CHAPTER ONE
THE TROUBLE WITH CHANGE
I HAD A CUSTOMER, Jim (not his real name), who paid me $50,000 for a year to help him implement the changes he wanted to make to grow his company profitably. We conducted weekly meetings and many phone calls with his team, where we discussed the specific issues he faced and how to move the business forward. I loved working with him since he was a sharp guy who knew his industry and what his customers wanted. One day, while waiting for him in his office, I reflected on what we had accomplished working together. My conclusionâabsolutely nothing! I suddenly realized he did not follow a single word of advice Iâd given him and only took a few of the action steps we mutually agreed upon.
Every time weâd meet, Jim enthusiastically agreed that things needed to change. However, when it was time to act and follow the new, agreed-upon path, he hesitated. He stalled. He made excuses. He ultimately blamed me. This confused me because he strongly supported the need for change, yet he could barely get past the first step. I wondered why heâd initially hired me to help enact changes.
None of this made sense. Jim was an intelligent and logical entrepreneur who ran a somewhat successful company. He earned enough to support his family and their lifestyle and was smart enough to know his company was stuck and it needed to improve to get to the next level. Jim even realized he needed outside support from someone like me to make change happen. Plus, he was aware of his strengths and weaknesses as a leader and manager of his business.
And stillânothing actually changed. I later learned I wasnât alone in my experience. Jim frequently sought highly paid advice from sources like me but rarely followed any of it.
Why this sounds so familiar
Unfortunately, over the past 20 years working with small business owners, Iâve met too many Jims. It puzzled me why people would pay for expensive advice but use so little of it.
As I said in the Introduction, these experiences drove me to search for the answers. And Iâve uncovered several reasons why the struggle with change is so common:
1 People try to âbuyâ change.
I sell inexpensive online video courses to small business owners who donât have the resources to hire me personally or want to learn more after theyâve attended one of my events. Unfortunately, after selling many of these courses, I realized that 90% of the people who bought the system never started the first module!
Iâm not saying they never completed the course. We all start things we never finish. I mean, they never even signed in to start one class even after paying for it. And they didnât ask for their money back. When I first noticed this, it shocked me. Why would anyone pay for a class and not start it? And if they never used it, why wouldnât they ask for their money backâespecially when I offer a lifetime âno questions askedâ money-back guarantee?
After talking to many of these non-users, I realized they thought buying the course was the equivalent of taking the key action to make the change. As a result, in their mind, no further action was required on their part. In other words, by purchasing the course, they thought theyâd started to make the change. And if they still canât change, they can say that the course âdid not workâ for them!
In other cases, after they purchased the class, their desire to change faded, and they did not want to admit their lack of effort to themselves and were embarrassed to ask for a refund since they never started the course.
As silly as this seems, it happens more often than youâd thinkâespecially with small business owners. Even in my consulting practice, customers think just by paying to work with me, they are making a change. These business owners seem to be satisfied paying to work toward change instead of taking the difficult steps actually to change. Unfortunately, this is a very expensive way never to change.
Working with me is their âproof â they tried to change, but it did not work. Their excuse: âI wanted to change. I hired a small business expert to help me, but even he couldnât get the company to change.â
While this is not reality, it helps them stay in their comfort zone. They convince themselves that âit is better to have tried and failed than not to have tried at all.â They then retreat to the comfort of doing the same old same oldâeven though itâs not really working for them.
2 People donât want to do âmore workâ even if it results in positive change.
Intellectually, these small business owners know their companies need to change, but they are stuck. Doing the same things, the same ways, has produced enough success enabling them to keep going without making the drastic changes theyâd need to get more than the same mediocre results. They may be stuck in a rut, but theyâre actually comfortable there. And it doesnât take any extra effort to remainâitâs become easy and routine for them. Plus, theyâre not experiencing severe financial distress, so nothing forces them to put in the additional work to get on a different path.
Change is hard by itself, and altering long-practiced habits is even more challenging. But, given a choice, people will stick to the path theyâre currently on; itâs just easier that way. Remember Newtonâs First Law of Motion: âAn object at rest stays at rest, and an object in motion stays in motion with the same speed and in the same direction unless acted upon by an unbalanced force.â I come into their companies as that unbalancing force, but ultimately when I leave, business owners stay where they were, headed in the same direction they were going before.
3 They are not in enough pain.
People only change when they are in so much physical, emotional, or financial pain that changing outweighs the fear of the unknown that change may bring. I have long believed people only buy a new product or service when they are in pain. Remember, consumers will always pay more for painkillers than vitamins.
The COVID-19 pandemic of 2020 forced many of us to pivot in a direction we never thought weâd take, but we had no choice when life as we knew it collapsed. In March of 2020, as the fear of the virus ramped up, supermarket shelves were empty, and we would eat whatever we could buy. For me, fear of eating unknown or unappetizing foods was better than going hungry.
These owners do not heed my advice because things in their companies are faring well enough that they can afford to keep doing it the way they have always done it. Not making a change will not drastically reduce their income or put them out of business. They are comfortable enough where they are without doing anything different.
4 They fear any change, especially the unknown.
Regardless of the future, these owners are comfortable continuing along the same path. They fear change will make business more difficult for them going forward. Although their companies are far from perfect, the status quo is always an easier path to travel. Remember the idiom; âBetter the devil you know than the devil you donâtâ? In other words, even if youâre stuck, youâre better off sticking with the familiar than changing and plunging into the unknownâinto what may be a disaster. Current comfort is always king.
As Iâve grown older, I have experienced this in my own life. The list of things I simply will not do grows bigger. I tell myself my body no longer allows me to do that. A great example is my karate practice over the last 20 years. As Iâve advanced through the black belt ranks, the curriculum got more difficult. This included doing more sweeps, falls, sparring and rolls. While I was never good at this to begin with, as I aged, I stopped doing these parts or pretended to do them. I reasoned it was no longer âsafeâ for me. Finally, my teacher, Jun Shihan Nancy, told me practicing karate this way was unacceptable. She understood that while these moves might be physically challenging, doing something was better than doing nothing. She told me that you must practice an accommodation that at least mimics the move that is safe for you. Doing something breaks the habit of doing nothing and forces change.
In fact, many small business owners who start as innovators stop taking risks because they fear change. For example, I sold my last large company in 1999 during the internet bubble. This was after I failed in my first two ventures, where I went out of business in one and was kicked out of the other by my partners.
After the sale, I didnât start another full-blown operational business because, having gone through so many ups and downs in the 1990s, I was afraid to take another big risk. Selling allowed me to pay the bank the $1.3M I owed them, build a healthy nest egg to pay for my childrenâs college tuition, plus much more. So, I just was not willing to take another large-scale risk. While I have been fortunate to have done well financially over the past 20 years, I could not hit another sm...