four
Tommyâs Planet
He has so many realitiesâand he believes them all.
âTom Ripley, The Talented Mr. Ripley
David and Donna were scene partners in Jean Sheltonâs class, and also extremely nice people, but they were in growing danger of raising Samuel Beckett from the dead and compelling him to stomp through San Francisco like Godzilla. I was sitting two rows back from Shelton, who was pinching the bridge of her nose and looking into her lap. When David and Donna came to the end of their scene from Waiting for Godot, Shelton was silent, as was everyone else. David and Donna stood on the stage like prey animals waiting to see which one of them would be eaten first.
Jean Shelton looked a little bit like Yodaâs mother: short, glasses, frizzy white hair. Yet she seemed to us, her students, more like Darth Vader. When you got up onstage in front of her, you were pulled between feelings of terror and exhilaration. She was the best kind of teacher, in that you didnât care if she liked you personally; you just wanted her to respect you professionally.
Sheltonâs class was held in a basement studio space on Sutter Street, off San Franciscoâs Union Square. But for the stage, the room was kept very dark, though you could always see Shelton, thanks to the way the light illuminated her halo of white hair. When you were awaiting her judgment, as David and Donna were now, you dreaded the first few words from her mouth. Her accent was very mid-Atlantic: soft, round consonants and fierce vowels. That big, commanding voice of hers filled the room, cutting through the darkness.
âAwful,â Shelton said to David and Donna. âThat was just . . . Iâd tell you to try it again but I doubt youâll do any better.â She waited for David or Donna to speak. They didnât. They couldnât even look at each other. âPoor selection of material, as well. I saw nothing good. Nothing useful.â She paused. âIâm sorry.â
That was another thing about Shelton. You never felt as though she enjoyed being negative. She always seemed to genuinely want you to be great. As David and Donna climbed from the stage and collapsed into front-row seats, Shelton looked around. âDoes anyone want to do anything? We still have some time. The stage is open.â The seats in the theater were old, so their creaking served as a good indicator as to how restless the class was feeling. On this evening, the chairs were creaking like crazy: Everyone was ready to leave.
To myâand, Iâm sure, everyone elseâsâastonishment, someone stood in the back row. It was the pirate from the previous week. Today he was wearing black pants, an ostentatiously studded belt, and a gleamingly pearlescent button-down shirt. He had a slightly hunchbacked posture, and when he walked his arms barely moved. He was also taking his sweet time getting to the stage. He went backstage and slowly picked around before returning with a foldout chair, which he snapped open and slammed down onstage, so that its back was facing the audience. He straddled the chair, legs spread wide, and pushed his long dark hair from his face. It suddenly seemed possible this guy was actually sort of great. No one who wasnât great could afford to conduct himself like this.
Shelton asked him, âAnd what are you doing for us, Thomas?â
âNo, not Thomas. Itâs Tommy.â
Bored already, Shelton scratched her nose. âWhat are you doing for us, Tommy?â
âThe Shakespeare, Sonnet 116.â
I heard someone mutter, âOh no, not this again.â
I was watching Shelton very closely now. We all were. âProceed,â she said.
âLet me not to the marriage of true minds,â he began, âadmit impediments.â He bludgeoned his way through the rest, each line a mortal enemy. Where the sonnet demanded clear speech, he mumbled; when it asked for music, he went singsong. Everything he said was obviously the product of diligent mismemorization, totally divorced from the emotion the words were trying to communicate. He was terrible, reckless, and mesmerizing.
Once again we waited, frozen within a dreadful glacier of Sheltonian silence.
âWhat is it exactly,â Shelton finally said, âthat youâre trying to do here?â
The guy drew his head back and flipped his hair over his shoulder. âSonnet,â he said.
âYes,â she said. âBut what are you trying to do?â
His bearing tensed up. âSend the message,â he said. âExpress emotion of Shakespeare.â
That accent, I thought. It sounded almost French, but not quite. Was there some Austrian buried in it?
âItâs a sonnet,â he continued. âYou know, sonnet?â
âOh, God,â someone said next to me, her hand clamped over her mouth.
âYes,â Shelton said, which she followed with a quick, huffy laugh. âI know what a sonnet is. What I donât know is what you are trying to do.â
The guy was silent. His face was getting red, rapidly.
Shelton noticed this and went into salvage mode. âLook,â she said. âThe chair is not helping you. Itâs distracting. Maybe you should do it . . . standing up.â
His face was now a tomato with orifices. But he didnât budge. âI disagree with that,â he said, now barely keeping control of himself. Everyone in that class was at least a little afraid of Shelton. No one ever got mad at her for expressing her opinion, certainly. But this guy wasnât afraid of her. It felt oddly liberating to watch someone confront her.
âI see, then.â Shelton lifted herself from her chair and turned to the rest of us. âYouâre all free to go.â
What I had just seen almost never happened in acting classes. The pirate was not only confrontational but fearless, a trait I wanted better acquaintance with. Of anyone in our class, this guy had the least cause to be so outspoken, so confident, yet he was. I was intrigued.
My mother, who was meeting me for dinner that evening, was waiting outside the studio. Just as I was describing to her the interesting French guy Iâd seen in class, the sonneteer himself passed by us. âThere he is,â I said.
My mother enthusiastically marched over to him to say hi, just as any French person outside of France does when informed that a fellow native is within two kilometers. âExcusez-moi? Mon fils me dit que vous ĂȘtes Français. Câest vrai?â
The guy whirled around as though heâd been pickpocketed. âNon, merci,â he said quietly.
