1
Why are you drawn to historical fiction?
Writers come to historical fiction for different reasons. This chapter explores what your reasons are, how you might therefore set about imagining and recreating places and times that you canāt have experienced directly, and how to get started on an actual story.
Sara Sheridan writes historical fiction based on real nineteenth-century explorers, and historical crime.
āThe best historical stories capture the modern imagination because they are, in many senses, still current ā part of a continuum. ⦠Writing historical fiction has many common traits with writing sci-fi or fantasy books. The past is another country ā a very different world ā and historical readers want to see, smell and touch what it was like living there.ā
Why do you want to write fiction?
The most important thing about historical fiction is that it is fiction: a story of events that never happened, told āas ifā they did happen. Historians and biographers are bound by the constraints of what can be proved or assumed to have happened, but you have decided, already, that you donāt want to be bound that way. Fiction escapes from the confines of real life so that the reader can ācome homeā with a new, wider sense of what it is to be human: to fear, laugh, cook, have sex, clean teeth, fight, go shopping, worship or dream. Fiction writers deal in the riches of what we imagine could have happened ā whatās possible, or plausible, or even downright fantastical. So our job is to make our fiction so convincing that the reader āagrees to forgetā that none of this actually happened or, at least, we canāt know if it did.
| | Key idea: write what you want, and make us believe you know it |
Have you ever been told that you should āwrite what you knowā? That command has probably depressed you or made you cross. Many of us arenāt interested in writing explicitly about our direct experience, but for a story to work on the reader it needs to have a similar smell of authenticity, a sense of ārealityā. In other words, if you want to write historical fiction, or, indeed, speculative, fantasy or science fiction, then the motto has to be, āWrite what you want, and make us believe ā at least while weāre reading ā that you know it.ā
Settle yourself and, using a watch or a timer,
⢠spend one minute writing down everything that you can see
⢠then one minute writing down everything you can hear
⢠a minute of everything you can feel
⢠a minute of what you can smell
⢠a minute of taste
⢠and finally a minute of whatās called kinaesthesia: how your shoulder knows that youāve got your head cocked to one side, the pressure between your knees where youāve crossed them, the way the table-edge presses into your wrist.
Itās important that you do the senses in that order: sight ā sound ā touch ā smell ā taste ā body sense, and that you donāt let yourself give up before each minute is up: patiently staying with not-knowing-what-to-write is important because thatās when the creative mind gets a chance to work.
Now, close your eyes and imagine your way back into the historical time and place of a story you want to write. Donāt worry if you feel you donāt know it very well yet, just let your imagination rip. Open your eyes and do exactly the same exercise for that time and place.
| | Focus point: we experience the world through our bodies, with all six senses |
Cognitive science explains that when weāre trying to decide whether something is true or not, we test it against our own physical and mental experience. So an important way of getting your reader to āagree to forgetā that this story isnāt actually ārealā is to engage their own sense-experience and use it to serve your story. You may not know, or need to know, the precise name of that rope far overhead at the top of the mizzen mast: you do need to evoke the scrubbed, salt-soaked deck-planks under our bare feet, and the way the shipās movement keeps rolling us towards the side.
Why do you want to write historical fiction?
By definition you canāt have experienced the world you want to write, which makes it harder to imagine and recreate the lives in it. So why do you want to write historical fiction? To help you to make writerly choices, ask yourself what your reasons are:
⢠To explore lives that until recently werenāt recorded at all, or only by educated, white men: the lives of women, servants, children, immigrants, convicts, slaves, the marginal, the mad, the strange, the oppressed. (The Long Song by Andrea Levy)
⢠To explore the inner life and subjective experience of people whose outer life is well recorded: kings and queens, the rich and powerful, the famous and the infamous, men and women who shaped the worlds they knew, or discovered new ones. (Wolf Hall by Hilary Mantel)
⢠To evoke a famous event in history, and what it was like to live through it. (The Siege by Helen Dunmore)
⢠To explore the past lives you sense in old buildings and landscapes and bring them to full life. (Stone Angel by Barry Unsworth)
⢠To evoke a particular time in history which has a very strong atmosphere and dynamic which you want to capture. (Pure by Andrew Miller)
⢠To explore fundamental human drives, desires and dilemmas, by stepping away from the clutter and close-up familiarity of the modern world. (Rites of Passage by William Golding and its sequels in the āTo the Ends of the Earthā trilogy)
⢠To explore modern drives, desires and dilemmas, by stepping sideways from a specific modern world to look at how all humans are shaped by their circumstances. (Restoration by Rose Tremain)
⢠To write about sex and love with more at stake: with more barriers of law and custom before two people can get together; when thereās no contraception and no divorce; when everyone knows that Hell is waiting for sinners. (The Far Pavilions by M. M. Kaye)
⢠To write about violence and death when both are closer: when death is only a swordās-length or witchās curse away; when small wounds can kill you; when honour is sometimes more important than life; when you need a priest before you can die without fear. (Master and Command...