1
Monsters
The Horror of Compassion
âThe Thing
Jaws remains a film of enduring significance. While the scenes with the shark may appear at times clunky and unrealistic, the power of the film lies in its ability to keep the shark monster off the screen while the threat of the monster remains very real. Whenever someone is even near water, we feel a sense of dread, an uncertainty and fear that we cannot shake off. We know that the best outcome for everyone is to simply stay out of the water! And yet the draw of the water, the skepticism that a killer shark actually exists, is too powerful to stop people from diving into the crystal waves. The constant sense of apprehension that you feel as a viewer while people are in the water is a credit to the genius of Steven Spielberg.
Jaws is a film for our time, for it speaks into a Western culture whose narrative is one of fear of what lurks beyond us. It is a monster that we glimpse that needs to be destroyed, that we know is not everywhere, that is very specifically in one place, albeit a vast and expansive space, and yet at the same time the media and government make us feel like the threat lies potentially everywhere. Since 9/11, the American and UK governments have committed themselves to the âwar on terror.â We have spent billions on war, sending troops on the ground, dropping bombs from the air, and increasing our ability for monitoring and surveillance of our own citizensâall to combat and defeat the threat of âterror.â We have been fed a narrative through the media and government that there is a specific threat that needs to be dealt with, and our energy and money needs to be given to the eradication of this threat, a threat that we should be afraid of. In one scene in Jaws the beach is packed full of people, all sunbathing and playing on the sand, but no one has gone into the sea. A boy has already died earlier in the film, eaten by the underwater monster that results in a massive search for the killer shark, with seemingly the whole town out in their boats looking for the shark to kill it. One boat finds and kills a massive tiger shark, and the whole town celebrates, yet, paradoxically, uncertainty remains. The visiting shark expert, Matt Hooper, tells Chief Brody that the shark that has been caught is not the shark they are looking for, that itâs too small, but the mayor will have none of it, fearing any talk of a killer shark still on the loose will damage the townâs summer economy. The townspeople and summer visitors seem to have an enduring sense of fear, unsure whether it is actually safe to go back in the water, so that on the Fourth of July weekend everyone is on the beach but not in the sea. The mayor throughout the film is deeply concerned by lost profits and revenue. A beach where no one is swimming is not good advertising. He walks up and down the beach ordering the locals to get in the water, which they eventually do. Once one person starts swimming many others join them, and fears of a killer shark soon disappear. But of course the threat remains, and another shark attack leads Chief Brody, Hooper, the marine specialist, and Quint, the hardened, skilled, and battle-worn fisherman, to go in search of the underwater monster. At the climax of the film Quint has been killed by the shark, the war veteran devoured by the relentless, sleepless killing machine. The hero, it turns out, is Brody, the middle-class, hard-working, white, all-American, saving the all-American town, preserving its middle-class beauty. Brody, having jammed a pressurized scuba tank in the sharkâs mouth, climbs the mast of the sinking boat, and starts shooting at the tank. He then utters the immortal line, âSmile, you son of a bitch,â and shoots the tank and destroys the shark. What then, you might ask, has this to do with âthe war on terrorâ?
Fear is a great motivator, and fear of the unknown, the unusual, or âotherâ can result in our desire for security and protection, whatever the cost. The âwar on terrorâ has cost a lot: money and lives. What we seek is a resolution, for the unseen enemy to be destroyed. We want our way of life to be preserved, indeed, to remember how things used to be and reclaim our country, in order to have a better life that has been eroded and disturbed by forces out of our control. The narrative from both media and successive governments is that there is a terrorist threat that needs destroying, so we send our âall-American heroesâ or âBritish heroesâ; these regular, hardworking people, we send them out to hunt and destroy the terrorists who are killing us and terrorizing our way of life. The only way to defeat the enemy is though violence, through bullets ripping through the enemyâs territory, much like Brodyâs bullets tearing through the water. The scuba tank in the sharkâs mouth is perhaps a modern-day symbolism of our own weapons in the hands of terrorists, sold to Saudi Arabia, resold to terrorist groups. Jaws, then, is that classic monster taleâa story of fear, of peace disrupted, a monster out to destroy our way of lifeâand the only way to overcome it is through our violence, a violence that will preserve our way of life. But not all monster stories follow this pattern; The Babadook is a different monster story altogether that offers us another way to handle the fear that the unseen terror evokes within us.
Babadookian Fear
The Babadook tells the story of Amelia, a depressed and troubled widow, who is struggling to raise her six-year-old son, Sam. Ameliaâs husband, Oskar, was killed in a car accident while Amelia was in labor with Sam. Throughout the film we discover the strain this has caused on Ameliaâs ability to bond with Sam, a simmering and sometimes overt resentment to her son. One night, Amelia reads to Sam a pop-up storybook called Mister Babadook, a mysterious man/monster with a top hat and pointed fingers, dressed in black with a pale face, who torments his victims once they become aware of his existence. She doesnât finish the story, but the first few pages are enough to terrorize Sam.
The poem of Mister Babadook goes like this,
The book, understandably, gives Sam nightmares, and so he climbs into his mumâs bed. Once Sam is asleep, Amelia moves across the bed as far from her son as possible, a look of revulsion written over her face.
As the film progresses the unseen presence of the Babadook grows, as does Ameliaâs paranoia and fear that something is lurking in the shadows, hunting her and her son. Eventually Amelia is literally possessed by the Babadook, but Sam manages to tie her up in the basement. He pleads with his mum to admit to herself that the Babadook is inside of her otherwise she can never get rid of him. Sam goes to her and strokes her face, at which she manages to get her hands free and begin to strangle h...