Thief

Maureen Gibbon

• Publisher: Atlantic Books
• Year: 2010
• Print ISBN: 9781848871847
• eBook ISBN: 9781848877603
• Subtopic: Women in Fiction

Taut, unpredictable and compelling. - Vogue One lazy summer, Suzanne escapes her life in the city for a long holiday in the countryside. She rents a cabin in the woods, and places a personal ad in the newspaper: "Great kisser, good listener." Among the several replies to her ad, one stands out. An ordinary letter, unremarkable in every way, except for the postmark: Stillwater State Prison. The sender is Alpha Breville. A convict, a thief, and a rapist. Perhaps against her better judgement, she writes back to him. But what begins as a remote correspondence quickly evolves into something much more dangerous, exciting, and intimate...

1

BEFORE I MET ALPHA BREVILLE, all I knew about Stillwater, Minnesota, was that antique shops and a cloying quaintness filled its downtown. I’d gone there once on a Prozac-induced spending spree and come home with an ink-stained quilt, a book of Jesse Stuart stories, and about thirty old photographs I’d stolen from various stores and shoved past my jeans into my underwear. The photographs were worthless, but Prozac made me compulsive, and I couldn’t stop myself from falling in love with the old-time faces.

My favorite photo, the one I framed and hung on the wall beside my bed, was of a man who looked to be in his forties, and who struck me as being a country preacher. He wore a dark suit and limp string tie, his expression was patient and sorrowful, and in spite of careful slicking back, his hair sprouted cowlicks at his fore-head and above each ear. Across the bottom of the dirty cream slip that held the photograph, someone had penciled t-h-e-i-f. It was partly that misspelled word that made me fall in love with the photo, and I wondered who had labeled the man: a family member who judged and banished, or the thief himself, giving himself penance by owning up to his misdoing. I decided it was the latter, but probably only because the photographer had tinted the cheeks of the man a faint red, and the color looked like hot shame.

I met Alpha Breville after he (along with a grave digger and an engineer) answered a personal ad I had placed in a weekly paper. When his letter came to me with his prison number as part of the return address, I thought it was laughable that a convict believed he had something to offer me in terms of dating, and I questioned how an inmate at Stillwater state prison even got the $2 the paper charged to forward responses. I thought about throwing away Breville’s letter, but it was somehow impossible to do. Even with the return prison address, the airy white envelope held the promise that all letters held. So I read the thing, and after I did, it seemed the joke was on me, because the letter Alpha Breville wrote to me from Stillwater state prison was no different from the other letters I’d received in response to my ad. There was an explanation of why he had chosen to write (my headline “Great kisser, good listener” caught his eye), followed by a short personal history and accounting of years, a series of questions for me, and a conclusion expressing hope that I would write back. An ordinary letter. I don’t know why that surprised me so much— after all, there is only so much that can go into a letter, and it was in Breville’s best interests to make himself sound like any other man. But it was the ordinariness of his letter that startled me. If what a convict wrote was no different from what other men wrote, maybe he himself was not so different.

Yet something was different. In explaining that he came from a town in western South Dakota, Breville wrote that though he missed his family and the land, he did not miss living there with its isolation. It was a thoughtful observation and one that meant something to me, since I’d spent time in South Dakota and knew how it could feel. But the part of Breville’s letter that really got my attention was the part that came next, his description of a sunset: In thesummer, the sun is the color of orangeade and fierce when it sets. You think it’s going to stay burned in your eyes forever.

It was just a couple of sentences— strings of words. But he was absolutely right. The summer I was out there, the sun really didn’t look like anything natural on this earth, and if I watched it too long as it slowly set behind the flat line of the horizon, I would be blinded to all color for a long time after. Of all the things men had written in their letters— paragraphs about seeking “friendship” or “that special someone,” or clever descriptions of what they liked to do in their spare time— nothing struck me more than Breville’s words about the nuclear-looking South Dakota sun.