My mother didnât give up. âDâoĂč venez-vous?â she asked pleasantly.
âI have to go,â the guy said with a sick, half-secretive smile.
My mother and I watched as he slithered away into the night. âI thought he was French,â I told her.
âThat guy is not French,â she said. âWhatever he is, I think heâs been put through the wringer.â
âą âą âą
âSomething bigâ was how my agent described it to me, and the more I learned the bigger it sounded. A film called Wildflowers, starring Daryl Hannah, Eric Roberts, and Clea DuVall, was going to be shooting in the Bay Area. I saw this as my chance to land something that would pluck me out of obscurity and plant me in Hollywood.
I ended up getting called back several times. Then my agent called. âEverything was right,â she said, âbut someone else fit the part better.â When she saw how upset I was, my mother said, in so many words, âI told you so.â When the person youâre closest to is telling you to quit, itâs not easy to go on. Her voice was still in my head. An acting career? A pipe dream. Agents? Evil with a Rolodex.
I was feeling defeated and almost didnât bother going to acting class that night. Any momentum Iâd thought Iâd gathered had vanished. Classes, it was becoming obvious, didnât guarantee anything. The only thing that made me consider going to class that night was the prospect of watching the unpredictable pirate go bananas onstage again. During the previous weekâs class, in the middle of his scene, he had grabbed a glass full of water from a prop table and thrown it against the wall. Then he kept going with his scene as though nothing had happened. When Shelton asked why he had done this, he answered, âI was in zone.â In fact, whenever Shelton questioned his creative choices, he answered as though he had as much right to expound on craft as she did.
That night would be the pirateâs final performance with his current scene partner. Theyâd decided to do a scene from A Streetcar Named Desire. I had no doubt which scene theyâd chosen.
Cut to: Pirate Guy in a white tank top, his wild hair in a ponytail, wandering around stage left, crying out, âStella!â many more times than the script called for and occasionally breaking into exaggerated sobs. He wasnât even bothering to direct his agony toward his partner, the intended focus of the scene. He was just launching his performance out into space. Two girls in the first row were squeezing each otherâs hands in an effort to contain their laughter. The actor sitting next to meâan older guy who was normally subdued to a faultâactually began laughing so hard he had to bunch his sweater up around his mouth. The pirateâs scene partner valiantly tried to bring him around with the smelling salts of actual lines from the script, but he kept yelling over her, âStella! Stella!â until he went to his knees, covered his face with his hands, cried for a moment, and finished with a final and piercingly wrong âStella!â
Most bad performances are met with silence. This was something else. There were murmurs. There were giggles. Everyone in that basement studio knew they had just witnessed one of the most beautifully, chaotically wrong performances they would ever see.
As for me, I felt resuscitated. Iâd never been so happy to be in a classroom.
Jean Shelton did not wait to address the lunatic who lay prostrate before her. âThomas, or TommyâIâm sorryâI must ask youâagainâwhat you are trying to accomplish?â
He was rising from the floor now. His face was flushed, his eyes intense little blurs of exhaustion. âI am performing the Tennessee Williams scene,â he said. At this, his scene partnerâan older womanâshook her head hopelessly.
âNo, Tommy,â Shelton said. âI donât think thatâs what you were doing.â I sensed Sheltonâs brain trying to plan its attack in a distractingly target-rich environment. âFirst, you did nothing to demonstrate Stanleyâs objective in the scene.â She stopped, shifted, reversed. âWhat is Stanleyâs objective in this scene?â
âStanley is hysterical,â he said.
âNo, thatâs . . . not an objective. Stanley loves Stella. Heâs trying to reach Stella. And if heâs trying to reach Stella, to speak to her, he is not going to shout at the stagehands or audience members. Heâs going to address her. But you hardly noticed Stella. As far as your performance was concerned, she wasnât even on the same stage.â
Thatâs when I realized what heâd been doing up there: He was looking for the camera. He wasnât thinking about Stanley. He was thinking about Brando. For him, there was no stage. There was only an appeal to a camera that didnât exist.
âYouâre wrong,â he said to Shelton.
I donât think she heard him, because she kept going: âAlso, Stanley is a very strong man. A strong character and a strong man. Heâs pursuing Stella. Heâs not screaming because heâs in pain. Stella is right in front of you, and youâre yelling in the opposite direction. And so I ask again: What are you doing?â
âIâm sorry,â the pirate said. âMay I correct you?â
âNo!â Shelton cried out, pointing at him. âNo, you may not!â
No one was laughing now. But I had a thought, a thought I canât fully explain, even today: He should be my next scene partner. I have to do a scene with this guy.
Maybe heâd cheer me up. Maybe Iâd learn some of his fearlessness. What made him so confident? I was desperately curious to discover that. It wasnât his acting, obviously, which was extraordinarily bad. He was simply magically uninhibited; the only person in our classâor any class Iâd ever taken, for that matterâwhom I actually looked forward to watching perform. The rest of us were toying with chemistry sets and he was lighting the lab on fire.
After Shelton dismissed us, I made a beeline for the guy. He was getting his stuff together, putting on his jacket, the adrenaline still draining from his face. I knew he probably didnât feel like talking, so I got right to it: âYou want to do a scene together?â
He looked at me, his eyes narrowed, his mouth partly open. I couldnât tell if he was annoyed or offended or pleased. âYou and me?â he asked.
âYeah.â
âWhy you ask me?â he asked, irritably.
The directness of this question caught me off guard.
âI just thought that since you donât...