Neonatal Bioethics

The Moral Challenges of Medical Innovation

John D. Lantos, William L. Meadow

• Publisher: Johns Hopkins University Press
• Year: 2006
• eBook ISBN: 9780801889004
• Topic: Medicine
• Subtopic: Ethics in Medicine

Neonatal intensive care has been one of the most morally controversial areas of medicine during the past thirty years. This study examines the interconnected development of four key aspects of neonatal intensive care: medical advances, ethical analysis, legal scrutiny, and econometric evaluation.

The authors assert that a dramatic shift in societal attitudes toward newborns and their medical care was a stimulus for and then a result of developments in the medical care of newborns. They divide their analysis into three eras of neonatal intensive care. The first, characterized by the rapid advance of medical technology from the late 1960s to the Baby Doe case of 1982, established neonatal care as a legitimate specialty of medical care, separate from the rest of pediatrics and medicine. During this era, legal scholars and moral philosophers debated the relative importance of parental autonomy, clinical prognosis, and children's rights.

The second era, beginning with the Baby Doe case (a legal battle that spurred legislation mandating that infants with debilitating birth defects be treated unless the attending physician deems efforts to prolong life "futile"), stimulated efforts to establish a consistent federal standard on neonatal care decisions and raised important moral questions concerning the meaning of "futility" and of "inhumane" treatment. In the third era, a consistent set of decision-making criteria and policies was established. These policies were the result of the synergy and harmonization of newly agreed upon ethical principles and newly discovered epidemiological characteristics of neonatal care.

Tracing the field's recent history, notable advances, and considerable challenges yet to be faced, the authors present neonatal bioethics as a paradigm of complex conversation among physicians, philosophers, policy makers, judges, and legislators which has led to responsible societal oversight of a controversial medical innovation.

Table of contents

• Cover Page
• Title Page
• Copyright Page
• Contents
• Acknowledgments
• 1 Overview and Introduction
• 2 Some Facts about Infant Mortality and Neonatal Care
• 3 The Era of Innovation and Individualism, 1965–1982
• 4 The Era of Exposed Ignorance, 1982–1992
• 5 The End of Medical Progress, 1992 to the Present
• 6 Economics of the NICU
• 7 Four Discarded Moral Choices
• 8 The Possibility of Moral Progress
• Notes
• Index