Of course, in that first letter Breville didn’t tell me the most important detail: why he was in Stillwater. The omission itself seemed damning, but even as I thought that, I also understood his choice. Either his incarceration would repel me so much it wouldn’t matter what he’d done, or else I would write back and, in doing so, give him an opportunity to explain. It was the only decision he could make, the only gamble he could take, and anyone smart enough to construct a very normal letter would be smart enough to take that chance. After all, I told myself, Rochester didn’t come right out and tell Jane Eyre he had a crazy wife in the attic— he didn’t tell until he had to.

The book was still on my mind because I’d finished the school year with it, teaching it to the seniors. When we got to the section where Bertha’s presence at Thornfield was revealed, most students said they could understand Rochester’s decision to conceal the truth. They believed almost to a person that Jane would never have even “given him a chance” if he’d revealed everything at the outset. When I pressed further, though, and asked them if they didn’t think that such an omission was a type of lie, they uncomfortably agreed it was. But still, they’d said. But still.

In any case, I suppose it was partly because of Jane Eyre that I decided to take things one step further and write back to Breville. And it wasn’t because I had some romantic notion that I was Jane and Breville was Rochester. It’s just that thinking of Jane Eyre made me remember I had enough of my own secrets to know they couldn’t be the first things told.

I’d always been interested in black sheep and underdogs. When I was a young girl, I liked boys with wolfish faces, who had a bit of the hoodlum in them, and my tastes still ran that way. My most recent relationship started when I saw a man get off a bus on Lake Street, and he saw me see him. We circled each other on Hennepin until he came up and began talking to me. I didn’t care that he worked as a dishwasher. I liked his face and his body, and I was glad that he liked mine. Even in my job, where I played the role of maiden aunt, I often went out of my way to help delinquent boys and wayward girls. I saw in those students pieces of myself, but more importantly I tried to see them as they were, with dignity. I believed each of them had a voice and a story, and at least some of them reflected that belief back to me. For instance, last year Danielle Starck wrote on the back of her school picture, Your class was the reason I came to school. The following semester, when she wasn’t my student, she tried to kill herself. I’m not saying I could have stopped her— I was only an English teacher— but maybe I could have helped her. I do know I would have tried.

It was that kind of thinking, in part, that made me give Alpha Breville a chance.

2

THOUGH I WAS INDICATING MY OPENNESS by the very act of writing back to Breville, I thought it would be best if I sounded guarded in my reply. So after my greeting to him, I wrote, “I’m not sure why you answered my ad. I’m looking for someone to date, and you can’t offer me that. Frankly, I don’t know what you can offer anyone. But perhaps we can exchange a few letters. You seem like a thoughtful enough person.”

Even that slight compliment seemed like a risk, however, so I followed it up immediately. “While I understand why you might be reluctant to tell me why you’re in Stillwater, you must know you have to,” I wrote. “I expect complete honesty. Surely you can see the need for it. I have to know how you came to be in prison. If you can’t tell me that, I would prefer you didn’t write back at all.”

I didn’t bother to say that I could find out anything about him I wanted— it was true, even in those days before the Internet. Whatever Breville had done was a matter of public record, and I was sure he knew it. Then I sent off my letter, an ink-jetted copy as de-personalized as I could make it. If he wanted to respond to my question, he could, and if he didn’t, I stood nothing to lose.

When I didn’t hear back for a week, when no plain white envelope with the Stillwater return address showed up in my mailbox, I figured my price— honesty—had been too high for Breville to pay. And I thought it was for the best. What ever the reason was for Breville’s incarceration, I didn’t need the drama. I’d come up north to a rented lake cabin the day school let out, and in the days after I sent my letter to Stillwater, I did all the things I’d driven four hours north to do: I swam, I went for walks around the lake, and I watched birds— loons and eagles, and a great blue heron that crossed so low over the water I could hear its wing-beats. In the afternoons, after the worst of the sun’s burning was over, I took a small pillow down to the dock and slept on the hard boards. I never thought I would be able to sleep in the light and sound and breeze of the day, but I always did. And when I woke— groggy and hot— I’d climb down off the dock and slip into the deliciously cold water. It amazed me that I felt so at ease in a place I’d never been before. Part of me wanted to tell someone about how the days felt, but another part of me wanted to keep it secret. Mostly I just wanted to go on feeling the way I did.

