part one
1
Mr Timothy Greenhall looked very uncomfortable. I knew why. Iād spent money on the fittings of my Pyrmont office and he was sitting in a well-made chair with his feet on decent carpet and clean windows to look out of. He was facing a clean-shaven, recently barbered man in a fresh shirt sitting behind a desk that had only had one previous owner. True, there was no secretary or receptionist and if he was to get coffee or a drink Iād have to make it. But discomfort was built ināonly a tiny percentage of people ever go into a private detectiveās office and they mostly wish they hadnāt needed to.
āI deliberated long and hard before coming here, Mr Hardy,ā Greenhall said.
I just nodded; nothing else to do with a statement like that.
Greenhall was a tidy-looking man in his late fifties or early sixtiesāneat grey suit, conservative haircut. He was thin in a way that suggested a disciplined life rather than athleticism. He took a deep breath as if he needed oxygen to fuel him for what heād come to say.
āMy son suicided five months ago.ā
I still didnāt say anything but I arranged my face in what I hoped was a sympathetic expression.
āPatrick was nearly thirty years oldāthe upper limit statistically for the cohort of young male suicides.ā
Statistics? Cohort? I thought. An accountant? He hadnāt mentioned his profession when heād made the appointment earlier in the day by phone.
āYouāve done some research,ā I said.
āA lot. Iām a businessman and I look very carefully at all the conditions and circumstances before I take any action.ā
Again, I thought a nod would do.
āI know why Patrick killed himself. He was depressed; his affairs were in chaos, he was worried about his sexuality. We were . . . estranged.ā
āThatās a heavy load to carry.ā
āYes, and Patrick wasnāt designed to carry heavy loads. He was what people call sensitive.ā
I was getting a new fix on Greenhall. At first Iād thought he was a dry stick but his last sentence was charged with emotion. It was loving, critical and ironic all at once.
āDo you have doubts about whether your son suicided?ā
āNo, it was cut and dried. He shot himself through the temple.ā
Greenhall surprised me again by demonstrating the action, right-handed with a cocked thumb and a pointed finger. He left the hand up at his head for what seemed like a long time before dropping it and giving a dismissive wave.
āHe made a good job of it. For all his . . . youthful sensitivity and other problems he was an efficient person, like me. He liked things neat and tidy. Shit!ā
He broke down then; his shoulders shook, sobs bobbed his head up and down and his eyes streamed with tears. He clenched his fists and babbled a muffled stream of swearwords with spittle flying from his lips. I got out of my chair to offer some help and he gestured for me to stay where I was. I pushed a box of tissues towards him but he took the handkerchief he had folded neatly in the top pocket of his suit coat and used it to blot his tears.
He lifted his tear-stained face. āDo you have any children?ā
āOne, a daughter, and two grandchildren. Have you . . .?ā
āPatrick was my youngest and his health was delicate in his early years. We spoiled him of course, gave him everything and . . . in the end, I suppose . . . nothing.ā
I had to wonder where this was going. Seeing an apparently composed, even chilly, man break down wasnāt something entirely new to me, but from what heād said I couldnāt see how I could be of use. Maybe he just needed to talk and I was wasting time and not making any money.
āThatās being very hard on yourself, Mr Greenhall. I . . .ā
He made a physical effort to pull himself together. He straightened his back and shoulders, shoved the damp handkerchief into a pocket and looked me in the eye. Heād made a remarkable recovery and now it was as if heād never admit that heād let himself go.
āI want to hire you, Mr Hardy, to find whoever it was who supplied my son with a gun.ā
He was all manned-up now, tears wiped away and forgotten.
āAnd?ā I said.
He smiled and there it was again, a complete change. He had a winning smile that reminded me of great actors like Rod Steiger and Jack Nicholsonāa smile that won you over although you knew you didnāt know exactly what it meant and couldnāt trust it.
āI want you to kill him. Or her.ā
2
Timothy Greenhall was a very wealthy man. He headed a company that made high-tech medical equipment and held a couple of patents for devices heād invented which were used in operating theatres all over the world. He told me this after making his proposal and watching me shake my head.
āYouāre not serious,ā I said.
He straightened his jacket and tie, which had got a bit rumpled. āNo, I just wanted to try to shock you but I see youāre unshockable, which is good. Have you had such propositions put to you before?ā
āAnd worse,ā I said.
