A Black Forest Walden

Conversations with Henry David Thoreau and Marlonbrando

David Farrell Krell

• Publisher: SUNY Press
• Year: 2022
• Print ISBN:
  9781438488486
  9781438488493
• eBook ISBN:
  9781438488509
• Topic: Philosophy
• Subtopic: Philosopher Biographies

Compares life today in the German Black Forest with Thoreau's experiences at Walden Pond.

Finalist for the 2022 Foreword INDIES Book of the Year Award in the Essay Category

A Black Forest Walden is a work of philosophical reflection, nature description, and sly humor. In brief chapters, or aphorisms, the American philosopher David Farrell Krell recounts his experiences in a cabin located in the mountains of southern Germany's Black Forest, where he has lived for several decades. Insofar as Krell compares his experiences with those of Henry David Thoreau, who serves as both inspiration and irritation, the book could be described as a critical commentary on Thoreau's Walden. Yet it equally reads as a rigorous yet playful and profoundly literary manifestation of where and how the mind wanders. Hence, the "Marlonbrando" of the subtitle is not the late actor but a feral cat who frequents the cabin and comes to be an important interlocutor, as if playing the role of analyst to the author. The subjects Krell treats are wide-ranging: the changing seasons, environmental issues, romantic love, parent-child relations, European versus American "values," higher education, artistic creativity, solitude, and the contrast between lifestyles in a quiet Black Forest village and in a noisy contemporary United States. Forty-one black-and-white photographs taken by the author accompany and enliven the text.

1

Silent snowfall

It happens over and over again throughout the winter, so why does it always surprise me? The evening, all windstorm, soon passes over into a night of rainfall. Droplets dance on the metal roof of the cabin—lightly, on their toes, and I doze; heavily, foot stomping, and I stir. Then silence. I sleep. In the morning, a lambent white light fills the bedroom of the cabin. The mirror affixed to the door of the old cupboard at the head of my bed tells me what I already know. I rise and gaze out the window at Douglas the Fir. His branches strain under the weight of white. The fields stretching up to Schauinsland Mountain blaze white-hot with cold. It’s always the same feeling that accompanies the first overwhelming glimpse of snowfall at the cabin, the feeling of having been hoodwinked during the night, the sense that I should have known what the night—that inexpressibly beautiful creature—was up to, or down to. The Snow Queen of Kurosawa’s Dreams has once again suffocated me softly in the night, and once again I awake in paradise.

2

The colors of snow; or, where beauty is

When Monet and Pissarro paint snow, it is all roses and bluebells with an orange aura and a crimson afterglow—every color but white. Of course, white isn’t a color at all, but, as we learned in school, it is all the colors spun around on a disc. That spinning disc is rarely encountered out there in the world, to be sure, but painted snow teaches us the lesson anyway. Herman Melville calls white “the colorless all-color,” and so it is, even at night, under a moon.

Years ago, I arrived at the cabin with a lover. We were jet lagged and could not sleep during the night. We sensed, then saw, in the moonlight outside the cabin window that snow had fallen. We got up, dressed, and stepped out the cabin door into two feet of snow. It was four o’clock in the morning. The waxing moon was only half full, but it lit up the blanketed valley. We walked, or trudged, in silence over Edward’s Heights until dawn. In the black of night, under moonlight, the snow crystals glittered violet and green—amethyst and sapphire—with each laborious step of ours. With each turn of the head or inclination of the back and shoulders, the snow scintillated in alternating flashes of green and purple, purple and green, each more brilliant than the last. It was as though not white but purple-green was the all-color. A flashing round dance of vert and violet seemed to capture the entire spectrum of colors, including ultraviolet and infrared. The philosopher Friedrich Joseph Schelling calls the unity of violet and green “supreme splendor,” and we believed him. We returned to the cabin, cooked a big breakfast, made love, slept away the day, and woke to another night of moonlit snow. We discovered that lag can also make a life.

Since then, I have walked over Edward’s Heights under snow and moonlight many times, searching for amethyst and sapphire but finding only diamonds. On these later occasions, I was alone. That was how I learned that vert and violet had been effluences of her eyes, and that beauty is in the eye of the beholder’s beloved.