The lack of response from Breville gave me time to think, and I began to believe that my willingness to write to him was just another sign of being adrift. While my work life was stable and pleasant enough, pieces of my personal life were in their usual disarray, and I was glad I hadn’t told any of my friends about writing to Breville, since I knew what their reactions would be. My friend Kate would rush on to another subject, trying to be nonjudgmental yet judging all the time, and Julian would castigate me. He knew everything that had gone on this past year, and why I’d decided to move out of my apartment and put some space between me and my old life in the Cities. “What is wrong with you?” I could hear him asking. “You just got rid of one dangerous asshole. Do you need to invite another into your life?”

To a certain degree he would be right— I did love danger. Adventure. There was a part of me that was content being an English teacher, living in book-lined rooms, writing poetry, hanging out with friends. But sometimes those things didn’t satisfy me, and like most people, I led a double life— and at times even a triple life. I was one person during the week, another with friends, and someone entirely different on weekends when I went out. I said I wanted a healthy relationship with a man, but I did nothing to find one. Instead, I patched together half-relationships and weekly assignations. I did nothing to unite the disparate pieces of my life. But as I always pointed out to Julian, I didn’t want to marry any of the men I dated— I only wanted to kiss them and fuck them. I knew how to draw the line. I also knew writing back to Breville had probably been foolish, and I knew it without any loving, meddlesome friend pointing it out to me.

And then a letter came. And I could tell by the heft of it that Breville had decided to tell me his story.

I didn’t open the letter the way I often opened my mail, right there at the mailbox, or walking the gravel road back to the cabin— I waited until I got inside. I don’t know why. Maybe I didn’t want to read in the bright June sunlight that Breville was a drug dealer, a thief, or convicted of some kind of assault, or maybe I already felt too secretive about the correspondence to begin reading on the public road. All I know is that as I opened the envelope, I tried to ready myself for what I might find. Yet when I started thinking that burglary would be a more acceptable crime than, say, assault, the idea of preparation seemed silly. What ever Breville had done, it had been serious enough to land him in Stillwater, and no amount of rationalizing on my part would change that.

Breville began by thanking me for the opportunity to tell me about himself and then apologized for taking so long to reply to my request. It took me a while to write back because I don’t like to think about the details of my crime, he wrote. But, yes, you are right, you have the right to know.

At nineteen, Breville said, he was a thief and a drinker, “a user and an abuser.” He took any drug he could get his hands on, though he preferred alcohol and marijuana because they were the easiest to get. His only idea of a good time, he said, was when he could get wasted. One night when he had been out drinking and partying with friends, he decided to break into a house in South Minneapolis because he wanted more money.

I was only going to steal what I saw through the window. A TV and a stereo. I didn’t think anyone was at home. But when I got inside the house, the woman who lived there heard me. She came out into the living room to investigate. I didn’t see or hear her at first but then she asked me what I was doing. She was wearing just a robe and I saw part of her breast. That’s when I decided to rape her. I didn’t plan to do it but, I did it.

Breville went on to say that he believed he would not have raped the woman if he hadn’t been drinking that night, but he said he also realized that was no excuse:

I was a different person when I was drinking. Crazy. But that was also part of my crime, or at least part of my sickness. I have been sober for seven years, in a 12-step program. But I doubt I would have changed at all if I hadn’t been sent to prison. I’d be out there running the streets. Or maybe I’d be dead. I don’t know.

Breville told me he received more than the mandatory sentence because he pled innocent to the rape and showed no remorse. Even though police found some of the woman’s possessions in his apartment the morning after the rape, he thought he could beat the charge because his lawyer told him there was no DNA evidence.

