Naval Advising and Assistance

History, Challenges and Analysis

Donald Stoker, Michael T. McMaster

• Publisher: Helion and Company
• Year: 2017
• eBook ISBN: 9781804516195
• Topic: History
• Subtopic: Military & Maritime History
• Index: History

This original edited volume is the only book on naval advising. Drawing upon the work of scholars and practitioners from all over the world, it takes a comparative and global approach to examining the history, theory and evolution of naval advising and assistance. Starting with a brief history of the evolution of naval advising, the book then moves to late-19th century naval advising efforts. These generally involved individuals such as the American adventurer in China, Philo McGiffin, but also included State-sponsored formal missions such as the first such US effort: Colonel John Lay's 1870s mission to Egypt. A comparative multi-national examination of the ability of non-European States such as China, Turkey and Japan to adopt Western naval methods and doctrine - and an examination of the French naval advising mission to Peru - round out the book's pre-First World War offerings. The trends in naval advising between the World Wars—particularly their use as tools of economic and political penetration—are revealed through chapters on the British naval aviation mission to Japan; the British and French naval missions to Poland; the US mission to Peru; and a comparative study of Italian naval missions in Persia, China and Spain. The latter also reveals early ideological motivations for dispatching advising missions. The Cold War saw an intensification of military advising—including naval advising—as both the Communist and the Western Powers used advising as ideological tools. The US naval missions to Nationalist China and South Vietnam are assessed, as are the Soviet naval advising efforts in East Germany and China. Together, through a wealth of original research, the studies in this book provide numerous lessons for future naval advising efforts and constitute a unique contribution to the field.

Table of contents

• Cover
• Title
• Copyright
• Contents
• Acknowledgements
• About the Contributors
• Foreword by John B. Hattendorf
• Introduction
• 1 Colonel John Lay’s Naval Mission in Egypt Frederick J. Cox
• 2 That Prodigal Son: Philo McGiffin and the Chinese Navy Richard H. Bradford
• 3 Adoption Capacity Theory and Naval Doctrine: A Theory of Success and Failure in Naval Advise and Assist Missions to Modernizing States—China, the Ottoman Empire, and Japan Sidharth Kaushal
• 4 The French Naval Mission to Peru, 1905–1914 Jorge Ortiz-Sotelo
• 5 A British ‘Unofficial’ Aviation Mission and the Rise of Japanese Naval Airpower, 1919-1925
• 6 Unfriendly Competition: The British and French Naval Advisory Missions to Poland and the Development of the Polish Navy, 1918-1932 Donald Stoker
• 7 A Question of Sovereignty: The US Naval Mission in Peru, 1920-1939 Joel C. Christenson
• 8 Fascist Naval Missions: Ideology, Commerce, and Strategy in Mussolini’s Navy, 1933-1940 Fabio De Ninno
• 9 Training a Reluctant Ally: The US Naval Advisory Mission to China, Katherine K. Reist
• 10 How to Train the Dragon: Soviet Advisors and Assistance to the Chinese Navy, 1949-1960 Xiaobing Li
• 11 Troubled Assignment: The US Navy’s Advisory Mission in Vietnam, 1954-1973 Edward J. Marolda
• 12 Soviet Naval Advising in East Germany, 1949-1990 Douglas Carl Peifer
• Select Bibliography