āAll right. What I want is for you to find out who supplied the gun and see that the person is prosecuted to the full extent of the law. I imagine a pretty heavy sentence would be the result.ā
āItād be a toss-up,ā I said. āAssisting a suicide is a criminal offence but itās a dodgy area with voluntary euthanasia advocates in the mix . . .ā
āIām in favour of voluntary euthanasia.ā
āSo am I,ā I said. āSo is almost everyone except gutless politicians and God-botherers, but you know what I mean. Lawyers can do all sorts of things when thereās an ethical dimension to play around with.ā
āWhat about possession of and supplying an unregistered gun?ā
āThatās a crime, certainly, but not exactly a hanging matter. Was the gun unregistered?ā
āSo the police said.ā
āWhat sort of gun was itārifle, pistol, what?ā
āIāve no idea.ā
āYou didnāt see it?ā
āNo. I got a nearly hysterical . . . no, to be honest I shouldnāt say that . . . an emotional call from Patrickās partner, but by the time I got to the flat the police were there and a swarm of other people. Patrick had been covered up and it was pandemonium. At the coronial inquest a police witness referred to an unregistered . . . weapon, I think he said, but I was busy comforting herāAliciaāand I scarcely followed the proceedings. If the make of the gun was mentioned I didnāt take it in.ā
After so long in the job, suspicion is an automatic reflex, and I had to ask what was a frequent question.
āWhy have you come specifically to me with this?ā
He told me heād had business dealings with a guy Iād worked for a few years back on a case involving a shooting accident.
āI was told you seemed to know about guns and used police contacts in your investigation with some success. I thought you could be the man to handle this.ā
āIād have to probe into your sonās life, talk to his partner and friends. I might turn up things you wouldnāt want to hear.ā
āHeās dead. Iāll never see him again. Thatās as bad as bad can be. People talk about closure. I always thought it was sentimental nonsense but I was wrong. Thatās what I want, closure. Call it revenge, if you like, I donāt care.ā
āThereās nothing wrong with revenge.ā
āI agree and Iām glad you think so. Will you help me, Mr Hardy?ā
I was interested. Gun control was constantly in the news with drive-by shootings happening regularly and a conservative government trumpeting its law-and-order credentials while allowing amateur hunting in national parks. I had no liking for guns and regretted it every time Iād had to use one. Iād once thrown a pistol as far as I could out into Balmoral Bay and that pretty well summed up what I thought of firearms, but Greenhallās case presented interesting possibilities.
I had him sign my standard contract and he agreed to do an electronic transfer of a sizeable retainer to my bank account. I got the full name of his dead son, the partnerās name and her address. Heād worked as what Greenhall termed āa sort of administratorā at the Powerhouse Museum in Sydney.
āWhat about friends?ā I asked.
āI wouldnāt know. I doubt if he had any, but his . . . partner . . . would be able to tell you that.ā
He gave me the date of his sonās death five months before, and said heād stewed about the matter until heād come to this decision. From memory, Iād been up in the Northern Territory on a case at around that time. I told him I hadnāt seen any press reports of the suicide.
āIt coincided with a couple of headline news stories,ā he said. āA big jewel robbery, I believe. That, and a major art scandal. What was it? A fake Old Master or the theft of a real one? I canāt remember. We tried to keep the press, those that were interested, at bay, and not encourage the sort of lurid speculation that goes on in these matters.ā
I got his details and told him Iād submit regular reports on my investigation by email.
āLast thing, your family. Do you have other children?ā
āYes, a daughter, Kate, unmarried. She lives at Mount Victoria in the Blue Mountains. She runs an organic plant nursery.ā
He gave me her address and contact details but when I asked him what sort of terms the brother and sister were on he said he didnāt know. The Greenhall family obviously wasnāt harmony incorporated.
āDoes your wife know youāre intending to pursue this?ā
He shook his head. āShe had a breakdown and sheās under treatment at a facility in Nowra. Kate visits occasionally, I believe; sheās got a big heart, Kate. I pay for it and I go when I can. This . . . event helped to blow a fragile family apart, Mr Hardy.ā
āFragile?ā
āVery. I worked like a slave, twenty-four seven, three hundred and sixty-five days a year to get my business established. I tried to make up for that with . . . material things . . . when Iād succeeded professionally and financially, but it was too late.ā
He gave me the address of the Nowra clinic; we shook hands and I saw him to the door. He walked stiffly and held himself erect, like a man who was determined that nothing was going to tear him apart because heād been there, suffered and survived, and had bolted himself back together.
I did the web searches you do as soon as the client is out the door. Greenhallās company, Precision Instruments Pty Ltd, had been the recipient of awards and commendations from the medical profession, export organisations and economists. It employed a large number of highly qualified people at a state-of-the-art laboratory and factory complex in Alexandria. Its stock price was high and several articles in professionally related magazines made the point that the company had prospered without government subsidy.
A trawl through the print media sites turned up coverage of Patrick Greenhallās suicide. An ambulance and the police had been called to a flat in Balmain, where a man had been found with a gunshot wound to the head. He could not be resuscitated. Names emerged over a series of low-key reportsāTimothy Greenhall, Patrick Greenhall, his partner Alicia Troy. The coroner found that Patrick William Greenhall had committed suicide while the balance of his mind was disturbed. As the father had said, his sonās death had low news value, especially with other more sensational things going on.
Unusually, there were no photos. It looked as though the G...