I was in denial then about my crime. But I did it. I raped that woman. That is my crime. If you do not want to write me again I will understand. I will more than understand.

After I finished reading Breville’s letter, I let the pages drop to the floor. I didn’t do it to seem dramatic— there was no one there to see the gesture. I dropped the pages because I didn’t want to hold them anymore. Breville had sat in his cell writing the letter— for days, if what he told me was truthful— and now the pages were here in the kitchen of the cabin, and I didn’t want to touch them. I didn’t want that proximity to Breville. I didn’t even want to see his handwriting on the cheap notebook paper.

The letter stayed on the floor for days. I walked past it at first, and then I pushed it under the kitchen table with my foot. I told myself not to think about it, but I did think about it. I thought about it when I was swimming, and when I lay on the dock, reading or writing in my journal. I thought about it when I talked in the yard with Merle, the old man who was renting me the cabin for the summer, and I thought about it as I drank my morning coffee under the birch tree. And what I thought was that the whole thing was a colossal joke, some ridiculous trick the universe was intent on playing on me. I place a personal ad in a paper and a rapist responds. But in a while, that idea passed, too, if only because I knew the universe wasn’t particular enough to single me out. In one way, what had happened was an ugly sort of co-incidence, but in another way, it was predictable enough. One lonely person placed an ad, and another lonely person had answered, and who else could be lonelier than a rapist in Stillwater state prison?

Days after receiving Breville’s letter, I picked it up and read it again. Not because of some sick impulse, as Julian would say, but because I thought maybe the letter represented a different kind of chance— an opportunity, if you will. I picked the letter off the floor because I thought maybe Alpha Breville and I had something to say to each other. I had been raped when I was sixteen, and he had raped when he was nineteen.

We were two sides of a coin.

3

ONCE I DECIDED that Breville and I might have something to say to each other, I could not stop thinking about the idea. If he could tell me why he had raped, maybe I could somehow make sense of the one ejaculation that so transfigured my life. His crime became the very reason to write back to him. Yet I knew the letter I wrote would not be the one he hoped to receive.

“You must be the unluckiest of people to have chosen my ad to respond to,” I began. “I was raped when I was sixteen years old, one week before I turned seventeen.” Then I told him some of the details of my rape and how it had affected me.

I never dated blond men, because my rapist was blond. I couldn’t stand certain smells, because my rapist’s hair and breath had been foul. I had a hard time sleeping beside a man, even if I was in an intimate relationship with him, because I could not let myself relax. I never entirely lost the feeling of dirtiness and infection, perhaps because I had, in fact, been infected with gonorrhea and herpes. I described in detail for him the ulcers and scarring and how, in some fluke, I had spread the virus to one of my eyes and almost lost vision there. I told Breville I still carried a sense of shame about the whole thing, even though it had happened seventeen years ago.

“I cannot say my life was derailed by what happened,” I wrote. “I think I have had success in spite of it. But I think about the experience almost every single day, and I sometimes wonder who I might have been i...

Table of contents

• Cover
• Also by Maureen Gibbon
• Copyright
• Dedication
• Chapter 1
• Chapter 2
• Chapter 3
• Chapter 4
• Chapter 5
• Chapter 6
• Chapter 7
• Chapter 8
• Chapter 9
• Chapter 10
• Chapter 11
• Chapter 12
• Chapter 13
• Chapter 14
• Chapter 15
• Chapter 16
• Chapter 17
• Chapter 18
• Chapter 19
• Chapter 20
• Chapter 21
• Chapter 22
• Chapter 23
• Chapter 24
• Chapter 25
• Chapter 26
• Chapter 27
• Chapter 28
• Chapter 29
• Chapter 30
• Chapter 31
• Chapter 32
• Chapter 33
• Chapter 34
• Chapter 35
• Chapter 36
• Chapter 37
• Chapter 38
• Chapter 39
• ACKNOWLEDGMENTS