Reinhold and Fichte in Confrontation

A Tale of Mutual Appreciation and Criticism

Martin Bondeli, Silvan Imhof, Martin Bondeli, Silvan Imhof

• Publisher: De Gruyter
• Year: 2020
• Print ISBN: 9783110681871
• eBook ISBN: 9783110685077
• Edition: 1
• Topic: Philosophy
• Subtopic: Idealism in Philosophy

From the early 1790s until after the turn of the century, a very productive but also controversial exchange took place between Reinhold and Fichte. Though many key aspects of post-Kantian philosophy were discussed, the philosophical confrontation between Reinhold and Fichte is most instructive for the understanding of post-Kantian philosophy.

The exchange started when Fichte published his verdict on Reinhold's Elementarphilosophie and disapproved of its fundamental principle. In 1794 Fichte challenged Reinhold by presenting his Wissenschaftslehre. Reinhold was not convinced of Fichte's foundation of philosophy at first, but announced that he accepted the Wissenschaftslehre in 1797. While Reinhold and Fichte officially collaborated in the following three years, tensions concerning fundamental questions were still present. When Reinhold adopted Rational Realism, his relation to Fichte deteriorated and the exchange between the two finally ended.

The contributions in the present collection focus on the central systematic issues at the different stages of the confrontation between Fichte and Reinhold, thereby illuminating questions that are essential to the understanding of the evolution of post-Kantian German philosophy.

Table of contents

• Title Page
• Copyright
• Contents
• Abbreviations
• Introduction
• “Wie der blinde von der Farbe.” Reinhold’s Misappropriation of the Wissenschaftslehre:A Narrative
• „Gehe der Unbedingtheit des Ich nach…“ Fichtes erste Auseinandersetzung mit Reinhold und die Entwicklung des Grundsatz-Gefüges in den Eignen Meditationen über ElementarPhilosophie
• Reinhold’s Principle of Consciousness and Fichte’s Third Principle An Attempt at a Reduction
• “There is No Will without Choice” Reinhold and Fichte on Autonomy after Kant
• Reinhold’s Transition to Fichte
• The “Weak Side of Critical Philosophy” or Why Reinhold Abandoned his Elementarphilosophie
• Die Freiheit des reinen Wissens Karl Leonhard Reinholds Auffassung der Wissenschaftslehre Fichtes
• Ist Reinhold je Transzendentalphilosoph gewesen?
• Rhythmus and Setzen Fichte’s Answer to Rational Realism
• Contributors
• Index of names