3

In the still of the night

If recently you’ve been living in a city, your first night in the cabin can be disconcerting, no matter how happy you are to get there. (You get there by taking a tram through Freiburg from the railway station to the southern outskirts of town, catching a bus up to the most remote village—the bus leaves once every hour till nightfall—then walking up the steepest hill on the horizon off to your right, Barley Stalk Hill, about a ninety-minute walk.)

Disconcerting first of all because of the chill in the walls. Whether winter or summer, the cabin walls are cold and damp long after you light your first fire. In winter, it will take you three days’ and nights’ worth of fires to rout that chill, even if the forester has come early on the day of your arrival (he has a key) and lit a fire for you. In summer, the chill will be banished more quickly once you light your fire and open all the windows and the door. Disconcerting in the second place because even after your bed is warm on that first night (ah, the featherbed! we will have to come back to this little touch of heaven!) so that you drift off into a grateful and gratifying sleep, you will be roused in the middle of the night by something else—the stillness.

Absolute silence is like noise: you can hear it. You wake up and you listen to it. You rise and fall on its waves, its periods and cadences. It fills your ears like the chirpings of tinnitus, and you wonder at it. You do not hear the man in the moon breathing, because he does not breathe. Yet in the silence you sense him looking at you, and you feel his pull on the seas and the blood. The stillness is palpable. Sometimes it is so disquieting that you have to rise and go outside to see if it is real, or if the cabin has become a pyramid. Once outside, you feel the winter wind or summer breeze, and more important, you hear it in the trees. After a while the silence abates, goes quiet. You can go back to bed now.

Back in Chicago or New York City, the drunken brawl outside your window has to escalate to beer bottle smashing or a gunfire exchange before you hear it. Here, the stillness of the night escalates without police or ambulance sirens, without cries and whispers or sound and fury, and it has all the time in the world to wait until you hearken to it. You will.

4

The snowplow

The roar of a motor at night—what can it be but the destroyer of sleep? It is true that whenever the salt-strewing snowplow comes bellowing up the switchback asphalt road of the Möhlin Valley, all the way up to the parking lot that is located several hundred meters south and east of the cabin, I wake up. Sleep is suspended, at least for a few moments, until the plow clears the parking area of snow, turns, and heads back down the road. Yet I am always delighted, no matter how heavy with sleep my head may be. I open my eyes to the brilliant headlights lighting up the forest pines and the spinning orange warning lights whose beams turn up periodically in the mirror. They are like searchlights in the sky near an airport or the beam of the outermost lighthouse. Nothing makes me feel more secure or gives me more hope for the day to come, not because I have anywhere to go, but simply because of the company. Depending on the timing of the snow or ice storm, the truck may come chugging by at one or three or five o’clock in the morning: the drivers do not sleep all winter long, no hibernation for them. It isn’t that I’m grateful for their work. For years now, I have been hoping to be snowed in for weeks at a time, to be like Jack in that high Colorado hotel laboring diligently over his book, all work and no play. And every year the undaunted, unstoppable snowplow frustrates my hope. I should be growling. Yet there is something reassuring about the deep hum of the engine and the scrape of the plow, as there is about a lonesome freight train’s whistle in the night. There is a world out there, a world of workers and wanderers, and it sings to me like Woody Guthrie or Pete Seeger, “Go to sleep, you weary hobo, let the towns drift slowly by.” So I turn and scrunch the featherbed tight around my shoulder and know that there is a world in here too. And mine is appreciably warmer.

5

Ice wings

“Many of the phenomena of Winter are suggestive of an inexpressible tenderness and fragile delicacy. We are accustomed to hear this king described as a rude and boisterous tyrant; but with the gentleness of a lover he adorns the tresses of Summer.” So says Henry David Thoreau (W 234), and he is right. If the dense fog lasts through the night and Boreas the north wind blows lightly but steadily till dawn, each twig and tine of the leafless birch on the meadow above the cabin forms along its entire length a wing of transparent ice an inch or more in width. By morning, the tree is an enormous white bird or, when the wind blows, a musical instrument. The poet Georg Trakl calls these ice wings crystalline angels.

There is a clearing near the edge of the forest on Barley Stalk Hill. Stinging nettles flourish there in summer, growing chest high in the rich soil. The very sight of them on a summer morning sets the skin to tingling. In winter, the tall stalks are stripped of their nettlesome leaves. The ice wings construct an enchanting heaven out of their little hell; they are swaying seraphim rather than stinging satans. A few meters farther on, huge boughs of pine and fir dip under the weight of ice wings grown so close together—crowding every needle and branch—that they form something like tufts of thick white wool, a warm mantle of ice, winter fur for winter firs—but back to that solitary birch on the meadow.

