Merit, Justice, and the Political Theory of Academic Knowledge Production

Camilla Boisen, Matthew C. Murray, Matthew C. Murray

• Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
• Year: 2024
• Print ISBN:
  9783031654978
• eBook ISBN:
  9783031654985
• Topic: Politics & International Relations
• Subtopic: Political History & Theory
• Index: Politics & International Relations

Academia has long established itself as an institution of knowledge and ideas. Facing pressure, many academic fields and institutions have turned their attention, singularly and collectively, to the task of what to do to rectify the causes of under-representations both academic knowledge itself and who gets to be an academic producer of knowledge. Boisen and Murray argue that simply solving the contemporary symptoms of inequity in ideas, knowledge production and the academy is not enough. Political Theory must be used to analyze why dominant ideas and institutions, namely merit and the resulting meritocracy and meritocratic procedures, were given power in the first place. In using political theory and theories of justice, the book argues that academia must radically shift rather than procedurally reform these methods of evaluation in order to achieve a more coherent approach to diversity in ideas, academic knowledge producers and academic knowledge production, which are necessary to bring about other forms of social change and reform in our larger world. In questioning the ideals and the use of rival ideals to temper flawed concepts, the present motivations and justifications for producing academic knowledge can be relegated as political tools, allowing true meaningful reform. Boisen and Murray show how contemporary crises in academia around diversification of perspectives can only be solved by considering the justifications of academic knowledge production, and the inherent risk of retaining the established competitive and presumptively 'natural', but ultimately biased, methods of deriving academic authority.

Table of contents

• Cover
• Front Matter
• 1. Introduction: Why Interrogate the Concept of Merit
• 2. Production and Politique: Establishing Academic Knowledge Production as Political
• 3. Merit as Moral: Justifying Applications of Power
• 4. The Merit Mythology: Merit as ‘Natural Selection’
• 5. Accepting Dissent, Resistance, and Error
• 6. Relegating the Rule of Merit and Escaping the “Academic Fingertrap”
• Back Matter