Reckless Disregard

St. Amant v. Thompson and the Transformation of Libel Law

Eric P. Robinson

• Publisher: LSU Press
• Year: 2018
• Topic: Law
• eBook ISBN:
  9780807170182
• Subtopic: North American History
• Index: Law

In the years following the landmark United States Supreme Court decision on libel law in New York Times v. Sullivan, the court ruled on a number of additional cases that continued to shape the standards of protected speech. As part of this key series of judgments, the justices explored the contours of the Sullivan ruling and established the definition of "reckless disregard" as it pertains to "actual malice" in the case of St. Amant v. Thompson. While an array of scholarly and legal literature examines Sullivan and some subsequent cases, the St. Amant case—once called "the most important of the recent Supreme Court libel decisions"—has not received the attention it warrants. Eric P. Robinson's Reckless Disregard corrects this omission with a thorough analysis of the case and its ramifications.

The history of St. Amant v. Thompson begins with the contentious 1962 U.S. Senate primary election in Louisiana, between incumbent Russell Long and businessman Philemon "Phil" A. St. Amant. The initial lawsuit stemmed from a televised campaign address in which St. Amant attempted to demonstrate Long's alleged connections with organized crime and corrupt union officials. Although St. Amant's claims had no effect on the outcome of the election, a little-noticed statement he made during the address—that money had "passed hands" between Baton Rouge Teamsters leader Ed Partin and East Baton Rouge Parish deputy sheriff Herman A. Thompson—led to a defamation lawsuit that ultimately passed through the legal system to the Supreme Court.

A decisive step in the journey toward the robust protections that American courts provide to comments about public officials, public figures, and matters of public interest, St. Amant v. Thompson serves as a significant development in modern American defamation law. Robinson's study deftly examines the background of the legal proceedings as well as their social and political context. His analysis of how the Supreme Court ruled in this case reveals the justices' internal deliberations, shedding new light on a judgment that forever changed American libel law.

Table of contents

• Cover
• Title Page
• Copyright Page
• Contents
• Preface
• Timeline: St. Amant v. Thompson and Related Events
• Introduction
• 1. The Gumbo of 1960s Louisiana
• 2. The Road to Sullivan
• 3. Philosophies of Communication and Defamation
• 4. “The Story of Politics in Louisiana Today”
• 5. Thompson Goes to Court
• 6. Results Shift in Louisiana’s Appeals Courts
• 7. The U.S. Supreme Court Sets a Standard
• 8. The Aftermath
• 9. The Legacy of St. Amant v. Thompson
• Appendix A: Text of Phil St. Amant’s Campaign Address
• Appendix B: Court Opinions in St. Amant v. Thompson
• Notes
• Bibliography
• Index