Can a practice enforced by government still have no lawful authority? Lysander Spooner turns that question into a searching constitutional case for abolition.
First published in 1845, The Unconstitutionality of Slavery challenges the belief that the United States Constitution sanctioned human bondage. Spooner begins with a fundamental claim: law must rest on natural justice, not simply on the commands of those who hold power. He then examines colonial charters, the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, and the Constitution to argue that slavery lacked a legitimate legal foundation.
At the heart of the work is a close reading of the provisions commonly invoked to defend slavery, including the three-fifths provision, the fugitive-servant clause, and the slave-trade compromise. Spooner insists that constitutional meaning must be established through the words ratified by the people, rather than the unexpressed intentions of the framers. His argument challenged defenders of slavery and divided abolitionists themselves. Today, it remains a provocative encounter with the relationship between written law, moral principle, and state power.
What readers find inside:
- Natural justice - Spooner grounds legal authority in rights that government does not create.
- Founding documents - America's early political instruments become evidence in a sustained argument for liberty.
- Contested clauses - Constitutional provisions used to support bondage receive detailed scrutiny.
- Rules of interpretation - The work argues for the authority of the ratified text over the private intentions of its authors.
- Law and conscience - Spooner presses judges and citizens to confront their responsibility when power conflicts with justice.
This work will engage readers of constitutional law, students of American abolitionism, and anyone interested in the philosophical foundations of individual rights.
Begin Spooner's argument and consider what makes a law worthy of obedience.
