Post-Weird

Fragmentation, Community, and the Decline of the Mainstream

Calum Lister Matheson

• Publisher: Rutgers University Press
• Year: 2025
• Print ISBN: 9781978840164, 9781978840171
• eBook ISBN: 9781978840195
• Topic: Social Sciences
• Subtopic: Communication Studies
• Index: Social Sciences

An ambitious look at rhetoric and psychosis that explores how communities form when society collapses

American society seems to have fractured. Common touchpoints of authority have receded in recent decades and beliefs that were once taboo are now openly shared, from neo-Nazism to occultism to conspiracy thinking. In this book, Calum Lister Matheson goes beyond the fraying of contemporary American culture to ask how splinter communities form in our current media environment, what keeps them together, and what they build from the ruins of shared language.

In his stirring exploration of how people communicate when old forms of authority and meaning collapse, Matheson examines far-flung groups that have departed the mainstream—Sandy Hook deniers, Appalachian serpent handlers, pro-anorexia bloggers, incels, transvestigators, pseudoscientific reactionaries, and more—and finds unexpected similarities among their many differences. Key among their parallels is the insistence that the symbols shared by each community represent a hidden truth that cannot be questioned or interpreted but is revealed through signs—words, images, videos, and texts. By documenting American fringe cultures, extremism, and the social functions of language, this book rethinks concepts like irony, psychosis, propriety, and what it means to be normal in weird times. 

Table of contents

• Cover
• Title Page
• Copyright
• Dedication
• Contents
• Introduction: The Spolia of Babel
• 1. Sandy Hook: Guns and Anti-Rhetoric
• 2. Serpent Handlers: Snakebites and Sadists
• 3. Pro-Ana: Wanting Nothing
• 4. Reactionary Science: Agents and Alibis
• Conclusion: The Ends of Rhetoric
• Acknowledgments
• Notes
• Bibliography
• Index
• About the Author