Designed to Lead

The Church and Leadership Development

Eric Geiger, Kevin Peck

• Publisher: B&H Books
• Year: 2016
• ISBN:
  9781433690228
• Topic: Theology & Religion
• Subtopic: Christian Church

Most churches merely exist. Many churches do not develop leaders intentionally and consistently. When leaders emerge from some churches, it is often by accident. Something is missing. Something is off. Authors Eric Geiger (author of bestselling Simple Church and Creature of the Word ) and Kevin Peck argue that churches that consistently produce leaders have a strong conviction to develop leaders, a healthy culture for leadership development, and helpful constructs to systematically and intentionally build leaders. All three are essential for leaders to be formed through the ministry of a local church. From the first recordings of history God has made it clear that He has designed creation to be led by His covenant people. More than that, He has decided what His people are to do with that leadership. Whether you are called to lead your home, in the marketplace, in God's church, or in your community, if you are called by God you are called to lead others to worship the glory of God in Jesus Christ. God has designed His people to lead.

CHAPTER ONE

What’s Missing?

Things which matter most must never be at the mercy of things which matter least.

—Wolfgang von Goethe

Developing leaders is hard work for an organization. It often seems like an even harder task for a local church. Many seem to be on the same page about its importance, and yet very few churches would admit to having a handle on the subject. Let us introduce you to three fictitious examples, though we could name dozens of real ones in each category.

Quitter Community Church (QCC): At QCC, the congregation has long existed in an ambivalent truce in the war of developing leaders. Congregants come to Sunday service and small group every week to learn about being a better Christian. The word leader at this church means volunteer with the job of doing whatever everyone else doesn’t remember or want to do. Members with leadership skills outside the walls of the church are not expected to bring those skills to bear in the church because, well, “church is church” and “work is work” and “the two worlds don’t need to intersect.”

At QCC, the work of the church isn’t a place for innovation, improvement, or creativity; it’s a place for duty and faithfulness. Duties are merely broken down into a manageable number of tasks and assigned to volunteers. Then the piles of tasks get too big for “just the volunteers”; the church looks at the budget and hires a new staff member according to their bylaws.

Church of the Flywheel: At the Flywheel, people know how to build things. A staff member brags, “Our system for making leaders is nails. We spent the last four years studying the most advanced leadership systems the world has to offer. We’ve studied the Armed Forces, Fortune 500s, and even several agencies in the espionage world.” But alongside all their systems is one major problem . . . no one cares.

The plans are met with blank stares. The “pipelines” are empty. The slogans and nudges from the platform to “own your development” fall on deaf ears. Sure, a few months after each major overhaul and new emphasis the church always gets a new batch of Johnny-come-latelies to jump into the amazing system; but they always seem to flake out. The staff knows this is a problem and pontificates, “Our content and system is good; maybe we just have a congregation full of duds?” Yeah, that’s probably it.

Talk Louder Community Church: Talk Louder claims to be all about making leaders. “Every year we have two sermon series on developing the next generation of leaders and we give everyone in the congregation the next best leadership book. It’s a success every time! We have nearly 50 percent of our people who see themselves as having leadership potential, and most of them have signed up to volunteer. We have piles of people every year take a gifts profile, and most people look really promising.” Still, strangely enough, every time there is a staff opening the leaders at Talk Louder have to look outside the body. And the truth is that those piles of “gift tests” sit on a desk, untouched since they were completed.

Also at Talk Louder, all the emphasis on “leadership” is focused on “making the church better.” Though not explicitly stated this way, the emphasis of the church is essentially: “Come to our church, get plugged in, and volunteer to help us do church even better.” Because of this, members at Talk Louder are no more likely to be effective leaders at home or in the marketplace than they were before joining the church. Thoughtful leaders on the team know this and struggle, “Every year we think we are taking big strides by creating more momentum for developing leaders, but something is holding us back from producing leaders.” Something is missing at Talk Louder, and it isn’t more rhetoric on leadership development.

Something is missing in many churches.

Perhaps you see your church in one of the examples. While fictitious, they are actually far too close and too real for many of us. It would be a challenge to find a vibrant evangelical church that doesn’t admit that leadership development is a key function of the local church. And yet, it is our experience that very few church leaders can identify the problem that is hampering the leadership potential in their church. Church leaders know the people they serve have been made in His image, purchased with His blood, equipped with His Spirit, and called to make disciples, but they struggle with helping people live out the reality of their capacity to lead.

