1
The power of self-projection
This chapter helps you to:
⢠Understand that loud self-promotion is not the only way to get noticed
⢠See the difference between selling and communicating
⢠Understand why itâs often hard to talk about yourself
⢠Explore why introverts and extroverts operate very differently
⢠See that self-projection is not just for extroverts, but a vital part of getting results
What is self-projection?
This question may be running through your mind right now, especially if youâre the kind of reader this book was written for. This guide serves as an antidote to the bookshelves of material out there that teach you how to be a smooth networker and a great self-publicist. Perhaps youâre the type that finds any chance to talk about yourself like pushing against an open door â a welcome chance to âwowâ, to make people smile and feel engaged? More likely, you find it hard work; for some itâs a nightmare.
Imposing your personality on others is a trend that permeates modern society. Psychologist Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic writes in Confidence: Overcoming Low Self-Esteem, Insecurity, and Self-Doubt about a long-term survey of US college students. In the 1950s, 12 per cent described themselves as âan important personâ; by the 1980s no less than 80 per cent made the same claim. Other studies point to the rise of digital narcissism, including extensive disclosure of personal information and the ever-present âselfieâ. In 2010 researchers at Western Illinois University looked at students who use Facebook, identifying such traits as âself-absorption, vanity, superiority, and exhibitionistic tendenciesâ and a âwillingness to manipulate and take advantage of othersâ.
This book is about self-projection. That isnât the same as self-promotion, which is about wanting to impose yourself on other people. To be clear about the behaviours we are discussing:
1 Self-promotion is the action of promoting or publicizing yourself or your activities, explicitly, often with some force.
2 Self-assertion in its most negative sense is about asserting your superiority; in its most positive sense it is about vocalizing your rights, claims and opinions.
3 Narcissism, according to the Oxford English Dictionary, is âa grandiose view of oneâs own talents and a craving for admirationâ. This self-regarding behaviour is often about attracting empty praise and avoiding objective feedback.
4 Other kinds of egotistical self-centred behaviours are easy to spot â believing that the world is all about you and itâs not worth listening to anyone else, or putting your own interests first.
5 Self-projection is something very different.
You will find the word âprojectionâ used differently elsewhere. Psychologists talk about projection as an unconscious transfer of desires or impulses to another person, as in âitâs your fault I had to shout at youâ. In this book I am using âself-projectionâ in a slightly unconventional but very literal way â like an image projected onto a screen. The screen is the community of people you want to share information with. What you project is what you decide to show on that screen.
Think of the different ways in which you project yourself. This might be in great detail (for example, in a CV), or whatever pops out of your mouth at a party when someone says ânow tell me about yourselfâŚâ (see Chapter 3 for the pros and cons of the Elevator Pitch). It could be in everyday conversation. How much of what you say is remembered? What will others say about you when youâre not around? My working definition of self-projection is: how you help others understand and remember important things about you.
Why self-promotion doesnât have to be the norm
Pushing yourself forward in a âme-firstâ style seems widespread and has acquired an air of social acceptability. In her book Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Canât Stop Talking Susan Cain reports that during the 1920s people were invited to believe that success and better health could be obtained simply by acquiring charm and avoiding an inferiority complex. Cain argues that society has a âcultural bias towards extrovertsâ and ânowadays we tend to think that becoming more extroverted not only makes us more successful but also makes us better peopleâ. She shows how in US colleges, outgoing, assertive behaviours are reinforced through praise; students feel they will receive lower marks if they do not impose their personalities in a group setting.
This creates huge tensions for individuals from cultures that see such behaviour as crass or rude. Studies by psychologist Robert McCrae show that personality types are not distributed evenly across the world â a much lower rate of extroversion is found in East Asia compared to Western countries. Japanese and Chinese students attending Western business schools can find that their quieter manner is misunderstood in team discussions. Their comparatively gentle approach arises from a concern not to embarrass or outshine other people; an uninformed observer might see it as a lack of enthusiasm or assertiveness.
Cain outlines the value that introverts bring to a range of contexts and roles, arguing that thoughtfulness is a helpful and undervalued component of business decision-making. Many writers today share her notion of the ambivert â someone in the middle ground between extrovert and introvert. Some psychologists argue that a large part of the population occupies this space, and recent writing offers a range of strategies to help quiet and mid-zone people rethink the way they interact with the world â and to find an operating style that both feels true to who they are and gets them the results theyâre looking for.
Party animals vs. wallflowers
Some people are naturally comfortable with self-projecting; others need to work at it. Where you sit on the extrovert/introvert scale depends on the starter kit youâve been given from the gene pool. Extroverts generally love company, introverts less so. Introverts prefer to think then speak after they have processed what they are going to say; extroverts often say âI donât know what I am thinking until I have explained it to someone elseâ.
