Part one
The fundamentals
1
The counselling role
In this chapter you will learn:
- the differences and similarities between counselling and psychotherapy
- what counselling involves
- about the counsellorâclient relationship
- the importance of confidentiality in the counselling setting.
Counselling can take many forms: people receive counselling individually, or have couple counselling or family counselling â when the dynamics between family members will be the focus of the work. The capacity and setting in which counsellors work also varies, ranging from a few hours a week doing voluntary work with an agency or organization to working privately in a professional practice. Some counselling involves working with particular client groups â examples are student counselling and marriage counselling; and some focus on particular problems â for example, medical conditions such as cancer or AIDS, or social problems such as alcohol or drug abuse. To add to the complexity, there are many âschoolsâ of counselling which are informed by their own particular theoretical frameworks. These can, however, be identified and understood by the three core approaches of analytical, humanistic and behavioural perspectives and these will be explored in later chapters.
Given that there has been a proliferation of counselling activity in the past 20 years or so in Western societies, it seems likely that counselling is fulfilling a need that was in the past met by other means. People in the community â family members, neighbours, friends, local doctors and clergy â formed emotional and social support systems for individuals.
Many of us no longer live in supportive communities bound together by religious faith and beliefs. Our world horizons have expanded; the cities where many of us live can feel large and impersonal. Perhaps in seeking counselling we attempt to repersonalize our lives. We take our problems to a place where we feel we will be listened to and where our thoughts and feelings are regarded as important. The role of counselling is ever evolving to meet the challenges of modern social pressures and demands which we often attempt to deal with at cost to our inner world. The role of counselling has been defined by its aims and values. Aims include providing an environment that enables the client to work towards living in a more resourceful and personally fulfilling way. Integrity, respect and impartiality are basic values that are demonstrated throughout the counselling process.
We enter into a counselling relationship when we engage the help of a counsellor in mutual agreement. No one can be forced into a counsellingâclient relationship; a person chooses to have counselling, otherwise it isnât counselling at all. The activity of counselling has been defined in many ways. The following are some of the ways that counselling can help people resolve problems or help people live their lives in a more insightful, fulfilling way. Counselling can help people:
- to clarify whatâs important in their lives
- to get in touch with their inner resources
- in the exploration of feelings, thoughts and meanings particular to them
- by offering support at times of crisis
- by offering support during developmental and transitional periods
- to work through âstuckâ issues â this might involve integrating childhood experiences
- to reach a resolution of problems.
Insight
People are a lot more resourceful and resilient than they think and counselling can help them reconnect with their coping side.
Psychotherapy and counselling: where they converge and where they differ
The terms counselling, psychotherapy and therapy often seem to be used in an interchangeable way, their differences unclear to the uninitiated. In particular, the use of the term âtherapyâ is widespread. A dictionary of psychology would define therapy using the words: âtreatment of disease or disorderâ and âto make betterâ. If we look at the word âdiseaseâ in two parts, dis and ease, we see that it refers to the state of a person who is no longer at ease with themselves in their physical and/or psychological state. Therapy, or counselling, is a process that helps the client make their life better by focusing on the areas of their lives that cause them problems or distress.
The word âtherapyâ has come to be a generic term used to describe something that is helpful or nurturing in some way or that gives relief from the strains of everyday life, hence such terms as âretail therapyâ. Itâs also used as an abbreviated form of âpsychotherapyâ. The word âtherapistâ is used likewise as an abbreviated form of âpsychotherapistâ, but many counsellors also refer to themselves as therapists.
SIMILARITIES BETWEEN PSYCHOTHERAPY AND COUNSELLING
Psychotherapy and counselling are regarded as separate professions. They sometimes have their own, and sometimes share, professional associations that safeguard the interests of both clients and practitioners. Among the functions that these professional associations serve is the accreditation of training courses and the accreditation of individual practitioners.
Although they have separate identities in the field of therapy, itâs a widely held view that thereâs a lot of overlap between the two. Both use a similar theoretical framework of reference; the same training materials, books and resources are used on courses. This is particularly true when courses are based around the same theoretical âschoolâ or approach; for example, person-centred or psychodynamic. A person may reach professional status as either a person-centred counsellor or psychotherapist, yet their fundamental differences are unclear. The humanistic psychologist Carl Rogers made no clear distinction between the two titles, sometimes referring to himself as a counsellor and at other times as a psychotherapist. Members of both professions work in similar settings, in medical and health centres, doctorsâ surgeries and clinics, and this can add to the confusion. The therapist and writer Windy Dryden, discussing the difference between the two titles in Self and Society, a humanistic psychology journal, jokes that the main difference is âabout ÂŁ8,000 a yearâ. He states that he finds difficulty in making clear distinctions between the two activities.
