Learning from Media

Arguments, Analysis, and Evidence

Richard E. Clark

• Publisher: Information Age Publishing
• Year: 2012
• Print ISBN: 9781617358104, 9781617358111
• eBook ISBN: 9781617358128
• Edition: 2
• Topic: Education
• Subtopic: Education Administration

Richard Clark's observation that "…media are mere vehicles that deliver instruction but do not influence student achievement any more than the truck that delivers our groceries causes changes in our nutrition" is as misunderstood today as it was when first published in the Review of Educational Research in 1983. The convincing if little read scientific evidence presented by Clark has divided the field and caused considerable concern, especially among the providers of newer media for learning.

A collection of writings about the "media effects debate," as it has come to be called, was published in 2001. Edited by Clark, Learning From Media was the first volume in the series "Perspectives in Instructional Technology and Distance Education." The series editors are convinced that the writings of Clark and those who take issue with his position are of critical importance to the field of instructional technology, Thus, a revised, second edition of Learning From Media is now being offered.

The debate about the impact of media on learning remains a fundamental issue as new mediated approaches to teaching and learning are developed, and Clark's work should be at the center of the discussion. The critical articles on both sides of this debate are contained in Learning From Media, 2nd Edition.

Table of contents

• Cover
• Learning From Media: Arguments, Analysis, and Evidence Second Edition
• Perspectives in Instructional Technology and Distance Learning
• Learning From Media: Arguments, Analysis, and Evidence Second Edition
• Copyright
• Dedication
• CONTENTS
• MEDIA ARE “MERE VEHICLES”: Foreword to the Second Edition
• PREFACE
• 1: MEDIA ARE “MERE VEHICLES”: The Opening Argument
• 2: QUESTIONING THE META-ANALYSES OF COMPUTER-BASED INSTRUCTION RESEARCH
• 3: WHY SHOULD WE EXPECT MEDIA TO TEACH ANYONE ANYTHING?
• 4: INTERNATIONAL VIEWS OF THE MEDIA DEBATE
• 5: A SUMMARY OF THE DISAGREEMENTS WITH THE “MERE VEHICLES” ARGUMENT
• 6: ROBERT KOZMA’S COUNTERPOINT THEORY OF “LEARNING WITH MEDIA”
• 7: KOZMA REFRAMES AND EXTENDS HIS COUNTER ARGUMENT
• 8: AN ANALYSIS OF KOZMA AND CLARK’S ARGUMENTS
• 9: THE MEDIA VERSUS METHODS ISSUE
• 10: ARE METHODS “REPLACEABLE”?: A Reply to Critics in the ETR & D Special Issue on the Debate
• 11: NEW DIRECTIONS: An Argument for Research-Based Performance Technology
• 12: NEW DIRECTIONS: Evaluating Distance Education Technologies
• 13: THE EQUIVALENT EVALUATION OF INSTRUCTIONAL MEDIA: The Next Round of Media Comparison Studies
• 14: WHAT IS NEXT IN THE MEDIA AND METHODS DEBATE?
• APPENDIX: A Biography of Richard E. Clark