08
Drawn and Cel Animation
The history of animation is normally written as the history of the animated cartoon, and the history of the animated cartoon is normally written as the creation of an animation âindustryâ by the Walt Disney Studio. While this rightly privileges the place of the Disney organisation in the development of animation as an art and a distinctive production process, it also neglects the animation of the pioneers in the United States, and overstates the âownershipâ of animation as a singularly American phenomenon. Indeed, it may still be the case that all animation both within the United States and elsewhere in the world remains a response to âDisneyâ â aesthetically, ideologically and technically. This is both a tribute â many individuals and studios across the world have aspired to the Disney style â and a model of resistance, challenging and implicitly critiquing the process, design and meaning of the Disney output, at the same time preserving indigenous traditions and other approaches to the art form.
The animated cartoon essentially emerged out of the experiments towards the production of the cinematic moving image. As early as 1798 Etienne Robertson created the Phantasmagoria, a sophisticated âmagic lanternâ to project images, and this was followed by Plateauâs Phenakistiscope in 1833, Hornerâs Zoetrope in 1834, von Uchatiusâ Kinetoscope in 1854, Heylâs Phasmatrope in 1870 and Reynaudâs Praxinoscope in 1877 as devices that in some way projected drawn moving images. With the development of the cinematic apparatus came the first intimations of âanimationâ. At first, they were accidents or trick effects in the work of figures like Georges MĂ©liĂšs and the emergence of âlightning cartooningâ â the accelerated movement of drawings by manipulating camera speeds â particularly in the British context where Tom Merry, Max Martin, Harry Furniss and Lancelot Speed defined an indigenous model of expression related to British pictorial traditions in caricature and portraiture. It was also Britons Albert E. Smith and J. Stuart Blackton, working in the USA, who saw the potential of a specific kind of animation film-making in The Enchanted Drawing (1900) and Humorous Phases of Funny Faces (1906), though these were essentially little more than developments in lightning cartooning.
While stop-motion 3D animation progressed in a number of nations, it was only with the creation of Ămile Cohlâs Fantasmagorie (1908) â a line-drawn animation based on the surrealist principles of the âincoherentâ movement of artists in France â that the 2D animated film was seen to be a distinctive art form.
Cohl was later to work in the USA animating George McManusâs comic strip The Newlyweds (1913), one of a number of popular comic strips that characterised early American cartoon animation, including Krazy Kat, The Katzenjammer Kids and Mutt and Jeff. Winsor McCay, an illustrator and graphic artist, made Little Nemo in Slumberland (1911), based on his own New York Times comic strip, and made one of the first self-consciously reflexive cartoons in the aptly titled Winsor McCay Makes His Cartoons Move (1911). McCayâs influence on the history of animation cannot be understated as he created one of the first instances of the horror genre in The Story of the Mosquito (1912); âpersonalityâ animation in the figure of Gertie the Dinosaur (1914), who featured in an interactive routine with McCay in his vaudeville show; and âdocumentaryâ in an imitative newsreel-style depiction of The Sinking of the Lusitania (1918). McCay had previously suggested that he only wanted to use animation to show things that couldnât be seen in everyday life â dragons, dinosaurs and dreams â but he realised that animation could also recreate things that had not been documented in another way, hence the realistic detail in his Lusitania film. McCay championed the art of animation, but feared, too, that it would become an industry driven by other motives.
8.1
Still from Humorous Phases of Funny Faces â J. Stuart Blackton
Blacktonâs film was essentially a development of the âlightning sketchâ â the speeded-up creation of a hand drawing â but its effects suggested that âanimationâ would soon become a distinctive art form.
8.2
Still from Gertie the Dinosaur â Winsor McCay
Gertie, who featured in Winsor McCayâs vaudeville routine, was arguably the first example of the kind of âpersonalityâ animation much admired and developed by Disney. The dinosaur clearly had an identity and point of view of its own, and was very appealing and amusing to audiences.