In his book Ordinary Ecstasy, John Rowan, a humanistic therapist, states, âEvery technique which is used in personal growth and in counselling is also used in psychotherapy and vice versa,â and in 2001 he wrote an article again discussing the subject of difference. He draws attention to the paradox when he writes:
On the one hand psychotherapy and counselling are different â they have different histories and associations, for example; while on the other hand they are the same â for example; they have many identical interventions and involvements. This contradiction â they are the same and they are different â has to be held and maintained.
(CPJ: Counselling and Psychotherapy Journal, August 2001)
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PSYCHOTHERAPY AND COUNSELLING
Length and depth of training
There are a few differences that can be identified at training level. Psychotherapy usually involves longer training. Itâs possible to obtain a certificate in counselling within a few months and a diploma in a year. Thereâs a lack of regularity in awarding such titles; many courses demand two or three yearsâ part-time study to reach diploma level. The varied length, and presumably depth, of training to reach the same status of qualification brings up ethical issues of standards. Itâs obviously important for the consumer â the client â to check out what the counsellorâs qualifications and experience are when embarking on therapy.
Whereas to reach a professional level a counsellor would most likely be expected to train for a period of two to three years part-time, a psychotherapist would have spent a minimum of three years and often longer in training. Psychotherapy training often incorporates a year of working in a health care setting or private practice towards the end of the course, providing case study material for assessment.
Origins
Psychotherapy has been a branch of medicine from the late nineteenth century and psychoanalysis was a major development in psychotherapy in the twentieth century. In the early 1900s another type of psychotherapy called behaviourism associated therapy with psychology and science, mainly because its theories were developed from behavioural experiments. In contrast, counselling is a comparatively new discipline which was developed by psychotherapists such as Carl Rogers in America in the late 1950s. Counselling began in educational settings and was widely applied in marriage guidance, pastoral care and voluntary organizations. It subsequently developed into private practice.
Length of treatment
Itâs generally thought that psychotherapists work long term with clients while counsellors work short term, or in crisis situations. There are no hard and fast rules. Counselling can incorporate both short-term and long-term ways of working; it sometimes begins with a short-term focus and for various reasons results in long-term therapy. Long-term counselling is common and, conversely, itâs not uncommon for psychotherapists to offer brief psychotherapy. Often the two activities are indistinguishable from each other, especially when the practitioners are very experienced. In some situations practitioners are restricted by the limited resources of their workplace; it might be deemed more satisfactory to offer six to eight weeksâ therapy to a greater number of people rather than long-term therapy to only a few.
Depth of work
The extended training of the psychotherapist is designed to equip them to work in more depth with clients. However, although this is used as a focus of training, itâs not always the case that psychotherapists exclusively cater for the client with more difficulties. It does seem true to say, as a general rule, that while the counsellor sees a client once a week for a single session, the psychotherapist might see a client two or more times in a week.
Personal therapy for trainees
Both professions require trainees to have personal therapy for the duration of the course. A psychotherapist in training, who is expecting to see individual clients two or more times a week, is usually required by the conditions of their course to have the corresponding amount of personal therapy throughout the training. The same applies to the counsellor whoâs training with a view to seeing individuals once a week; they too will require personal therapy once a week for the duration of the course, although this requirement doesnât necessarily apply to shorter courses.
The counselling role
Counselling can take many forms:
- doctors refer patients to counsellors who practise alongside them in their surgeries
- teachers and youth workers will often direct young people to counselling agencies for help
- counsellors are called to accidents and disaster areas to counsel the victims and their families
- individuals seek counselling for themselves for all kinds of reasons
- counselling is used in a variety of settings: in education, in pastoral care and increasingly in industry.
The role counselling plays in society is increasingly multifaceted and always supportive. Counselling now seems to be very much a part of our lives, no longer regarded as a luxury or indulgence. Therapy is seen for the mo...