So the programmatic rat race in most churches continues. Most churches merely exist to keep running their programs and services. They are not developing leaders intentionally and consistently. When leaders emerge from some churches, it is often by accident. “Wow, a leader emerged. . . . How did that happen?” should not be heard among God’s people. Something is missing. Something is off.

We attend conferences and preach sermons imploring the church of God to stand up and take hold of their destiny to advance the Kingdom of God across the globe. Still, our pews and folding chairs stay warm with immobile, uninspired, ill-equipped saints. Our churches, homes, and places of work lack the leadership of Christian men and women.

Something has to change.

We must find a way to unlock the power of God in the people of God, to see His sons and daughters rise up and lead for the glory of God. Jesus Himself has given to His blood-bought people the mandate to lead in His Kingdom, and to equip others to do the same.

For leaders to be developed consistently and intentionally, churches must possess conviction, culture, and constructs. Based on our own leadership and ministry experiences, studying leadership development, and interacting with churches and ministry leaders who develop others, we believe the following framework encompasses what must happen in a local church for leaders to be developed and deployed.

Designed to Lead Framework

Churches that consistently produce leaders have a strong conviction to develop leaders, a healthy culture for leadership development, and helpful constructs to systematically and intentionally build leaders. All three are essential for leaders to be formed through the ministry of a local church.

Conviction is a God-initiated passion that fuels a leader and church. Conviction is at the center of the framework because without conviction to develop others, leadership development will not occur. Developing leaders must be a burning passion, a nonnegotiable part of the vision of a local church and her leaders, or it will never become a reality. The essential task of developing others must not be at the mercy of other things, of lesser things in a local church.

Once the church leaders share this conviction, this ambition must become part of the very culture of the church itself. Culture is the shared beliefs and values that drive the behavior of a group of people. The church that believes in and values the development of others collectively holds the conviction for leadership development. When development is in the culture, it is much more than an idea or program; it is part of the very core identity of the church.

Wise leaders implement constructs to help unlock the full potential of a church that seeks to be a center for developing leaders. By constructs, we mean the systems, processes, and programs developed to help develop leaders. Constructs provide necessary implementation and execution to the vision and passion of culture and conviction.

Because we have a proclivity to run to the practical for a quick fix and to find something we can quickly implement, most leaders will run to constructs when addressing leadership development problems in a church. While constructs are important, if you embrace and implement constructs without first developing a coherent and strong conviction and culture, you will only reap apathy or exhaustion.

Constructs without Conviction = Apathy. The reason that many people in churches give blank stares to leadership development initiatives is because an overarching sense of conviction has not been fostered in the church. The reason many churches settle for enlisting people to “fill necessary slots” to pull off programs is there is not a conviction for developing leaders. The pastors, the people, everyone has given up on the grand idea of discipling and deploying leaders. If a shared sense of conviction that God wants to raise up and release leaders in His Kingdom through His Church is lacking, apathy is sure to follow. If you want to know why churches have given up, look no further than lack of conviction.

Constructs without Culture = Exhaustion. Constructs are doomed to fail without strong conviction and a healthy culture. If a church attempts to execute constructs without a culture of leadership development, the systems will feel exhausting. The church longs for the “leadership flywheel” and seeks it through systems; but without a healthy culture those systems are merely seen as another set of things to do, a cumbersome hoop to jump through. And as staff attempts to implement, everyone grows weary. Every time the team aims to fill the leadership pipeline it feels as if they are pushing a boulder up a hill. An unhealthy culture breeds exhaustion.

Conviction without Constructs = Frustration. At the same time, if a team holds a deep conviction for development but lacks constructs to help develop leaders, frustration festers. Constructs are vitally important. Conviction and culture must be the starting point; but if constructs are not provided, then intentional and ongoing leadership development is merely wishful thinking. A vision without a strategy is nothing more than a fun whiteboard moment that rarely results in anything significant. There is nothing more frustrating than an unrealized vision, than a passion without any traction. A leader who isn’t passionate about leadership development will sleep better tonight than the one who is but lacks necessary constructs to help develop leaders. A leader without constructs often says, “We keep talking (louder and louder) about developing leaders, but nothing happens.”

Conviction, culture, and constructs. If any of the three are missing, leadership development will be stifled. Is one missing in your context? Does one or more need focus and attention?

To further explain and illustrate the importance of all three, let’s look at Moses and his leadership of God’s people. Moses is as an example of a godly leader who developed others for the mission the Lord had for His people. In observing Moses’ leadership, we can see a holy conviction for investing in others, an emphasis on a culture that develops leaders, and constructs that enables development.

Moses and Conviction

Often our churches don’t make leaders because we lack conv...