I Evaluation and Empirical Evidence of ICM Implementation
For the first time long-term evaluations and empirical research which have been conducted during the last semesters constitute contributions to these 3rd ICM conference proceedings.
Based on empirical research, Christian Decker and Stephan Beier answer the central question whether the implementation of the ICM, with its learner-centered self-navigation, its intensification of cooperation, and the learners’ active involvement in the learning process, lead to an increased learning success compared to traditional teaching methods. Their evaluation of the ICM implementation at the HAW Hamburg shows that a higher learning success and an enhancement of learner-centered self-guidance and active participation and collaboration are the results.
Similar beneficiary effects are shown by Jürgen Handke in his evaluation of two on-campus classes and the VLC-MOOC ‘Linguistics 201’. Supported by a wealth of data, he gives an overview on general student behavior, in-class attendance and learning outcomes in large classes with regard to special adjustments to the Inverted Classroom Mastery Model.
dp n="16" folio="" ? dp n="17" folio="" ?
1 The Instructor as Navigator: Empirical Evidence of the Implementation of the ICM at HAW Hamburg
Christian Decker & Stephan Beier
1.1 Introduction
The Hamburg University of Applied Sciences (HAW Hamburg) is the third largest University of Applied Sciences in Germany. At HAW Hamburg, curricula of three different bachelor degree programmes include the identical lecture module ‘Investment and Finance’. The three programmes are:
- Foreign Trade/International Management
- Logistics/Technical Business Administration, and
- Marketing/Technical Business Administration
In the summer semester 2013, the Inverted Classroom Model (ICM) was introduced. The implementation of the ICM was accompanied by an empirical research project. The research question to be investigated was whether the implementation of the ICM, with its learner-centered self-navigation, its intensification of cooperation, and the learners’ active involvement in the learning process, lead to an increased learning success compared to traditional teaching methods. A master thesis, which was conducted in the context of the degree programme ‘Educational Media’ at the University Duisburg-Essen, documents the results of this research project.
1.2 Initial situation
The lecture module ‘Investment and Finance’, which combines the two sub-modules ‘Investment’ and ‘Finance’, is credited with 5 ECTS credit points (2.5 ECTS-CP each). The lectures of the sub-module ‘Finance’ comprise 15 weekly sessions (90 minutes each), taught separately for each of the three degree programmes. The average number of students enrolled in the three programmes totals to approximately 140 to 170 students per semester. Previously, the lecture contained both parts of traditional teacher-focused reading and parts of hands-on seminars. However, significant parts of the lecture were characterised by elements of traditional teaching approaches. Between 30 and 60 students participated regularly in each session. In general, the students did not have previous lecture-specific or practical knowledge. In the past, the average failure rate had continuously increased to reach a peak of 57%. Assumed drivers for this trend were the distinctive heterogeneity with respect to the individual cognitive capacity, the abilities of concentration and reflection, the motivation, and the social behaviour. However, the lecture module’s evaluations in the past indicated that an increased portion of practical-based case studies and hands-on exercises might have positive effects on the students’ motivation, which might also impact the students’ learning success and examination grades. Due to time constraints, such an increase in activities would have resulted in a reduced content of reading, which might have induced problems with the accreditation of the study programmes.
1.3 Development of a new concept
Based upon the observation of the initial situation, it was analysed whether the course concept could be modified in order to improve the lecture’s quality and accordingly better meet the students’ needs. These aims ought to be achieved by shifting the focus of learning from teacher-centered lectures towards student-centered learning activities. Furthermore, the modification of the concept was supposed to be realised without the reduction of the content of learning. Didactical and methodical changes in the course concept were based on the Inverted Classroom Model (Schäfer, 2012: 3). The modified concept should define the framework for an increase in the students’ intensified and self-directed learning engagement (Davis, 2013: 214) as well as an increase of their responsibility for learning processes (Spannagel, 2012: 73). Furthermore, the modified concept should increase the students’ involvement in constructivist learning environments such as active and collaborative learning activities (Bishop/Verleger, 2013). In this concept, the provision of e-learning videos during the online phase should mainly support self-directed learning processes and their positive impacts on cognition and information processing as well as motivation and flexible handling of resources regarding time and place (Friedrich/Mandl, 1997). Activities during the in-class phases should mainly be based on constructivist learning environments such as active, cooperative and problem-based learning approaches (Bishop/Verleger, 2013). The graphic below presents the theoretical framework of the new course concept.
Figure 1.1: Framework for a learner-centered concept in the ‘Finance’-lecture
The development of a fundamental theoretical understanding and the acquisition of practical and methodical competencies were major objectives while developing the course concept. It was expected that students comprehend the teaching and learning content at a deeper level and that failure rates decrease. Finally, the new concept was supposed to lead to an improvement of the students’ learning success. Therefore, four hypotheses were derived from the research of learning theories with regard to the implementation of self-directed, active and collaborative learning activities, which ought to be realised by the application of the Inverted Classroom Model:
- (1) The transfer of self-guiding and self-responsibility leads to a more intensive engagement with the learning content compared to traditional teaching approaches.
- (2) The design of in-class phases leads to intensified active participation as well as to intensified collaboration and cooperative learning activities.
- (3) Students intensifying their active involvement or achieving a better understanding of contents prefer the concept compared to traditional teaching approaches.
- (4) The implementation of an ICM leads to increased learning success, which may range from a better understanding of the learning contents to better average examination results.
The analysis of the hypotheses was subject to empirical research based on the lecture module ‘Finance’ at HAW Hamburg in the summer semester 2013.
1.4 Content production and distribution and organisation of in-class activities
The content production for e-learning videos was based on an extensive Microsoft PowerPoint script containing various graphics, charts, d...