A Quite Impossible Proposal

How Not to Build a Railway

Andrew Drummond

• Publisher: Origin
• Year: 2020
• Print ISBN:
  9781912476886
• eBook ISBN:
  9781788852715
• Topic: Technology & Engineering
• Subtopic: Modern History
• Index: Technology & Engineering

By the author of An Abridged History, "a detailed examination of an overlooked chapter in Scotland's transport history" ( The Scotsman).
In the 1890s, the people of north-west Scotland grew tired of Government Commissions sent to consider a railway to Ullapool. Despite rock-solid arguments in favor of such a railway, neither government nor the big railway companies lifted a finger to build one. Against the recommendations of its own advisers, the Scottish Office dismissed the project as "a quite impossible proposal."
This book tells the whole sorry tale of the attempt to improve transportation in the north-west Highlands and the resulting government inquiries, set against the region's economic and social problems and civil unrest in the crofting communities. Stories, facts and figures have been unearthed from the archives of government departments and railway companies, from local people's letters and petitions, from contemporary newspapers and from the plans prepared for the hoped-for railways. Other unbuilt railways to the north-west coast are also described.
But this story is not just about planned railways that were never built. It is about the frustrations of the people of the Highlands in the face of government incompetence, railway-company obstructionism, local rivalries and the struggle against the historical injustice of land ownership.
"Delves deep into the archives to reveal an astonishing story of establishment incompetence and indifference—and some west coast skullduggery—contriving to thwart the energy and enthusiasm of locals keen to share in the benefits which railways had brought to other Highland communities." — RailScot

Table of contents

• Cover
• Title
• Copyright
• Contents
• List of Illustrations
• Acknowledgements
• Introduction
• 1. ‘A Right to Improved Communications’
• 2. ‘We Must Speak the Truth to All Men’
• 3. ‘Our Trusty and Well-Beloved Commissioners’
• 4. ‘The Railway Would Be the Making of the Place’
• 5. ‘Encumbering Rocks and Great Hilliness’
• 6. ‘Bodies of Distinguished Strangers’
• 7. ‘The Day for Promises, Evasion and Trifling is Past’
• 8. ‘A Railway Terminus on the Moon’
• 9. ‘Zeal and Enterprise’
• 10. ‘Imprisonment With or Without Hard Labour’
• 11. ‘Unsatisfactory from the Very Beginning’
• 12. ‘The Luxury of a Steam-Tramway’
• 13. ‘Pestilential Robber Barons’
• 14. ‘Difficulties in Paying the Fare’
• 15. ‘Not an Economic Proposition’
• 16. ‘National Duty and National Policy’
• Appendices
• Chronology
• Notes
• Bibliography
• Index
• Picture Sections