1 This Writing Business
Featured poems
Writerâs Block by Helen White
The Water Poem by Nicholas Shannon
Writerâs Workshop by Michaela Morgan
Everyone Can Be a Writer by Mike Jubb
Instructions for Growing Poetry by Tony Mitton
Swimming in a Sea of Words by Jane Clarke
Canât Think! by Olivia van Zwanenberg
Words by Robert Louis Stevenson
âBut Eeyore was saying to himself, âThis writing business. Pencils and what-not. Over-rated, if you ask me. Silly stuff. Nothing in it.ââ (A. A. Milne)
Well, thatâs one view of writing, but the following one is nearer the truth:
âWriting is easy; all you do is sit staring at a blank sheet of paper until the drops of blood form on your forehead.â (Gene Fowler)
Writerâs Block by Helen White (p. 34) pretty well sums up the frustration of wanting to be creative, and yet not quite being able to ⌠and Olivia van Zwanenberg certainly had the problem identified at the age of ten, judging by her poem Canât Think! (p. 40).
The Water Poem by Nicholas Shannon (p. 35) aged 13 (now pushing 30, at the time of this edition!), is a remarkably mature piece that captures the familiar struggles, witnessed by teachers, of a class of children suffering the devilish pains of trying to write creatively. Iâm going to take a closer look at this poem at the end of the chapter but, for now, Iâd like to draw your attention to the insightful line, âoutside a locked larder of ideasâ, and to the equally telling (and sad) observation that âMost just try to fill the pageâ. This kid knew what he was talking about!
The aim of this chapter is to make a start on the unlocking of that larder in children and, hopefully, you the teacher/writer. Michaela Morganâs Writerâs Workshop (p. 36) rejoices in some of the tools and ingredients that can be used to cook up a poem, once the larder is unlocked.
But first, as Jane Clarke writes in Swimming in a Sea of Words (p. 39) you have to take the plunge. Paddling in the shallows, by which she means thinking too much, just gives you a headache. You need to âdive straight into the sea of wordsâ; take a risk; go for it; get something down on paper as quickly as possible. Once youâve done that, you can âstop to thinkâ; decide what is worth keeping and what to chuck out; redraft.
* * *
You have to put on a whiny voice for this: âDonât know what to write, Miss. Canât think of anything.â Sound familiar? It does to many children, and it certainly does to me, because I can remember saying exactly those things, in exactly that tone of voice, when I was at school. Even worse, I can remember my Year 6 teacher (or fourth year junior as we called it in the 1950s) saying, âJubb, you havenât got a single idea in your head, have you?â And I believed him, just as plenty of children believe it of themselves today. Low confidence is a killer to creativity. Canât take the chance ⌠too risky.
The truth is my teacher didnât know what he was talking about. He knew little or nothing about the writing process â or about art in general, come to that. Hereâs a shortened version of the proof that I like to present to children in order to persuade them that EVERYONE has loads to write about.
When a baby is born, they donât know very much â but they learn very quickly, largely through their senses. In computer terms, their senses input to their hard drive (or floppy disc in my case!). By the time kids reach Key Stage 2, they must have had millions of sensory inputs. They know what dogs look like, what a baby crying sounds like, what chocolate tastes like, what rain feels like, what a chip shop smells like.
Then thereâs direct experience: everything from being told off for something that wasnât their fault, to finding their hamster dead in its nest. All this is proof positive that no child has a shortage of things to write about. So to indicate that I was, or any child is, empty headed is clearly to misunderstand the nature of the problem.
There is a problem, but it isnât a lack of material in any childâs head. The problem is: how to get the material out of the childâs head. Many children, after theyâve run out of all the displacement activities they can devise, just sit there staring at a blank piece of paper ⌠âthinkingâ. They are âoutside a locked larder of ideasâ. Thatâs a familiar experience to many professional writers too.
Imagine playing football that way. You bring the ball to the middle of the pitch, place it on the centre spot and you ⌠go and make a cup of coffee, do the washing up, take the dog for a walk. And when youâve done all that, you stand there looking at the ball and think about playing football with it. No, you donât. You give the ball a kick straight away. We call it âThe kick-offâ. And really, it doesnât matter so much where the kick-off goes, because during the next 90 minutes the ballâs going to be booted all over the place. But, the kick-off is the most important kick of the whole match ⌠well, if someone doesnât kick it for the first time, it stays where it is and you ainât got no game.
The lesson for would-be writers is shocking, but clear: thinking about writing prevents you from writing. You need to get on with it. You need to get into the game. Whatâs more, you need to get into the game without worrying about whatâs going to happen in the second half. You need a writing kick-off. And you need a draft book to make mistakes in.
âI never think at all when I write. Nobody can do two things at the same time and do them both well.â (Don Marquis)
Kick-offs
âThe beautiful part of writing is that you donât have to get it right the first time, unlike, say, a brain surgeon.â (Robert Cormier)
WRITING ACTIVITY: One word at a time
This is a whole-class activity, with you acting as scribe at the flipchart. Tell the children that youâre not writing a poem, youâre not writing a story, youâre just writing ⌠something, but you donât know what yet.
You put up the first word, then each child in turn has to add one word as quickly as possible; it must make grammatical sense, but otherwise just follow where the piece leads. Anyone can put in punctuation before adding their word if they want to.
Relax them and make it clear that this is for fun. Apart from the need for appropriate parts of speech, there is no right and wrong. The outcome isnât important as such. Children who hesitate can be asked, âWhat could come next?â But weâre aiming for S P E E D here. (For more about calligrams, see A Poetry Teacherâs Toolkit Book 3, Ch. 3.)
The kids will love this game; thereâll be loads of enthusiasm and anticipation. Youâre bound to have some of them trying to influence the choice of others, but thatâs your problem. Once theyâve got the hang of it, you can start getting them to have a go in their groups, then in threes, then pairs. No rubbers, no spellings. Confidence builds if they donât think the outcome is CRUCIAL.
I have just dragged my two âteenmonstersâ from whatever vital activity they were engaged in to have a go. This is what we came up with in about 90 seconds (Nickyâs contribution is in bold, Kevinâs is in italics):
One day there was some delicious raspberries in the back of the car. Katie ate a raspberry and felt peculiar because she had eaten a magical raspberry. She then started to spin faster and faster until she woke up in a ditch and realised what must have happened.
(Iâm a bit embarrassed about âwas someâ from my Year 11 daughter, but then she did rescue us with âmagicalâ.) If the piece runs out of steam, start another one. Give it a go.
WRITING ACTIVITY: One sentence at a time
This is a similar idea, but each child has to give a whole sentence. It is worth trying ...