building resilience, being active and engaged in the learning process, making decisions, making connections, thinking skills and creativity. All of these skills and dispositions are central to developing young children as mathematical thinkers and learners.
In addition, there has been wide-ranging exemplification within national guidance documentation and linked website pages to support practitioners in their practice. Getting It Right for Play: The Power of Play – An Evidence Base (2012) commissioned by Play Scotland discusses how children’s play patterns in the outdoors have changed over time as many play spaces for children have become restricted. This document sets out the power of play in the outdoors for children’s overall development. At a national level, Play Scotland is supporting play for all children and young people as part of the wider Scottish Government’s Play Strategy. Similarly, the national charity Learning through Landscapes in England, Wales and Northern Ireland (Grounds for Learning) in Scotland supports schools and settings to enrich childhood by improving outdoor spaces. Its paper on core values for high quality outdoor experiences for young children identifies ten key features further explored in White et al. (2011). Each of these vision and value statements could also be clearly linked to the mathematical potential in the outdoors.
There also still remains a widespread culture of fear of maths at the adult level, and this has provided even more focus on the need to develop growth mindsets in young children. We know that they will learn best when they are happy, secure and can learn through play where there are no mistakes. How many of us may still have a fear of our own learning in maths – scared to try, unsure of what to do and quite a negative attitude which can remain with us for a long time? Boaler (2015) reminds us that we can’t know what mathematics our children will need in the future but that the best preparation is to develop their mathematical ideas and help them to think in a flexible way, promoting problem solving and creativity.
The perception that it is OK to be ‘no good at maths’ and the many negative attitudes to maths in society are being increasingly challenged. The All Party Parliamentary Group for Maths and Numeracy (2016) identifies the difficulties for many parents to engage in mathematical experiences in the home due to embedded attitudes. The groups’ paper on Maths and Numeracy in the Early Years concurs with the need to ‘raise the profile of maths and encourage the development of mathematical thinking in young children.’ It highlights the need to incorporate play into maths and the development of more concrete experiences for young children, especially in developing counting skills and a deeper understanding by practitioners in this key skill of number sense. In Scotland, one of the key areas for change comes from the Making Maths Count Group (2016) and focuses on transforming public attitudes to maths and in creating greater enthusiasm for maths as a vital life skill.
Based on our own experiences, it is also true that we can often focus on quite a narrow view of maths in our observations of children’s play and can jump in too quickly with a question that we consider to be appropriate, e.g. ‘How many is that?’ when the child is not even considering the abstract nature of counting or whether it has a purpose in the nature of their play situation. We tend to see the maths curriculum as separate aspects, i.e. counting, shape, pattern, measure and information handling, but to the young child it is all learning. So in planning to meet their needs, we have to understand the links and connections in early mathematics, which will in turn help children to develop key skills and the confidence to apply their new-found knowledge and skills in different contexts. Central to developing our young learners is their motivation as mathematical thinkers, talkers and recorders – all of which will be necessary as the foundation of later learning in mathematics. Pound (2008) reminds us of the importance of these key aspects which will be further explored in Chapter 3. There is also a sense of maths being a boring subject and not in the least creative. On the contrary, Devlin (2000) argues that maths is full of creativity and about life. In thinking of maths only in terms of a worksheet or task to be completed, we risk gaining a full understanding of what children already know about the world and lose the possibilities to make ‘the invisible visible’ (Devlin, 2000) through quality interactions and appreciating this part of childhood as a time in its own right.
I spent a wonderful session with some 4-and-a-half-year-olds who had just started school, talking about what they knew about numbers, where they could find numbers and what numbers were for. Each child brought something different to these questions as they talked about their ages ‘I’m 4 and will be bigger when I’m 5, but my brother is bigger still and he’s 8’; numbers on buses ‘I go on the number 45 ’; and ‘I like big numbers. They’ve lots of zeros’ . It brought me back to my firm belief that children have rich previous experiences upon which to build, but the most effective memories that children create are those that are truly embedded in their play with experiences in number, shape, measure and sorting and embedded in their own contexts to give real meaning. I am also more conscious of using the term ‘experiences’ rather than ‘activities’. Influenced by Moyles (2013) and Building the Ambition (Scottish Government, 2014), experiences have a more qualitative feel for child-led learning, with deeper thinking involved than activity which may still be rich in learning but has the possibility of being highly planned with a very definite outcome in mind.
I have asked staff and students about the types of young mathematical learner we want to develop on many occasions, and their very varied responses are listed in Table 1.1.
In then asking about how young children learn best and develop a sound mathematical awareness, the following comments have been made, as shown in Table 1.2.
Table 1.1 What types of young mathematical learners do we want?
| • Confident, engaged, focused |
| • Eager, motivated, enthusiastic |
| • Curious, investigative, inquisitive |
| • 'Have-a-go' attitude, resilient, tries different ways to solve a problem, risk taker |
| • Likes and seeks out challenges |
| • Open to suggestions |
| • Imaginative, creative |
| • Communicative, wants to talk about their learning |
| • Thinks things through, plans, predicts |
| • Sees real purposes for sorting, counting, measuring in contexts that make sense |
| • At times independent, but also cooperative and collaborative |
Table 1.2 How do young children learn best and develop a sound mathematical awareness?
| • By being actively engaged in their learning |
| • In rich play experiences |
| • Using open-ended resources which help them think differently |
| • Making choices and decisions about what they need |
| • With problems and challenges that are meaningful and playful to them |
| • Communicating in different ways ' sometimes talking and reflecting; representing their ideas through mark making; sometimes revisiting their ideas |
| • By watching others and sharing ideas |
| • Getting a feel for numbers in their own way |
| • Starting with child-led ideas which are followed through by responsive adults |
The outdoor environment should complement the mathematical learning occurring indoors, have equal value and offer mathematical opportunities which can’t be:
- achieved indoors, e.g. due to restriction in size and scope of materials. This would include the use of construction with large crates and pallets, experiences that will take up an extended space, water and sand investigations which extend beyond one indoor water tray to enable exploration of longer tubing and linking builders’ trays or connecting to a hose pipe. Learning mathematically outdoors will also enhance the experiences of real seasonal change and the understanding of time, which can be more limited in scope through pictures indoors. If early mathematical awareness requires children to make links, where can it be done more effectively than in this context?
- achieved in the same way, e.g. selection of loose parts for creative investigations, sorting with different resources in different ways, measuring for different purpose...