Chapter 1
Whatâs the Brand Idea?
Find the simple story in the product and present it in an articulate, intelligent, and persuasive way.
âBill Bernbach, Legendary âMad Manâ
Destiny is a dramatic wordâbut really, the first step in starting a new venture is identifying your business destiny, determining what specific business youâand only youâwere born to create. The best idea for you will involve the perfect convergence of your skills, talents, and passions with the needs of the marketplace.
The hardest part of launching a business is beginning. You need to find the brand idea thatâs right for you. Yet, itâs the most important step. Finding your business idea is like examining your DNA. Itâs finding whatâs different, relevant, and special about you so that you can share it with others. Itâs discovering where you belong in the world so you can embark on the journey that will take you there.
The Valley of Death
Entrepreneurs brand the time between coming up with a business idea and having a successful start-up as âThe Valley of Death.â As the name implies, the beginning period is no picnic. Itâs a tough time to get through intact. You donât have enough financing. You donât have all the skills and resources you need. You can die in the valley if you donât get enough customers and money to cover cash flow.
Yet, in so many ways, this starting period is the most valuable time you will ever have as an entrepreneur. Itâs the time when you can create tremendous value out of nothing. Youâre creating a new product or service where there was none before. Youâre positioning the brand so it can stand out in the marketplace. Youâre creating intellectual property with a brand name and with your brandâs look and feel. Youâre starting to build a reputation for the new brand and for Brand You. Youâre developing tangible assets such as your product, equipment, and even real estate.
As a bootstrapping entrepreneur, youâre creating many valuable brand assets during the beginning phase that will set the course for brand success or failure. The beginning period, this Valley of Death, may be your riskiest time, but it is also your most valuable time creatively and strategically.
Yet, many entrepreneurs rush to market, shortchanging the formulation phase. They want to have a business, yet they donât have a fully formed and viable idea. Or they have a copycat idea. Or a gargantuan, overly complicated idea. Or an idea that tries to appeal to everyone and therefore is destined for failure. When you try to appeal to everyone, you appeal to no one. If you donât use this beginning phase to build a solid foundation of brand assets, you will likely not survive the Valley of Death.
The Paradox: Small Ideas Are Big
It all begins with an idea. In the branding business, people talk a lot about the âbig idea.â
But I say, âForget the big idea, go for a small idea.â
Thereâs a fundamental paradox of business ideas: the bigger the idea, the simpler and more focused it will be. Big ideas are smallâsimple, focused, and specificâso that they can occupy a unique niche and dominate their category. The best business and product ideas come from drilling down and being very targeted and specific. Drill down until you come up with a way that your brand can be superlative.
That way, youâre building a business on something thatâs small enough to own and create a brand identity around and that will get you big results. You and your business will stand for something, rather than being a mashup of who knows what.
All good branding involves sacrificeâyou must sacrifice the things that donât belong to the core business idea. Too many entrepreneurs stumble over this simple reality. When expressing their business idea, they ramble on and on for fifteen minutes, leaving their listeners (investors, potential clients, potential employees) scratching their heads. Either they havenât zeroed in on what they want to accomplish or they havenât figured out how to express it simply. Whatever the caseâthey are not yet ready for business.
So get a clearly focused business idea. You donât want to be an apple and orange business. You want a clear-cut business that you can define easily and effortlessly. Your simple sentence that defines your business will serve you well when pitching your idea to investors, attracting talent, talking to the press, and, most especially, connecting with your customers.
âSMALLâ IDEA: a simple, focused brand promise that defines whatâs special about your brand.
Your brand idea is your tagline or mantra for your business that expresses the core concept. Itâs the promise of what your brand will offer customers that others donât. For example, FedExâs brand promise is its advertising tagline: âYour package will get there overnight. Guaranteed.â The Japanese retailer Uniqloâs tagline is âMade for All,â reflecting its mission of creating stylishly simple casual clothes for all to wear. For its fruit smoothies, the U.K. company Innocent uses the tagline, âThe fruit, the whole fruit, and nothing but the fruit.â
In breakthrough branding, youâll find that you always convey the most when you say the least. So make it simple. You must figure out a way to articulate clearly, for yourself and others, what the business is, who itâs for, why itâs needed, and why it will be a success.