When the March sun burns off the frozen fog, usually by mid-afternoon, the wings take flight, an Icarus of ice, and plunge to the ground. A silhouette of shattered wings, shards of iced fog, spreads across the matted brown grass beneath the tree. Within half an hour every wing has fallen, the music is stilled, and the naked birch grows taciturn once again. It wants to bud leaves, not ice wings. I scoop up some jagged fragments of ice and hold their freeze, albeit only for a melting moment. I notice that the wings are ribbed, as though for tensile strength, testifying to the long and patient labors of the night fog. But did any effort at all go into these formations? One tree would have taken you and me years of work to transform. So much effort! No effort at all for nature. The fragments chill my palm, then swell to one great tear that rolls across my lifeline, uncertain of the cause of its weeping. Toil? Time? Warmth? Transient beauty?

6

The Storm Beech

The enormous tree, my most august neighbor, dominates the hill and the sky of the pasture above the cabin. In fact, the sky stretches over the Storm Beech like a tarpaulin, gray in winter, blue in summer; the beech’s roots gather together the earth, frozen and brown in winter, green and gay with wildflowers in summer. It is called the Storm Beech because the south wind has shaped it for a century or two, twisting and bending its boughs so that they incline toward the northeast like the myriad needles of numberless compasses. “No tree has so fair a bole and so handsome an instep as the beech,” says Thoreau in an unpublished text cited by Ralph Waldo Emerson (SW 428). On every fair summer evening, I sit on that instep—one of the many insteps, which are the thick gray roots almost entirely exposed to the light and air. Onto one of the neighboring insteps, one that happens to be flattened and scarred, I place my wine cup. The blood of the grape is sometimes red, sometimes pale yellow-green, and I toast the setting sun after it has toasted me during the day. I lay back in the arms of the tree and study—through gnarled branches and a riot of green leaves—the brilliant sky. The great beech has soaked up so much caloric during the day that it now communicates it to me: if I am able to write tomorrow, it will be thanks to the energy transfer from tree to me.

One of the locals told me many years ago about the arboreal energy of the Storm Beech, but I was skeptical at the time and merely laughed: old wives’ tales. As I toast the sun now, I do not forget to salute the Storm Beech, which extends over me its protecting boughs and leaves and subtends me with its earth-embracing root system. I may be dendritically drunk. Or perhaps I have gone a bit mad, tetched by numerous old wives and their stories? Am I altogether a beechnut?

7

The Moon and Venus

I had to catch the first bus to Freiburg on a December morning and so had to leave the cabin at five o’clock, long before daylight. The chilly sky blinked with iced stars. The waning moon showed but a sliver, even though I could easily make out the shadowy circle or corona of the entire sphere. It was like an eclipse of the sun, with the curved arc of the celestial body startlingly clear, as though backlit. Below the moon was the brightest satellite I had ever seen, huge and silver and seemingly unmoving. It could not have been a manmade satellite, yet I had never seen the likes of it before. Had the calendar put us closer to Christmas, I would have thought of Bethlehem, Hallmark, and Monty Python. A friend later told me it was Saturn, vast enough on its own, yet appearing even larger because of its rings. No earthling could make out the rings, of course, but I was witness to a massive, unified, argentine light in...

