Mining, the Environment, and Indigenous Development Conflicts

Saleem H. Ali

• Publisher: University of Arizona Press
• Year: 2021
• Print ISBN: 9780816528790, 9780816523122
• eBook ISBN: 9780816546886
• Topic: Social Sciences
• Subtopic: Environment & Energy Policy
• Index: Social Sciences

From sun-baked Black Mesa to the icy coast of Labrador, native lands for decades have endured mining ventures that have only lately been subject to environmental laws and a recognition of treaty rights. Yet conflicts surrounding mining development and indigenous peoples continue to challenge policy-makers.

This book gets to the heart of resource conflicts and environmental impact assessment by asking why indigenous communities support environmental causes in some cases of mining development but not in others. Saleem Ali examines environmental conflicts between mining companies and indigenous communities and with rare objectivity offers a comparative study of the factors leading to those conflicts.

Mining, the Environment, and Indigenous Development Conflicts presents four cases from the United States and Canada: the Navajos and Hopis with Peabody Coal in Arizona; the Chippewas with the Crandon Mine proposal in Wisconsin; the Chipewyan Inuits, Déné and Cree with Cameco in Saskatchewan; and the Innu and Inuits with Inco in Labrador. These cases exemplify different historical relationships with government and industry and provide an instance of high and low levels of Native resistance in each country. Through these cases, Ali analyzes why and under what circumstances tribes agree to negotiated mining agreements on their lands, and why some negotiations are successful and others not.

Ali challenges conventional theories of conflict based on economic or environmental cost-benefit analysis, which do not fully capture the dynamics of resistance. He proposes that the underlying issue has less to do with environmental concerns than with sovereignty, which often complicates relationships between tribes and environmental organizations. Activist groups, he observes, fail to understand such tribal concerns and often have problems working with tribes on issues where they may presume a common environmental interest.

This book goes beyond popular perceptions of environmentalism to provide a detailed picture of how and when the concerns of industry, society, and tribal governments may converge and when they conflict. As demands for domestic energy exploration increase, it offers clear guidance for such endeavors when native lands are involved.

Table of contents

• Contents
• Figures
• Tables
• Preface
• Introduction
• Abbreviations
• Part I - Communities of Interest and Emergent Conflict
• Part II - Analyzing Resistance
• Part III - The Prescriptive Synthesis
• Appendix 1 - Highlights of the Nunavut Land Claims Agreement
• Appendix 2 - Technical Concerns Regarding the Voisey’s Bay Project
• Appendix 3 - Questionable Mining–Land Dispute Linkages Used by Activists
• Appendix 4 - Charles Lipton’s Eighteen Points on Indian Mineral Leasing
• Appendix 5 - Marjane Ambler’s Suggestions on Aboriginal Negotiations for the Minerals Industry
• Notes
• Works Consulted
• Index