1 A Critical Review on the Machining of Engineering Materials by Die-âSinking EDM
P. Sreeraj, S. Thirumalai Kumaran,
M. Uthayakumar, and S. Suresh Kumar
Kalasalingam Academy of Research and Education
Contents
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Researches on Electrical Discharge Machining Process
1.2.1 Researches on Enhancement of Tool Wear
1.2.2 Optimization of Process Parameters
1.2.3 Selection of Electrode Material
1.2.4 Multispark Erosion Studies
1.2.5 Selection of Optimized Pulse Duration
1.2.6 Vibratory Tool and Workpiece
1.2.7 Introducing Servo Control Mechanism
1.2.8 Magnetic FieldâBased Electrical Discharge Machining
1.2.9 Special Tools
1.2.10 CNC-âControlled Electrical Discharge Machining
1.2.11 Selection of Dielectric Medium
1.3 Application of Electrical Discharge Machining for Biomaterials
1.4 Conclusions
References
1.1 Introduction
In automotive and aerospace industries for producing complicated shapes of high hardness and toughness, electrical discharge machining (EDM) has been commonly used [1]. Conversion of electrical energy to thermal energy is taking place by means of discrete sparks through separating dielectric medium, which causes material removal. Plasma channel is generated between electrodes, and this high temperature around 20,000°C melts the electrodes, which cause the material removal. When the plasma channel breaks down, materials are flushed away by means of circulating die electric fluid, which actually causes material removal.
Nowadays, EDM is employed as a standard technique for machining of hardened new-âgeneration alloys where traditional machining techniques have proved to be inefficient. Frequent changes of electrodes are required because of rapid tool wear. Machining accuracy of process is also influenced by tool wear, and hence, cost of replacement of the tool increases. In EDM, tool and workpiece have been considered as electrodes, and erosion occurs on both the electrodes. Electrode wear can be classified into four types such as volumetric, corner, end, and side wears [2]. Among them, corner wear has significant influence on affecting the accuracy of machining.
Minimization of electrode wear is one of the research areas to be concentrated in EDM. Considerable research has been done in this area for the minimization of tool wear rate (TWR). Likewise, improvement of material removal rate (MRR), that is, maximization of machining rate and improvement of surface quality (SQ), is also a major challenge for researchers. When an electrode is connected to negative polarity, MRR found to be influenced by recast layer creation. Regarding quality of each prepared surface EDM, it consists of three layers such as recast or white overlay, heat-âaffected zone, and original substrate material. For improving SQ in machining through research, these three layers are required. Quality of machined surface depends on white layer because it is the topmost layer exposed to atmosphere [3].
This chapter concentrates on standard techniques suggested and contributed by different authors for the reduction of tool erosion rate, maximization of material expulsion rate, and SQ. Furthermore, scope for future work has been proposed, and it may be helpful for those who conduct studies in the field of EDM.
1.2 Researches on Electrical Discharge Machining Process
A complete analysis of research activities conducted in the past decades in die-âsinking EDM process has been discussed in this section. There are quantitatively good advantages in EDM such as high precision production of mirror image. In spite of these advantages, EDM has many disadvantages such as formation of surface cracks, metallurgical changes in surface and subsurface regions, formation of recast layers, and formation of heat-âaffected zones. Researchers have devised many methods to overcome these deficiencies of EDM. The following sections describe the methodologies and strategies adopted in EDM process for enhancing the efficiency and quality of machining.
1.2.1 Researches on Enhancement of Tool Wear
Melting of electrodes, due to powerful dislodgement of superheated electrodes at the end of each pulse, causes material removal in EDM. In this development, both tool and workpiece undergo some surface changes because of this melting phenomenon. Many researchers have studied about workpiece modification, abatement of tool wear, and maximization of MRR. Equally important issue is reduction of tool wear. Soni et al. [4] have noticed that appreciable quantity of material migrates from workpiece to tool by forming a protective layer, which causes the reduction of tool wear. Marafona et al. [5] have proved that reduction of tool wear is achieved by a protective thin film of carbon formed on the surface of the tool. Researchers have also shown that this carbon film has considerable effect on reduction of tool wear but has no role on MRR. Marafona [6] has found that because of shift of carbon from circulating dielectric medium, a black surface on tool (W/Cu) is produced while machining the workpiece BS 4695 D2, and the presence of iron, chromium, vanadium, and molybdenum in black layer is also found. These elements present in tool surface form carbon equivalent, which is the main reason for the reduction of tool wear.
Mohri et al. [7,8] proved that in the beginning of machining, electrode wear is more at the edge than flat portion, and it increases in longitudinal direction. In the edge portion, proper deposit of carbon does not take place from die electric during sparking process, and it is the main reason for more wear in the edge portion. Researchers have reported that by providing proper protective layer on tool surface and by using dry medium, the tool wear can be minimized considerably. The ultimate aim of the new researchers is to obtain zero wear electrodes.
In order to achieve improvement in mechanical properties, a recast film has been on EDMed surface of AISI H13 tool steel. Amorim et al. [9] have conducted experiments with electrolyte copper as electrode and hydrocarbon oil as die electric with suspended molybdenum (Mo). The results have indicated that a coating has been formed on the surface and it has improved hardness and other mechanical properties.
1.2.2 Optimization of Process Parameters
Input parameters influence various aspects such as material depletion rate, surface irregularities, tool erosion rate, radial over cut, cutting width, cutting agility, and crater width. By controlling and optimizing major process parameters, the quality of machining can be improved [10]. EDM of Alâ10% SiCp composite has been carried out by Vinothkumar et al. [11] for investigating and comparing influence of cryogenically cooled copper electrode and conventional electrode. For cryogenic cooling, liquid nitrogen (LN2) is used. Grey relational analysis (GRA) has been used for optimizing the process framework, and result shows that cryogenic cooling gives increased efficiency. Majumder [12] has conducted experiments on AISI 316LN stainless steel for optimizing the process parameters in EDM process. Researchers have made fuzzy model to provide fitness function and finally used particle swarm optimization (PSO) for optimizing multiobjective function. Teimouri and Baseri [13] presented a novel model for removing the debris from toolâworkpiece interface by using a rotary tool assisted with rotary magnetic field.
Shabgard et al. [14] investigated the influence of process parameters of AISI H13 tool steel work piece and AISI H13 steel tool. The research has shown that the controlling of processes parameters can considerably reduce TWR. The significance of operational parameters on machining performances of EDM has been studied by Huang et al. [15]. Central composite design has been used with different input process responses and two output parameters [16]. Analysis of variance has been utilized for investigating most important process measures in this process. In the aforementioned work, different flushing methods have been used for conducting experiments.
GRA combined with principal component analysis (PCA) has been applied by Jadish et al. [17] to evaluate and optimize the EDM performance characteristics. PCA-âweighted components corresponding to the performance measures are first evaluated, and then by applying GRA, the process has been optimized. Most significant factor among the process parameters is determined by analysis of variance (ANOVA). Instead of conventional Response Surface Methodology (RSM) model, Xuan-âPhuong Dang [18] has used Kriging model for creating nonlinear equations related to MRR and tool wear with standard input parameters in CNC EDM of P20 steel. Then, PSO has been used for optimizing this multiobjective optimization problem. It is also proved that this method is successful for other types of applications. A new approach of optimization known as Neuro-âGrey method of optimization has been presented by Panda [19] and Tripathy and Tripathy [20] in EDM. In this process, commercial grade oil is used as dielectric, and SiC powder is used as an additive. This attempt has been proved to be very successful. Manivannan and Pradeep Kumar [21] have conducted drilling of mic...