Table of contents

• Cover
• Title
• Copyright
• Contents
• Preface
• 1. Silent snowfall
• 2. The colors of snow; or, where beauty is
• 3. In the still of the night
• 4. The snowplow
• 5. Ice wings
• 6. The Storm Beech
• 7. The Moon and Venus
• 8. The cabin; or, plucking the raisins
• 9. The past has not passed
• 10. Neighbors
• 11. But where’s the pond?
• 12. River of fog
• 13. My “office”
• 14. Conversations with Marlon Brando?
• 15. Ice wings, Part Two
• 16. Douglas the Fir
• 17. Aurora
• 18. Freaks of nature; or, lighting fires and mourning the woods
• 19. H.D. in bed
• 20. Maudlin and bathetic
• 21. Add your dreams, and not just the sexy ones!
• 22. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right
• 23. Neighbors, Part Two: Herr S.W.
• 24. The darkness of the woods
• 25. Monarchs in December
• 26. The limits of description
• 27. The limits of knowledge
• 28. Black and white
• 29. Fool’s spring
• 30. A reflection on consumer society; or, a Romantic has his uses
• 31. The deserving poor
• 32. A succession of beautiful days
• 33. Neighbors, Part Three: Wolfgang
• 34. La pensée du jour
• 35. The smartphone in high mountains
• 36. The new adventures of Pinocchio
• 37. News of the world
• 38. On the difference between European and American “values”
• 39. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Two
• 40. On the degeneration of poetry to chemistry
• 41. Platonism and Puritanism keep us on our spiritual toes
• 42. Neighbors, Part Four: Frau S.M.
• 43. Let’s (not!) do lunch
• 44. The perfect universe
• 45. Autarchy; or, fatties beware!
• 46. Woodchuck Heaven
• 47. Mudslide Man
• 48. Knowing beans
• 49. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Three
• 50. Moving mountains
• 51. Obscene spring
• 52. On jealousy and brutalization
• 53. The bowlegged larch
• 54. Speculative gardening
• 55. Former inhabitants
• 56. The two corners of Melville’s smile
• 57. Thaw and Thor
• 58. Former inhabitants, Part Two
• 59. Taking the arm of an elm tree
• 60. Thoreau’s serviceable body
• 61. On loneliness; or, snap out of it!
• 62. The work of mourning
• 63. A cautionary note
• 64. Hurry up, please, it’s time
• 65. Return to sender
• 66. Former inhabitants, Part Three
• 67. A snippet on schnapps
• 68. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Four
• 69. Doubling up
• 70. My little chickadee!
• 71. Home Entertainment Center
• 72. Neighbors, Part Five: Rüdiger
• 73. The forlorn pair of shoes
• 74. The forlorn BMW
• 75. Kids
• 76. Henry’s mom and dad
• 77. More work of mourning
• 78. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Five
• 79. Old people
• 80. About that blackbird
• 81. Former inhabitants, Part Four: The lover suspended in the rafters
• 82. On doing good
• 83. Organized religion
• 84. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Six
• 85. Living in the present
• 86. Out of doors
• 87. Bronchitis? Pneumonia?
• 88. Day, season, and year
• 89. The bloody truth about trees
• 90. The head monkey at Paris
• 91. On the gift-giving vice
• 92. Losing the whole world
• 93. Knowing when to break up
• 94. Accentuate the negative
• 95. Prejudice
• 96. How to become just friends
• 97. Faithless fidelity
• 98. Advice to the lovelorn
• 99. Books
• 100. Former inhabitants … of color … at Walden Pond
• 101. Crooked genius, crooked rules
• 102. Art is not yet weaned
• 103. Life is not yet weaned
• 104. Problematic praxis
• 105. The Copernican Revolution?
• 106. New beech leaves
• 107. God bless the American Igel; or, true patriotism
• 108. One more angel story, the last one, I promise
• 109. Creationism
• 110. Capital punishment
• 111. May fog
• 112. Thoreau’s model farm
• 113. The water works
• 114. There is nothing inorganic
• 115. The ashes of once living things
• 116. The katzenjammer of birds
• 117. The wolf spider
• 118. A morning hike
• 119. Music of the rain
• 120. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Seven
• 121. Save your hay
• 122. A day’s journey
• 123. Dream and catastrophe; or, the politics of archaeology
• 124. And then the sky fell
• 125. Still more work
• 126. Life stammers on
• 127. Pinions
• 128. The logic of error; or, a modest disquisition on the synthesis of being, time, and truth
• 129. Tell Marlonbrando your dreams, honey, and everything will be all right, Part Eight and Last
• 130. Cabin smells
• 131. Desperately sad
• 132. Self-confidence
• 133. Polonius
• 134. Sea of fog
• 135. Sunworshiper fog
• 136. Weather can be extraordinarily precise
• 137. The man in the moon
• 138. Breaking News: Marlonbrando confesses all!
• 139. Extra-vagance
• 140. September mood
• 141. Periwinkle and ivy
• 142. To see and say it all
• 143. Marlonbrando sees the light
• 144. The power of the past tense
• 145. From the mountains of Saint Ulrich to the prairies of Chicagoland?
• 146. Life is at bottom indestructibly powerful and pleasurable
• Notes
• List of Illustrations
• Back Cover