Rather than risk inadequate definitions, Iâm turning to a trusted friend who understands psychometric testing better than anyone I know. Business psychologist Stuart Robertson is author of the Quintax personality questionnaire (sr-associates.com).
Introversion and extroversion
In my personal view, introversionâextroversion is a broad domain in personality which includes a number of components influencing how we act and interact with people and situations. Each component has a âpolarityâ with roughly opposite behaviours at each end. For example, being relatively friendly and relaxed about approaching people (extrovert pole) has its opposite in being more independent, and less energized by social contact, even a little aloof (introvert pole). Extroverts are more interested in making and maintaining social contacts; introverts prefer self-reliance.
We might think about where people derive energy â extroverts do so from the outer world of action and social connection, introverts from the inner world of reflection and ideas. When it comes to risk-taking and adventurousness, extroverts often have a âdo-think-doâ cycle where introverts may adopt a more cautious âthink-do-thinkâ cycle. Extroverts tend towards spontaneity, liveliness and even an impulsive approach to decisions while introverts take a more prudent, thoughtful approach.
Different levels of comfort with self-disclosure are also evident. Extroverts are often more open with others about their feelings, introverts more private and selective about who they share with, and how much information they feel comfortable imparting and receiving.
We may show broadly introverted or extroverted styles â or a balance between the two, sometimes in apparently contradictory ways. For example, an adventurous person may turn out to be relatively self-reliant and less sociable. Or an outgoing person seems risk-averse in action, perhaps shy in less familiar social settings. Other examples include the serious academic who inspires admiration through unexpected humour, and the shy actor.
While they permeate our whole approach to people and things, extroversion and introversion rarely exist in pure or consistent forms. They are not simply about whether one likes social contact. They help condition what we feel is the most appropriate and desirable way to behave, moment by moment in the world.
In a climate where introversion is sometimes seen as a form of weakness, you need to remember that both extroversion and introversion have their strengths. Itâs also important to note that shyness and introversion are not the same thing.
âShyness is the fear of social disapproval or humiliation, while introversion is a preference for environments that are not overstimulating. Shyness is inherently painful; introversion is not.â
Susan Cain
Iâm happy to talk about any subject except myself
Some people are relatively good in social situations, but hate talking about themselves. What makes people react so differently to the same context? Shyness, self-esteem, and confidence are important factors. You may find it easier to talk about a product, service or idea than talk about yourself. Actors often say they can speak the words of a playwright with great confidence, but some find it hard to appear in public âout of roleâ, as themselves. So this difficulty appears to be partly about the role you occupy, and partly about subject matter â the things you have to talk about.
Legitimate solutions come from two angles. One is about thinking, the other about behaving (see âthinking and behavingâ in Chapter 2). Thinking differently can be about standing back from yourself and acquiring objectivity. It can be about reframing (for example, operating as if youâre doing things on someone elseâs behalf). It can also be about taking the focus away from yourself and your anxieties. These are some of the strategies youâll discover in this book.
Behavioural change is also powerful; donât underestimate the power of experimentation. You can get better at self-projection even if youâre relatively shy â repeated exposure to situations where you need to talk about yourself makes the process feel easier and more natural.
How âselling yourselfâ gets in the way
As you will read in the pages ahead, one thing that goes wrong for people trying to make an impact is starting with the idea that they should be selling themselves. As Chapter 3 explains, itâs the dominant message in most advice about networking and personal branding. And itâs completely wrong.
Most people dislike being on the receiving end of a sales process. You immediately associate it with cold selling â the telephone interruption when youâre at home relaxing, or the fundraiser who blocks your path with a cheery but determined expression. When buying something youâre more open to a salesperson who finds out about your needs rather than one who tells you what you want â building curiosity rather than pushing a sale. Average sales training is about communication; excellent sales training is about asking questions.
If you feel youâre being sold to, you sense that youâre the second most important person in a conversation. You feel under unwelcome pressure. Itâs okay to be sold to when youâve given your permission and you can choose the setting. For example, nobody likes being sold to in a social context. Research in 2012 from ExactTarget showed that only 4 per cent of social media users in the US would look at Facebook to find a promotional deal, even from companies that have been given permission to send them offers. It stands to reason that youâre going to be more resistant to being pitched at when youâre enjoying yourself â so meeting someone at a party who insists on explaining the benefits of his services is a big turn-off.
âOvertly selling yourself is just embarrassing for you and embarrassing for the person listening to you. People put up all kinds of barriers if they feel theyâre being sold to. Many professionals are developing a completely different approach to selling â sometimes described as a feminine approach â more listening, less broadcasting. I encourage people to learn to talk about what theyâve done with confidence but also with dignity.â
Kate Howl...