A Brief History
As early as 1913, John R. Bray and Raoul BarrĂ© were developing systematic, âindustrialâ processes for the production of animated cartoons using variations of what was to become the âcelâ animation process, where individual drawings, later cels, were created with various stages of a characterâs forward movement, and these were aligned with backgrounds that remained the same, using a peg-bar system: by replacing each stage of the movement and photographing it frame by frame, the illusion of continuous movement occurred. More importantly, a production system was emerging that echoed the economies and hierarchical organisation of Taylorist production processes that characterised the industrial progress of modern America, most notably, in the production of Model T Fords at the Henry Ford car plants. Though the Fleischer Brothers, Paul Terry and Pat Sullivan with Otto Messmer, all emerged as viable producers of cartoons, it was Walt Disney who effectively took the Ford model and created an animation âindustryâ.
With Steamboat Willie (1928), Disney, in the face of increased competition from the technically adept Fleischer Studio, created the first fully synchronised sound cartoon, simultaneously introducing animationâs first cartoon superstar, Mickey Mouse. Within ten years, Disney had made Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937), the first full-length, sound-synchronised, Technicolor animated film, along the way making the seminal Silly Symphonies, including Flowers and Trees (1932), the first cartoon made in three-strip Technicolor; Three Little Pigs (1933); The Band Concert (1935); The Country Cousin (1936); and The Old Mill (1937), all of which made aesthetic, technical and narrative strides in the field. Disney effectively defined animation and created a legacy that all other producers learn from, respond to and seek to imitate or challenge. As Disney made Pinocchio (1940) and Fantasia (1941), the Warner Bros. studio continued its emergence, and following the Disney strike of 1941 (which arguably ended âthe Golden Eraâ of animation), provided a context in which Chuck Jones, Frank Tashlin, Tex Avery, Bob Clampett and Friz Freleng became the new heirs to the animated short. Altogether more urban and adult, the Warner Bros. cartoons were highly inventive, redefining the situational âgagsâ in Disney films through a higher degree of surreal, self-reflexive and taboo-breaking humour. While the Fleischers had Betty Boop, and a strong embrace of Black culture and underground social mores, and Hanna-Barbera had the enduring Tom and Jerry, Warner Bros. had the zany Daffy Duck, the laconic âwise assâ Bugs Bunny and gullible dupes Porky Pig and Elmer Fudd, who became popular and morale-raising figures during the war-torn 1940s and its aftermath.
Jones and Avery, in particular, altered the aesthetics of the cartoon, changing its pace and subject matter, relying less on the âfull animationâ of Disney, and more on different design strategies and self-conscious thematic concerns, for example, sex and sexuality; injustice; status and social position. In many senses, the innovation in cartoons as varied as The Dover Boys (1942), Red Hot Riding Hood (1943) and Coal Black and de Sebben Dwarfs (1943) anticipates the more formal experimentation of the UPA (United Productions of America) studio, a breakaway group of Disney animators, including Steve Bosustow, Dave Hilberman and Zachary Schwartz, wishing to work more in the style of modernist art (actually pioneered at the Halas & Batchelor and Larkins Studios in England), less in the comic vein, and on more auteurist terms and conditions. Works like Gerald McBoing Boing (1951) and The Tell-Tale Heart (1953) used minimalist backgrounds and limited animation, and were clearly embracing a European modernist sensibility that itself was developing in the âreduced animationâ of the Zagreb Studios, and its leading artist Dusan Vukotic.
As the Disney studio arguably entered a period of decline, Chuck Jones created three masterpieces â Duck Amuck (1953), One Froggy Evening (1956) and Whatâs Opera, Doc? (1957) â all exhibiting Jonesâs ability to deconstruct the cartoon, work with literate and complex themes, and create cartoon âartâ in its own right.
8.3
Fritz the Cat â Ralph Bakshi
Bakshiâs counter-culture cartoon for adults was taboo breaking and subversive in its representation of a sexualised, drug-taking, politically aware America in the shape of cartoon animals, previously the epitome of innocence and child-friendly humour.
8.4
Akira âKatsuhiro Ătomo
Ătomoâs breakthrough animĂ© is distinguished by its dystopian feel and its spectacular animation sequences, which revolutionised animated feature animation and brought a new audience to the form.
In retrospect, it is clear that these were the last gre...