1
Committing to the Relationship
Programs designed with strong parent involvement produce students who perform better than otherwise identical programs that do not involve parents as thoroughly or that do not involve them at all.
āAnne T. Henderson
Why should schools work so hard to form and maintain positive parental relationships? In a nutshell, because research has clearly proven that student achievement improves when parents are involved in their childās education. So, in answer to the why question, the overwhelming answer is increased student achievement. It makes sense, then, since we are educators whose main goal is to help students learn and achieve, that we must believe in our obligation to forge strong relationships with the parents of our students.
A simple search of current and past literature on parent-school relationships will yield countless research reviews, books, and articles supporting the need for building strong relationships with parents and families. In a synthesis of 35 years of education research, Robert Marzano writes in What Works in Schools (2003) that community and parental involvement is one of 11 factors that are highly effective in enhancing student achievement. According to Henderson and Berla (1994), āThe single best predictor of student success in school is the level of parental involvement in a childās education.ā The benefits of parental involvement include improved academic achievement, reduced absenteeism, improved school behavior, increased academic motivation, and lower dropout rates.
Henderson and Mapp (2002) found that regardless of family income or background, students whose parents are involved in their schooling are more likely to have higher grades and test scores. They also found that when parents are invested and participate in school activities, their children attend school regularly, develop better social skills, show improved behavior, and adapt well to school.
While the childās academic success is certainly the most important reason to build a strong, positive parent-teacher relationship, there are benefits that extend beyond those gained by the individual child. As parents and teachers forge strong ties, benefits expand to the teacher, parents, class, school, and, ultimately, the school district. Strong parent-teacher relationships can have a snowball effect on all stakeholders.
Henderson and Berla (1994) also found that, when parents participate in their childās school activities (e.g., volunteer readers, teacher assistants for special projects), the performance of not only their own child but that of all the children at school tends to improve. Additionally, they found that the more organized and comprehensive the partnership between parents and home, the higher the individual student academic achievement. Indeed, the presence of an additional adult in the classroom increases the amount and timeliness of direct attention the students receive and allows the teacher to focus on priority individual assistance where needed.
In reflecting on our personal experiences with the parents and families of our students, the evidence supporting the benefits of parental involvement is overwhelming. So much so that we often told parents that we needed their involvement, even if it was only to complain or to tell us that they were upset about something. We reminded them that it was their job to keep us on our toes, to keep us informed, and to advocate for their child. We referred to the educational process as āa three-part pie.ā One part is the student, one part is the school, and one part is the parent (i.e., home). We would further explain that āif one part spoils, the rest can go with it.ā
As we developed strong partnerships with parents, we began to observe numerous effects on the individual student, teacher, parent, classroom, school, and school district. A discussion of each follows, with some of the specific benefits we identified as we worked toward and developed strong parent-school relationships. We would encourage you, upon reflection of your own parental relationships, to think about observed and personally experienced benefits.
BENEFITS TO THE STUDENT
As proven, when the teacher and parent have a strong, positive relationship, student achievement improves. With collaboration and teamwork, we have observed that even with severe academic deficiencies, students show improvement when parents are involved.
As parents form a closer partnership, they tend to support school efforts at home with more frequency and intensity. This increased support leads to better achievement, which in itself becomes a strong rationale for putting in the time and effort to keep a childās parents involved. It supports taking action to do whatever is needed to forge a strong partnership.
Another observed benefit of a strong school-home partnership is that many children exhibit a sense of security in knowing that both their teacher and their parents are working together to help them do well in school. By working harmoniously, home and school can set clearer and more concise expectations for the child. They can also establish and maintain boundaries that are well articulated and consistent and form a collaborative team that creates solutions to problems that may arise. For sure, all of these possible outcomes will benefit the child academically, socially, and behaviorally. Donāt underestimate the power of school and home alignment.
A commanding example of what happens when school and home are at odds is that of James, age 12. James was so used to his parents being angry with his teachers and school that he had little trust in any of the school staff. His parentsā negativity and distrust were passed on to James to such a degree that he felt disloyal to his parents if he enjoyed a certain class or teacher. Consequently, he began to resist going to school. His behavior in school became defiant and oppositional. His teachers, in turn, felt frustrated and misunderstood, and they grew wary of communicating with Jamesās parents at all. The situation only grew worse.
Only when a couple of Jamesās teachers slowly and consistently called his parents with good reports of his abilities did an opening for change occur. Gradually, with a great deal of patience and understanding on the part of school personnel, Jamesās parents became less combative and more receptive to hearing from the school. Over time, as the relationship improved between home and school, James started to relax, ended his resistance to attending school, became more cooperative, and made academic progress.