Your business idea should be short enough to write on the back of a business card. You want a phrase or sentence, not an elaborate paragraph. Another way of looking at it is, if you canât explain your business idea successfully to a ten-year-old, you donât have a clear-cut idea for your business. You need to be able to sum up what your business is and why it matters. As Einstein said, âEverything must be as simple as possible, but not simpler.â
Your sentence should contain a keyword or phrase that you want everyone to associate with your brand. Think of the way big brands try to own a word or phrase, like Google owns âsearch,â Volvo owns âsafety,â and FedEx owns âovernight.â So when people think of your brand, they think of âX.â Or when they think of âX,â they think of your brand.
When Your Heart Talks, Pay Attention
To be a successful entrepreneur, your goal has to be more than just making money. Entrepreneurship and finding your business idea are about finding your purpose. Your goal must be tied to your deeper story, your sense of destiny for yourself and your business. It must feel authentic and right for you. Itâs discovering your personal vision that reveals your essence, your passion, and your values. That vision comes from your heart, not your head.
Great brands are always built on authenticity, on who you are and what your business can be, not what you want it to be. For a decade in the 1990s, Las Vegas marketed itself as a family vacation destination. Think about it, positioning Vegas as a family destination. Nobody goes to Vegas for family stuff, well, almost nobody. Vegas is about drinking and gambling like crazy and doing things you want to keep under wraps afterward. Its nickname is âSin City,â after all. In 2003, when Vegas adopted authentic positioning, the city came up with its famous slogan, âWhat happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas.â And the branding was a smash success. Now, here was a positioning line that came from Vegasâs DNA. It was a brand promise that people could believe in.
Branding has to come from who you are and what your business can be, not from what you want it to be.
Great brands didnât get that way by failing to deliver on an authentic brand promise. When customers and prospects believe what you say, you get a trust premium over competitors. Procter & Gamble found that its businesses that were growing faster than average, including Pampers, Tide, Downy, and Crest, had a trust advantage that gave these brands a market share advantage. A global study conducted by the former chief marketing officer of P&G found that the quality of a companyâs external and internal communications around a shared customer ideal led to business success and the ability to grow.1
When we believe something is honest and comes from its true nature, what psychologists call essentialism, that even gives us pleasure.2 And that pleasure is lost when we find out something is âfakeâ or not what we thought it was. The pleasure of a good wine is influenced by whether we think itâs expensive or cheap. Just as we enjoy a painting that we trust is authentic, and donât enjoy it when we are told it is a reproduction or a fake.
You need to build a business based on authenticity, based on what the business is and can be, and who you are and can be. More than working for others, entrepreneurship offers you the opportunity to be who you were meant to be, to succeed on your own terms. You donât have to do it the company way anymoreâyou can and must do it your way. Thatâs the good news and the bad news, of course, because you wonât have the company to lean on or to blame when things go wrong. You canât be fired or even reprimandedâbut you can lose everything.
The Mouse That Roared
Small, âhigh-conceptâ ideas are different. Theyâre not copycat ideas but try to break new ground. They provide a fresh benefit, appeal to a hungry target audience, have a new processâa different something. Even though youâre a small business now, having an important difference will give you a loud voice in the marketplace.
Being different is a cardinal rule of branding. You donât have to have a big idea, but you do have to have an idea that is different from your competitorsâ ideas. Having a different idea for your business is powerful. Just being different from everything else in your category in some way is immensely helpful for your brand because you can position your business and products as unique, occupying their own niche.
You canât own what someone else owns, so donât even try. Once youâve claimed your position in the market, no one can easily move in on your spot, either.
There are a lot of ways to be different. The ultimate way is to create a whole new product category and, in the process, to create a consumer need that no one has previously exploitedâpossibly even a need that consumers didnât know they had. Apple has been wildly successful at this. But while not all of us are brilliant (or capitalized) enough to create a whole new product platform, we can make changes in the existing ones and be successful.
You could utilize a new technology that gives your product a competitive edge, as the various smartphone makers do every year, in an attempt to outmaneuver their competitors. Or your product might be made out of ingredients or by a process thatâs different.
The television cook and author Sandra Lee created a new cooking concept she called Semi-Homemade. She came up with the name while walking down the aisle in a grocery store one day and seeing bags of semisweet chocolate for cooking. Thatâs sort of what Iâm doing, she thought, because her dishes are made up of about 70 percent packaged ingredients and 30 percent fresh foods. While Leeâs concept is more than semi-controversial with many cooks, she has a thriving business with adoring fans who love her easy-to-prepare recipes and her appealing personal brand. Sandra Leeâs tagline for her cooking concept is âKeep It Simple, Keep It Smart, Keep It Sweet, Keep It Semi-Homemade.â3
Each target market has its preferences and hot points, and your product could tap into the mindset of a specific group or generation....