The Practice Run

How a Failed Art Heist Provided a Blueprint for the World's Largest Art Robbery

Frederick J. Fisher

• Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield
• Year: 2025
• eBook ISBN:
  9798881858810
• Edition: 1
• Subtopic: History of Art

On Saint Patrick's Day, 1990, one of the largest art thefts in the world took place-the heist of Boston's Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, in which thirteen works of art, worth over half a billion dollars, were stolen by two thieves posing as policemen. Had there been a prior practice run for this theft? Ten years earlier, two thieves posing as delivery men were thwarted in their attempt of a nearly identical robbery at The Hyde Collection in Glens Falls, New York-an art museum modeled after the one in Boston. The young mastermind of these crimes was Brian McDevitt of Swampscott, Massachusetts. He arrived in the small NY town in the spring of 1980, posing as a rich Vanderbilt heir and freelance writer. Prior to his failed heist he spent two months ingratiating himself to the museum's director, the author of this story, in hopes of extracting vital information that would aid in his crime. The book investigates the planning and execution of The Hyde's attempted robbery and traces McDevitt's various escapades following his jail sentences in New York State and Massachusetts. After the Boston heist, he fled to Hollywood, California, masquerading as a screenwriter. When word of his criminal past hit the West Coast, he hightailed it to South America to avoid extradition, where he mysteriously died. FBI and Gardner Museum officials act skeptical about McDevitt's association with the heist, yet they claim the perpetrators have been identified and are deceased, raising suspicion that McDevitt may be in the witness protection program. This story also explores the fascinating history of these two rather impoverished sister museums with art collections of international renown as well as their vulnerable public exposure following the heists. Even more fascinating is the possibility that a single individual might have been the mastermind of both crimes.

Table of contents

• Half Title
• Title Page
• Copyright Page
• Dedication
• Chapter 1: Affirmation
• Chapter 2: The Hydes and Mrs. Gardner
• Chapter 3: Acquiring Art on a Budget
• Chapter 4: The Transition
• Chapter 5: A Career Move
• Chapter 6: Young Mr. Vanderbilt
• Chapter 7: Saved by the Dog
• Chapter 8: Brian Michael McDevitt
• Chapter 9: Planning the Heist
• Chapter 10: Facing the Law
• Chapter 11: Revitalizing The Hyde
• Chapter 12: McDevitt Again
• Chapter 13: Déjà Vu
• Chapter 14: “To Catch a Thief”
• Chapter 15: Hollywood Reinvention
• Chapter 16: Circumstantial, Or . . .
• Chapter 17: Dead or Alive?
• Chapter 18: Where Do We Go from Here?
• Epilogue
• Sources
• Index
• About the Author