The 1619 Project Myth

Phillip W. Magness

• Publisher: Independent Institute
• Year: 2025
• eBook ISBN: 9781598134117
• Topic: History
• Subtopic: African American History
• Index: History

“There is no one better to pick apart the disastrous 1619 Project than Phil Magness. If every classroom that incorporated the 1619 Project into its curriculum replaced it with this book, the country would be better off.” —Coleman Hughes

Slavery is part of America’s story—its greatest shame. But abolition is part of America’s story, too.

Ignoring the latter isn’t just bad scholarship.

It’s brazen deceit.

And more often than not, it’s done for political reasons.

But that didn’t seem to bother the writers at the New York Times when they launched the 1619 Project in August 2019. Advertised as a journalistic deep dive on the history of slavery, the series promised thematic explorations on a number of topics ranging from the first slave ship’s arrival in Jamestown, Virginia, in 1619, to the present day.

Independent Institute Senior Fellow and David J. Theroux Chair Phillip W. Magness was intrigued. What he found, though, was something else entirely.

To say he was disappointed is putting it mildly.

The 1619 Project was riddled with partisan hysteria, sloppy “scholarship,” blatant errors of fact and interpretation, and, above all else, an anti-capitalist ideological agenda to make the case for tearing down our free market economy. Worse still, its transformation from intellectual debate to political dogma poisoned discourse on the right and the left. Angry Twitter mobs canceled and called for the censoring of all critics. Civil discourse and rational thinking became almost impossible.

Almost impossible.

Thankfully, The 1619 Project Myth boldly sounds the alarm on the New York Times’ outright ideological warfare against American history. It’s the essential guide to the many lies, distortions, and propaganda peddled by the 1619 Project and its defenders.

Magness’ writing is cool, calm, collected, and firm. An acclaimed academic and historian in his own right, he debunks and dismantles every myth and blunder of the 1619 Project, including:

• how the 1619 Project’s creator Nikole Hannah-Jones twisted history into shallow political propaganda (just in time for election season);
• why the Project’s activist defenders rely on sneering derision instead of historical facts;
• why capitalism is not racist … and, in fact, helped free the slaves;
• why reparations are a moral and logistical dead end;
• how the American Historical Association fumbled a chance to protect its institutional integrity and defend real scholarship;
• how Hannah-Jones responded to her critics by ignoring their corrections and making her message even more partisan, political, and anti-capitalist;
• and so much more…

In these pages, Magness delivers a long-overdue rebuke to “scholars” who treat history as a political weapon. History isn’t a tool for scoring points. It’s a long, complicated, and morally nuanced story that demands humility, intelligence, and moral courage from every scholar who dares plumb its depths.

This is a must-read book on slavery, freedom, and the true American story.

Table of contents

• Cover
• Title Page
• Preface to the Updated Edition
• Preface
• Chapter 1: How the 1619 Project Rehabilitates the “King Cotton” Thesis
• Chapter 2: The Anti-Capitalist Ideology of Slavery
• Chapter 3: How Capitalist-Abolitionists Fought Slavery
• Chapter 4: The Statistical Errors of the Reparations Agenda
• Chapter 5: Fact-Checking the 1619 Project and Its Critics
• Chapter 6: The Case for Retracting Matthew Desmond’s 1619 Project Essay
• Chapter 7: A Comment on the “New” History of American Capitalism
• Chapter 8: The New History of Capitalism Has a “Whiteness” Problem
• Chapter 9: What the 1619 Project’s Critics Get Wrong About Lincoln
• Chapter 10: The 1619 Project: An Epitaph
• Chapter 11: Should K–12 Classrooms Teach from the 1619 Project?
• Chapter 12: Down the 1619 Project’s Memory Hole
• Chapter 13: The Suicide of the American Historical Association
• Chapter 14: The 1619 Project Unrepentantly Pushes Junk History
• Chapter 15: Hulu’s 1619 Docuseries Peddles False History
• Chapter 16: The 1619 Project’s Confusion on Capitalism
• Chapter 17: The Tooth-Fairy Economics of Slavery Reparations
• About the Author
• Notes
• Index
• Copyright