1 ABSTRACTION
THE DISTANCING OF AN IDEA FROM OBJECTIVE REFERENTS
Abstract, or nonrepresentational art, emerged in the early twentieth century as a radical idea. When used in philosophy, the word refers to the distancing of an idea from objective referents so that it becomes a distillation of thought. Abstraction came about in art through a similar process of distancing, as various artists began to present simplified, or distilled, notions of the objective world.
A series of art movements—starting with Impressionism in the 1870s and continuing through Postimpressionism to Cubism in the 1920s—gradually shifted the focus in art away from the task of representation and toward the making of artworks that were entirely autonomous. As early as 1907, the Fauvist artists of Paris were producing works in which the representational subject matter was little more than a motif on which to hang adventurous explorations of non-natural color. By 1910, the Cubists were making paintings in which classical space had been replaced by a shallow pictorial space that suggested multiple viewpoints. During World War I, Dadaist artists in Zurich began making artworks that challenged cultural expectations on all fronts; works by Hans Arp (1886–1966), for example, featured nonobjective sculpted reliefs. Exactly who was the first artist to do entirely abstract works is open to some question. The most popular candidate is Wassily Kandinsky (1866–1944), whose paintings moved away from simplified and flattened allusions to figurative subjects to become compositions of autonomous floating forms by 1912.
Today, abstract art covers a huge range of different kinds of artworks in both two and three dimensions. Some of the abstract or nonobjective qualities that can be manipulated by artists are color, form, space, volume, geometry, texture, weight, balance, presence, scale, decoration, rhythm, and movement.
Kasimir Malevich (1879–1935)
Black Square on White Ground, 1915, Oil on linen, 31
5/
16 × 31
5/
16 in (79.5 × 79.5 cm)
In Russia, the Constructivists, led by Malevich, began to make abstract art of great geometric austerity by 1915.
Wassily Kandinsky (1866–1944)
Improvisation 27 (Garden of Love II), 1912, Oil on canvas, 47
3/
8 × 55
1/
4 in (120.3 × 140.3 cm)
Kandinsky was amongst the first artists to make purely abstract works. This painting was shown at the famous Armory Show in New York in 1913, where new ideas in European art were seen in the Americas for the first time.
2 ALLEGORY
ABSTRACT IDEAS COMMUNICATED WITH CONCRETE IMAGES
Allegory is a device whereby abstract ideas can be communicated using images of the concrete world. Elements, whether figures or objects, in a painting or sculpture are endowed with symbolic meaning. Their relationships and interactions combine to create more complex meanings.
The success of an allegorical work naturally depends on the audience’s ability to recognize the identities and corresponding symbolic meanings of each of the elements within the work. A famous example is Titian’s Allegory of Age Governed by Prudence. Here, the three human heads represent the past, present, and future. They also represent the three ages of man: youth, maturity, and old age. Beneath them three animal heads symbolize the three stages of life and give us new information about them. The head beneath the young man is an eager puppy. Beneath the middle-aged man is a powerful lion, while beneath the old man a large and aging wolf stands with its ears back. Above the figures is an inscription in Latin: EX PRAETERITO/PRAESENS PRUDENTER AGIT/NE FUTURA ACTIONE DETURPET (“From [the experience of] the past, the present acts prudently, lest it spoil future actions”).
As in most allegorical paintings, the meaning offered here is complex and open to a number of interpretations. Part of the pleasure of contemplating such a work involves reflecting on the possible multiplicity of meanings. For instance, we know that in this painting the old man is a self-portrait of Titian (c. 1488–1576), while the middle-aged man is his son, and the youth is his nephew. The painting might be seen as a cautionary image in which the artist is telling his family not to make the same mistakes that he did. On the other hand, the painting might just be a general observation about the increase of wisdom and circumspection that so often comes with age. Or again, the painting may refer to the more narrow idea that artistic judgment and discrimination become better with age.
Although allegory was a popular form of painting during the Renaissance and Baroque periods, it has long fallen out of favor and played little role in the development of modern art. This is no doubt because the moderns, with their interest in abstraction and visual purity, found allegory to be too literary.
See also: Symbols on page 186
Titian (c. 1488–1576)
Allegory of Age Governed by Prudence, 1565–70, Oil on canvas, 30 × 27 in (76.2 × 68.6 cm)
3 AMBIGUITY
LEAVING THE WORK OPEN TO DIVERSE INTERPRETATION
Sometimes a work of art acquires strength by projecting a structure or meaning that is ambiguous.
VARIETIES
• Perceptual ambiguity
A representation of a three-dimensional formation that can be interpreted in alternative ways. The classic example is the Necker cube, a drawing of a cube that can be seen as occupying space in two alternative ways. The most notable artist to explore perceptual ambiguity was M. C. Escher (1898–1972). In many of his works, ambiguities of both recognition and spatial construction are presented in endlessly playful and provocative ways.
• Ambiguity of recognition
A representational element has more than one interpretation due to inadequate or confusing cues. A shadowy shape might be a human head or an apple, for instance. The surrealist artist Yves Tanguy (1900–1955) made many paintings in which he rendered forms that had ambiguous and confusing identities, deliberately presenting the viewer with a sense of puzzlement and mystery.
• Ambiguity of meaning
The sense or import of the artwork is ambiguous. The viewer is presented with an ongoing conundrum because symbols, narrative action, or other cues do not coalesce around a clear idea. This was a favorite strategy of the French artist Balthus (1908–2001) whose paintings often present narrative scenarios of indeterm...