Denver picked at her fingernails. âIf it's still there, waiting, that must mean that nothing ever dies.â Sethe looked right in Denver's face. âNothing ever does,â she said.
âBeloved
BELOVED
(1987)
SPOILER ALERT!
In many of her novels, Toni Morrison reveals critical information in the first few pages, so it makes no difference if you know in advance. In Beloved, it does make a difference. Morrison structured Beloved as if the reader had no advance knowledge of either the novel's central tragedy or the identity of the title character. So if you haven't read Beloved and you want to experience it exactly as TM wrote it, don't read past this page.
On the Other Hand...
Of all Toni Morrison novels, Beloved may be the one that readers abandon most often because they have no idea what's going on or they feel intimidated by the book's âliteraryâ style. As original and innovative as her first four novels were, Beloved is a whole other world, reaching levels of almost impossible beauty. It's a shame if people give up on the book simply because they are confused or intimidated by the literary technique. Part of the unique spell that this novel casts is a powerful need to share it! So to those of you who have started Beloved and given up, read this chapter! Here's what you need to appreciate the book deemed âthe best American work of fiction of the past 25 years.â
Background
In the early 1970s, while helping Spike Harris gather material for The Black Book, Morrison read an article she couldn't get off her mind. Titled âA Visit to the Slave Mother Who Killed Her Child,â the article was about a slave named Margaret Garner who escaped from a Kentucky plantation in 1856 and fled with her four children to Ohio. When finally tracked down by her master's slavecatchers, Garner tried to kill her children so they couldn't be forced into slavery. Only one of the children died, but Garner said she'd rather her children were dead than made slaves and âmurdered by piecemeal.â What struck Morrison about the story was that even after being imprisoned for the murder of her own child, Garner believed she had done the right thing.
One of the characteristics of Morrison's genius is that she sees things in a unique way. Her take on Garner's suffering is a perfect example. It was, TM said, âa despair quite new to me but so deep it had no passion at all and elicited no tears.â
For years after reading the account, Toni Morrison wanted to write Margaret Garner's storyâbut it refused to happen. Morrison almost decided that the story couldn't be written, but in the end she found the power by surrendering to that of the Garner family: âIn the end, I had to rely on the resilience and power of the charactersâif they could live it all of their lives, I could write it.â
How do you tell the story of a woman who kills her own child? What can you say that isn't shrunk into insignificance by the terrifying logic of the act itself?
Help came as well from the lead character in a play Morrison had written in 1983, called Dreaming Emmett (1983). Based on a true story, the play was about a teenager named Emmett Till who had been shot in the head and thrown into a river for whistling at a white woman. In Morrison's play, Emmett came back from the dead to speak for himself. She would elevate that technique to a new level in Beloved.
The Story
The year is 1873. The house, known by locals as â124,â is located on 124 Bluestone Road on the outskirts of Cincinnati. Sethe (the Margaret Garner character), formerly a slave on a Kentucky plantation called Sweet Home, has been free for 18 years. Eight years earlier, Sethe's two sons had run away from home. Two months after that, her mother-in-law, Baby Suggs, died. By the time the novel opens, only Sethe and her 18-year-old daughter Denverâalong with the ghost of a dead baby girlâlive in 124.
âFor a baby she throws a powerful spell,â said Denver.
âNo more powerful than the way I loved her,â [Sethe replies.]
Sethe flashes back 18 years to the time she traded a stone carver ten minutes of sex to carve the word âBelovedâ on her baby's headstone. We aren't told how the baby died; we learn the details only in flashbacks. Throughout the novel, events in real time are interrupted by memoryâbut it's reluctant memory. Whereas other flashback novels resurrect the past, Beloved is an attempt to forget it. We get only what leaks through the cracks.
When the novel opens, the Civil War has been over for eight years and all the characters are trying to forget everything about slavery. Even Sethe tries to close off the past, but her âdeviousâ brain lets though chunks of memory: âBoys hanging from the most beautiful sycamores in the world.â Sweet Home, that hateful place, looked so beautiful it made her wonder if hell was pretty too.
On the tail-end of that memory, Paul D, another former slave from Sweet Home, turns up at 124. But when Paul tries to enter the house, he's stopped in his tracks by âa pool of red and undulating light.â He remarks on the feeling of evil, to which Sethe responds, âIt's not evil, just sad.â Sethe asks Paul D to stick aroundâthey (and we) have 18 years of catching up to doâand Paul chases the ghost away. A few days later, a beautiful womanâabout the age Sethe's baby would have been if she'd livedâcomes to the house. She calls herself Beloved. The novel that bears her name and tells her story shuttles back and forth in time, filling in the past, moving through the present, and connecting one to the other.
With apologies to the author for telling the story in a different sequence, perhaps the clearest way to recount the events from this pivot point between past and futureâthe arrival of Paul D and Belovedâis to go back 30 years and do the âcatching-upâ all at once.
In about 1840, a pair of âniceâ slave owners had a plantation in Kentucky called Sweet Home. Paul D, his two brothers (Paul A and Paul F), and Sixo were slaves at Sweet Home when Baby Suggs, a limping old woman, arrived with her lastborn child, a son named Halle. The Garners treat the slaves with uncommon respect; they call the men âmen,â value their opinions, and let them carry guns. Once they set foot outside Sweet Home, however, the slaves are âboysâ to everyone else.
Garner does not free any of his slaves, but he does allow Halle to buy his mother's freedom. Baby Suggs wonders why he bothers to do soâwhat can a crippled old woman do with freedom? But when she walks through Cincinnati a free wo...