Other benefits to the student include the following:
⢠Increased motivation
⢠Lower absenteeism
⢠Decreased use of drugs and alcohol
⢠Fewer suspensions
⢠Improved attitude
⢠Increased cooperation
BENEFITS TO THE TEACHER
Strong parent-teacher relationships have several advantages in addition to those enjoyed by the students. When teachers have positive relationships with studentsā parents, understanding of and support for classroom curriculum and activities rises. Collaboration often leads to improved ideas, enriched resources (e.g., volunteers, donations), expanded trust, and increased teacher willingness to try new things. All of these, in turn, lead to improved teacher confidence, job satisfaction, and self-esteem.
Through our discussions with and observations of teachers who had strong, positive relationships with parents, several noticeable commonalities appeared. In general, these teachers employed a more positive, nurturing approach to their instruction. They appeared to have more energy and less stress. They brought home into the discussion and made the school an extension of the childās life with his or her family. They increased the relevance of what students learned in school by sharing family situations and stories that were pertinent to the educational discussion. The teachers were seemingly happier with their job and provided classrooms that were positively charged.
In general, teachers who forge strong partnerships with parents and families enjoy higher levels of student achievement, professional license to try new things, and personal satisfaction with their day-to-day activities. We know how draining a negative or hostile parental relationship can be to our teaching. It makes the benefits of working hard to turn that negative into a positive all the more worth it.
Other benefits to the teacher include the following:
⢠Fewer discipline problems
⢠Increased time to focus on task at hand
⢠Greater sense of value to the classroom and school
⢠Decreased sense of isolation in their work
⢠Improved job satisfaction
BENEFITS TO THE PARENT
The most valuable parental benefit of having a positive relationship with their childās teacher is the development of trust that emerges from this relationship. As parentsā trust in their childās teacher increases, their anxieties tend to decrease. As their anxieties decrease, their willingness to support the efforts of the teacher increases. This, in turn, increases their childās academic achievement.
Another benefit of this forged relationship is the sense of partnership built in the educational process. This partnership can empower parents and increase their sense of ownership in their childās education. As their sense of ownership increases, their commitment to school events, activities, and requests for support will likewise increase. This commitment will lead to their own personal satisfaction and involvement in their childās education.
As the relationship develops in a positive fashion, parents will enjoy a higher level of comfort with the teacher. This will lead to a more honest and open sharing of information that is critical to the childās overall wellbeing and success in school. Parents will feel supported and assisted in their desires to have their child thrive in school.
Other benefits to parents include the following:
⢠Additional information source for potentially problematic family issues with negative educational effects
⢠Additional support for family initiatives that may need carryover outside the home (e.g., diet and health programs)
⢠Greater security in knowing that the childās educational needs are recognized and addressed
⢠A child who views school in a more positive light
BENEFITS TO THE CLASS
As previously stated, when parents have positive relationships with teachers, they tend to become more involved in school activities. As their involvement increases, they offer more experiences to share with the class. They will be more likely to volunteer their services for special events or for in-class activities such as tutoring or aide programs in the classroom. Additional support in the classroom is of benefit to all.
Since the collective mind is always better than the single mind, increased parental involvement leads to increased ideas and creativity for instruction. It is easier to establish the class as a community and allow the teacher to stay focused on the instruction while the parents take care of the extraneous duties to carry out the instructional plan (e.g., finding or setting up materials for activities).
Having another set of eyes in the classroom can be of great help to the entire class. If the teacher requests assistance with observing anything specific in the classroom, the parent may lend a unique perspective that can be most helpful to the teacher, who canāt always see everything that is happening while focusing on instruction. The parent might even come up with some suggestions or ideas that will benefit the class or aid in the delivery of instruction.
One case in point involved a volunteer parent who consistently assisted in writing class. She noticed that a small group of students who were not strong writers were consuming a great deal of the teacherās time in getting started on their writing pieces. This caused the teacher to work less efficiently with stronger writers who still needed support with mechanics. The parent, working with the stronger writers, noticed that they got off to a quicker start because they could generate ideas faster for their writing pieces. The parent suggested pairing stronger writers with weaker ones to generate writing ideas, allowing both teacher and parent to work with all students on the mechanics of the writing samples being generated. The teacher accepted and used the suggestion very successfully from that time on.
Other benefits to the class include the following:
⢠Wider exposure to cultural differences represented by families
⢠Increased attention to each student with better student-adult ratio
⢠Increased on-task behavior
⢠Introduction of additional ideas and experiences to the curriculum
BENEFITS TO THE SCHOOL
Strong, positive relationships between parents and teachers build trust in the entire school. This trust reaps significant positive public relations, which can then translate to support of schoolwide initiatives. We all know the benefits of having a strong, supportive parental group working toward the schoolās goals.
Strong, positive relationships between parents and teachers also serve to open the lines of communication and apprise administrators of important issues and concerns that parents may have about the school. By receiving this information from parents, administrators can work proactively to address concerns or solve current problems brought to their attention. Concurrently, by listening to many parents, administrators can assess what is enjoyed and valued by the parental community.
With increased parental...