International Trade Theory

A Critical Review

Murray Kemp

• Publisher: Taylor & Francis
• Year: 2008
• Print ISBN: 9780415437653
• eBook ISBN: 9781134073184
• Edition: 1
• Topic: Business
• Subtopic: Business General
• Index: Business

Murray C. Kemp is one of Australia's foremost economists. He has held positions across the world including London School of Economics, U.C. Berkeley, Columbia University, McGill University, MIT, and latterly Macquarie University. Kemp was a Member of Council for the Econometric Society and was a Distinguished Fellow of the Economics

Part I
The classical theory of international trade

1
The Torrens-Ricardo Principle of Comparative Advantage

An extension

1.1 Introduction

Nearly two hundred years on, the Torrens-Ricardo Principle of Comparative Advantage is still widely admired within the profession, and appears prominently in many elementary textbooks and in most treatises on international trade. However, careful inspection of the Principle, either in the mildly disparate formulations of Torrens (1815:264–5) and Ricardo (1817:135) or in any later formulation, reveals that it relies on restrictive assumptions about preferences and technology in each trading country, assumptions that are always implicit, never explicit. Specifically, the Principle rests on the assumption that in autarkic equilibrium each country consumes all commodities, at least incipiently. Our purpose is to make good this claim and to reformulate the Principle in sufficient generality to accommodate alternative assumptions about preferences and technology. In our reformulation the emphasis is on marginal rates of substitution in consumption, not on the traditional ratios of marginal labour costs in production. Thus our restatement concerns not merely the proper display of the Torrens-Ricardo Principle but rather its essential content. It is shown in effect that, in existing formulations, the supply side is assigned a role that it cannot always sustain. That two classical economists overlooked this point can be understood, but the same indulgence cannot be extended to the authors of neo-classical textbooks.¹

1.2 The standard formulation

In the usual textbook formulation, two countries, England and Portugal, produce, consume and trade two commodities, cloth and wine; there are no non-tradable commodities. Each commodity is produced by means of a single primary factor, homogeneous labour, under constant returns to scale. Within each country, but not necessarily across countries, all households are identical in all respects: size, age distribution, preferences, quality of labour and access to technical information.²

For England, the household and (by revision of quantity units) the economy-wide production possibility locus is represented in Figure 1.1(a) by the straight segment Q_EQ′_E, the slope of which is (minus) the ratio of the two marginal labour costs of production. In the absence of market distortions, a unique autarkic equilibrium is represented by point C_E, where a community indifference curve forms a tangent to the production possibility locus and where, for each commodity, (positive) consumption is equal to production. The equilibrium commodity price ratio is equal to the ratio of marginal labour costs. Similarly, the unique autarkic equilibrium of Portugal is represented in Figure 1.1(b) by point C_P.

Figure 1.1a England’s autarkic equilibrium, with incomplete specialization

Figure 1.1b Portugal’s autarkic equilibrium, with incomplete specialization

Figure 1.2a England’s offer curve, with incomplete autarkic specialization

Figure 1.2b Portugal’s offer curve, with incomplete autarkic specialization

Abandoning the assumption of autarky, let us pass in review all conceivable world price ratios. Given any particular price ratio, we can determine the profit-maximizing pair of English outputs, uniquely except when the hypothetical price ratio is equal to the equilibrium autarkic price ratio, and we can determine uniquely the utility-maximizing English consumption pair. Transferring that information to Figure 1.2(a), we obtain the offer curve EOE′ for England, where the straight segm...

Table of contents

• Routledge Studies in International Business and the World Economy
• Contents
• Acknowledgements
• Introduction
• Part I The classical theory of international trade
• Part II The neo-classical theory of international trade
• Part III Normative trade theory
• Part IV Methodology
• Notes
• References
• Index