Bakespeare
Francis Bacon (1561â1626), William Shakespeare (1564â1616).
To all of you William Shakespeare disciples who consider any disparagement of the Bard or debasement of his august reputation (and I once was included among you) to be abject heresy, I am going to present, as fairly and objectively as possible, both sides of the Bacon-Shakespeare true-authorship controversy. There is no harm or heresy intended. This is merely a search for the truth which, frankly, will probably never be known, just like the presence of extraterrestrials among us, the true builders of the pyramids and the methods they used, the President Kennedy assassination, and the Malcolm Butler benching in Super Bowl LII. (For those of you who are not New England Patriotsâ fans, the mystery behind Head Coach Bill Belichickâs benching of Butler is at least as significant as the other examples.) Moreover, there are those who believe Edward de Vere, the seventeenth Earl of Oxford, or maybe John Donne wrote the Shakespeare plays. The New Oxford Shakespeare Series, published in 2016, credits Marlowe with collaborating with the Bard on the three Henry VI plays.
The first time I disagreed with Mark Twain, my intellectual lodestar, was after I read Is Shakespeare Dead? His essay arguing for Francis Bacon as the true author of the Shakespearean canon failed to move me. Like a true Shakespeare disciple, I believed strongly that the Bard was a singular literary genius worthy of his title as the greatest English (probably the worldâs greatest) playwright. I wanted to cling to my cherished beliefs, even if Twain, my favorite author and the one I credit for teaching me to question everything, explained that a man with the historical William Shakespereâs (historical figureâs proper spelling) humble background could not have possibly had the depth and breadth of knowledge it would have taken to be the author of the plays and sonnets attributed to him.
Twain writes of Shakespeare, âIsnât it odd, when you think of it, that you may list all the celebrated Englishmen, Irishmen, and Scotchmen of modern times, clear back to the first Tudors, and you can go to the histories, biographies, and, encyclopedias and learn the particulars of the lives of every one of them except oneâthe most famous, the most renownedâby far the most illustrious of the allâShakespeare! About him you can find out nothing of even the slightest importance.â
Shakespeareâs youthful years are a mystery. He came from a working-class background. His father was an alderman (elected member of a municipal council) and a bailiff who suffered financial setbacks. Shakespeare presumably attended a Stratford-upon-Avon grammar school where he may or may not have acquired some knowledge of Latin, the language of aristocratic London in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. According to his contemporary, the playwright Ben Johnson, Shakespeare understood âsmall Latin and less Greek.â
Shakespeare did not attend Oxford or Cambridge or any educational institution beyond grammar school. Manly P. Hall writes, âIt is quite evident that William Shakespeare did not possess that necessary literary culture, for the town of Stratford where he was reared contained no school capable of imparting the higher forms of learning reflected in the writings ascribed to him. In his early life, he evinced a total disregard for study.â
There are no real documented facts about his teenage years until he married Anne Hathaway in 1582. They had a daughter and then twinsâa boy and a girl. In the seven years between the official record of his marriage and his association with the troupe of actors known as Lord Chamberlainâs Men, soon to become the Kingâs Men, there is no information about Shakespeare. Robert Greene, a popular writer at the time, described Shakespeare as âan upstart crow, beautified with our feathers.â
After Lord Chamberlainâs Men built the Globe Theatre in 1599, Shakespeareâs reputation as a playwright and actor became known, and he became prosperous enough as a stockholder and manager of two theaters to warrant the title of âgentleman.â According to Twain, after his retirement, Shakespeare âbusied himself in lending money, trading in tithes, trading in land and houses, suing debtors for shillings and coppers, and acting as a confederate to a neighbor who tried to rob the town of its rights in a certain common and did not succeed.â Twain adds, âWhen Shakespeare died in Stratford, it was not an event. It made no more stir in England than any other forgotten theater actor would have made.â
Historians and writers have made much of Shakespeareâs will, in which he left his wife his âsecond-best bedâ and which bears three of the six extant examples of the Bardâs handwriting. According to Twain, Shakespeareâs will ânamed in minute detail every item of property he owned in the world, but it mentioned not a single book.â (The italics are Twainâs). According to Manly P. Hall, âThere are in existence but six known examples of Shakespeareâs handwriting. All are signatures, and three of them are in his will. There is no record that Shakespeare ever possessed a library, nor does he make any mention of books in his will.â
Despite Twainâs body of evidence and his characteristically irreverent tone, I did not, for several years, agree with him. That changed when I started immersing myself in literature about ancient wisdom, secret societies, and ultimately, Francis Bacon. Among the many facts I learned about Bacon was that he was a principal founder and sponsor of the Virginia Company of London, a group that invested in the voyage to and settlement of the Virginia colony in the New World. After reading how an actual shipwreck near Bermuda served as a model for The Tempest and subsequently reading passages in that play that evoked ancient wisdom, I started to believe that Bacon was the true author. Thereafter, the more I read Shakespeareâs work, the more convinced I became that I was reading Bacon or, at the very least, Baconâs strong influence.
The Tempest shipwreck is based on the flagship Sea Adventure, which headed a group of nine vessels that set sail from England to Virginia in June of 1609. It carried the new deputy governor of Virginia Sir Thomas Gates, Admiral George Somers, and Captain Christopher Newport as well as authors Richard Rich, Silvester Jourdan, and a man named William Strachey. The Sea Adventure washed ashore in Bermuda on July 28, but everybody survived. Prosperoâs spirit in The Tempest, Ariel, speaks of Bermuda in Act I, scene ii, lines 228â229:
Thou callâdst me up at mi...