Appendix A: The Particle Enigma
What is a particle? We all know that the concept of a particle comes from Democritusâ idea of atoms. His conception, and what today we would call Brownian motion, was related by Lucretius to the origin of all motion in his poem On the Nature of Things (50 B.C.E.):
Whence Nature all creates, and multiplies
And fosters all, and whither she resolves
Each in the end when each is overthrown.
This ultimate stock we have devised to name
Procreant atoms, matter, seeds of things,
Or primal bodies, as primal to the world.
âą âą âą
For thou wilt mark here many a speck, impelled
By viewless blows, to change its little course,
And beaten backwards to return again,
Hither and thither in all directions round.
Lo, all their shifting movement is of old,
From the primeval atoms; for the same
Primordial seeds of things first move of self,
And then those bodies built of unions small
And nearest, as it were, unto the powers
Of the primeval atoms, are stirred up
By impulse of those atoms' unseen blows,
And these thereafter goad the next in size;
Thus motion ascends from the primevals on,
And stage by stage emerges to our sense,
Until those objects also move which we
Can mark in sunbeams, though it not appears
What blows do urge them.
With a little license, Lucretiusâ âProcreant atoms, matter, seeds of things, Or primal bodiesâ formed the basis of physical thought until quite late into modern times. In the ancient world, however, while it was accepted there might be different kind of atoms, the number of types was small and sometimes related to geometrical shapes. The advent of modern chemistry and spectroscopy in the 19th century began the formation of the current understanding of the nature of atoms.
Today, it is believed that the elementary building blocks of matter are leptons and quarks, all of which are called fermions and obey the Dirac equation for a particle of spin of œ In addition, there is electromagnetic radiation carrying a spin of 1. Lucretiusâ understanding of atoms has been carried over into the modern conception of âparticleâ in the sense that the basic fermions are thought to be âstructurelessâ or âpointâ particles. This can be seen in the attempts to construct âclassicalâ models for the electron. Examples are the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation of quantum mechanics [1] and the work of David Hestenes. [2] But retaining the idea of a massive charged point particle requires that both mass and charge be renormalized, a process that has never rested comfortably with many physicists.
The greatest challenge to the ancient idea of a particle came from the work of de Broglie, who introduced in 1924 the idea that each particle had associated with it an internal clock of frequency m0c2/h. From this idea he found his famous relation showing particles of matter were associated with a wave. [3] He did not believe a particle like the electron was a point particle, but rather that the energy of an electron was spread out over all space with a strong concentration in a very small region: âLâĂ©lectron est pour nous le type du morceau isolĂ© dâĂ©nergie, celui que nous croyons, peut-ĂȘtre Ă tort, le mieux connaĂźtre; or, dâaprĂšs les conceptions reçues, lâĂ©nergie de lâĂ©lectron est rĂ©pandue dans tout lâespace avec une trĂšs forte condensation dans une rĂ©gion de trĂšs petites dimensions dont les propriĂ©tĂ©s nous sont dâailleurs fort mal connues.â [4]
A1. The de Broglie Relation: Theory and Experiment
De Broglie, in his 1929 Nobel lecture used the following argument:
Identifying the energy of the massive particle with E = hv gives
De Broglie then assumed that c2 / V corresponds to a phase velocity via vV = c2, so that
Using V = vλ, he obtains his relation λp = h.
Note that by assuming that c2 / V corresponds to a phase velocity de Broglie is introducing waves having neighboring frequencies so that he can define both phase and group velocities. The phase velocity so introduced is, in Max Bornâs words, âa purely artificial conception, inasmuch as it cannot be determined experimentally.â [5]
The existence of de Broglieâs internal clock has recently been directly subject to experiment. The experimental approach used is known as âelectron channelingâ, a phenomenon observed in silicon crystals. [6], [7] In the experiments, a stream of electrons is aligned along a major axis of a thin single crystal corresponding to a row of atoms. Th...