Altered Pasts

Counterfactuals in History

Richard J. Evans

• Publisher: Brandeis University Press
• Year: 2014
• Print ISBN: 9781611685381, 9781611685374
• eBook ISBN: 9781611685398
• Topic: History
• Subtopic: Historical Theory & Criticism
• Index: History

A bullet misses its target in Sarajevo, a would-be Austrian painter gets into the Viennese academy, Lord Halifax becomes British prime minister in 1940 instead of Churchill: seemingly minor twists of fate on which world-shaking events might have hinged. Alternative history has long been the stuff of parlor games, war-gaming, and science fiction, but over the past few decades it has become a popular stomping ground for serious historians. The historian Richard J. Evans now turns a critical, slightly jaundiced eye on a subject typically the purview of armchair historians. The book's main concern is examining the intellectual fallout from historical counterfactuals, which the author defines as "alternative versions of the past in which one alteration in the timeline leads to a different outcome from the one we know actually occurred." What if Britain had stood at the sidelines during the First World War? What if the Wehrmacht had taken Moscow? The author offers an engaging and insightful introduction to the genre, while discussing the reasons for its revival in popularity, the role of historical determinism, and the often hidden agendas of the counterfactual historian. Most important, Evans takes counterfactual history seriously, looking at the insights, pitfalls, and intellectual implications of changing one thread in the weave of history. A wonderful critical introduction to an often-overlooked genre for scholars and casual readers of history alike.

INDEX

Actium, Battle of: won by Mark Antony, 2, 98

Adamson, John, 32–33, 103, 114

Addison, Paul, 52, 57, 62

Alba, Victor, 15

Alexander the Great: conquers Rome, 2

Allen, Louis, 20

Allende, Salvador: avoids coup, 20–21

America, United States of: becomes another Canada, 23; defeated by Confederacy, 10–12, 23, 90; destroys British Empire, 49–55; does not invade Afghanistan, 60; drops atomic bomb on Germany, 72, 113; existence avoided, 1, 19, 21, 23, 61, 99, 101, 109–10; friendship with Germany, 13; neutral in World War II, 50; no Civil War, 1, 23; peace with Nazi Germany, 79; preempted by Spanish conquest, 14; war with Nazi Germany, 80–81, 100, 104; writers dominate counterfactualism, 66, 96

Anglo-Saxons: rule England into twentieth century, 98

Antarctica: Nazis in, 87

Argentina: Hitler escapes to, 85, 91; wins Falklands War, 100–101

Armada, Spanish (1588): fails, 65; makes no difference, 103; succeeds, 1, 2, 13, 22, 89, 106

atomic bomb: American, 118; dropped on Germany, 72, 113; dropped on London and Chicago, 68; Nazi, 118; used by partisans, 117–18

Auschwitz, 72, 76, 83, 86, 121

Austria, Don John of: marries Mary Queen of Scots, 10–11

Austria-Hungary: conquers Italy and France, 14; and World War I, 47, 58, 122

Battle of Britain: RAF loses, 71

Beauharnais, Joséphine de, 4

Beckett, Francis, 97

Bismarck, Otto von, 11, 40, 75, 113

Black, Conrad, 104

Black, Jeremy, 28, 31–33, 37, 94–95, 106

Blakemore, Harold, 20

Bonaparte, Napoleon: chance in career, 40; conquers world, 3–6; decides not to conquer world, 6, 8; defeated in 1812, 104; disregards constraints, 46–47; lose...

Table of contents

• Cover Page
• Title Page
• Copyright
• Dedication
• Contents
• Foreword
• Preface
• Wishful Thinking
• Virtual History
• Future Fictions
• Possible Worlds
• Notes
• Index