Breaking Images

Damage and Mutilation of Ancient Figurines

Gianluca Miniaci

• Publisher: Oxbow Books
• Year: 2023
• Topic: Social Sciences
• eBook ISBN:
  9781789259162
• Subtopic: History of Ancient Art
• Index: Social Sciences

"…Breaking Images (as engaging as some of the case studies and analyses are) demonstrates that new approaches to archaeological breakage beyond intentionality will be required to generate new insight." – Journal of Anthropological Research

Archaeological remains are ‘fragmented by definition’: apart from exceptional cases, the study of the human past takes into account mainly traces, ruins, discards, and debris of past civilisations. It is rare that things have been preserved as they were originally made and conceived in the past. However, not all the ancient fragmentary objects were the ‘leftovers’ from the past. A noticeable portion of them was part and parcel of the ancient materiality already in the form of a fragment or damaged item. In 2000, John Chapman, with his volume Fragmentation in Archaeology, attracted the attention of scholars on the need to reconsider broken artefacts as the result of the deliberate anthropic process of physical fragmentation. The phenomenon of fragmentation can be thus explored with more outcomes for a category of objects that played an important role inside the society: the figurines. Due to their portability and size, figurines are particularly entangled and engaged in social, spatial, temporal, and material relations, and – more than other artefacts – can easily accommodate acts of embodiment and dismemberment. The act of creation symmetrically also involves the act of destruction, which in turn is another act of creation, since from the fragmentation comes a new entity with a different ontology. Breaking contains the paradigms of life: creation and reparation, destruction and regeneration.

The scope of this volume is to search for traces of any voluntary and intentional fragmentation of ancient artefacts, creating, improving, and sharpening the methods and principles for a scientific investigation that goes beyond single author impression or sensitivity. The comparative lens adopted in this volume can allow the reader to explore different fields taken from ancient societies of how we can address, assess, detect, and even discuss the action of breaking and mutilation of ancient figurines.

Table of contents

• Cover
• Contents
• Contributors
• Preface
• At the dawn of a break: The agency of the damage
• Chapter 1 In the footsteps of Auguste Rodin: Fragmentation is not an end Gianluca Miniaci
• Chapter 2 The meaning of deliberate figurine fragmentation: Insights from the Old and New Worlds John Chapman and Bisserka Gaydarska
• Beyond ritual: When the whole cracks
• Chapter 3 In the beginning: Exploring integrity of anthropomorphic images in prehistoric Europe Elisabetta Starnini
• Chapter 4 When garbage is art: Broken ceramic figural objects from ancient Honduras
• Chapter 5 Parts not wholes: Long histories and negative space analysis Stacy Boldrick
• Chapter 6 Not whole yet holy: Some breakage rituals and their significance in Hinduism and other religions of India Urmi Chanda
• The materiality of the damage: Searching for the intentionality
• Chapter 7 Broken beyond repair. Reflections on the intentionality of breakage and its archaeological identification regarding Naqada period clay figurines Axelle Brémont
• Chapter 8 The materiality of the damage in the faience figurine corpus from late Middle Bronze Age Egypt (1800–1550 BC) Gianluca Miniaci
• Chapter 9 Breaking into pieces: An experimental investigation into fracture behaviours in ceramic female figurines Paulina Wandowicz
• Chapter 10 Intentionality in the breaking. A case study of the intentional damaging of figurines at Neolithic Tell Sabi Abyad (Syria) and Çatalhöyük (Turkey) Monique Arntz
• Chapter 11 Fragmented or intact – Mycenaean figurines and figures in cult and burial contexts Ann-Louise Schallin
• Inside the fragmentation: Exploring methods and technologies
• Chapter 12 Made it for breaking it? Assessing fragmentation of the Lahun figurines (Egypt, MBA II, c. 1800–1700 BC) Vanessa Forte
• Chapter 13 Displaying the fragmented: Damaged and mutilated ancient Egyptian figures from Sir Charles Nicholson’s collection Candace Richards and Michelle F. Whitford
• Chapter 14 Broken collections: A 3D approach to the digital reunification and holistic study of dispersed terracotta figurines assemblages Valentina Vassallo
• Concluding remarks Afterword: Strong at the broken places? Caitlín Eilís Barrett