eBook - ePub
Enchanted Shows
Vision and Structure in Elizabethan and Shakespearean Comedy about Magic
Elissa Hare
This is a test
Partager le livre
- 208 pages
- English
- ePUB (adapté aux mobiles)
- Disponible sur iOS et Android
eBook - ePub
Enchanted Shows
Vision and Structure in Elizabethan and Shakespearean Comedy about Magic
Elissa Hare
DĂ©tails du livre
Aperçu du livre
Table des matiĂšres
Citations
Ă propos de ce livre
The book, first published in 1988, examines the role of magic in Elizabethan and Shakespearean theatre. The author observes how certain plays, including Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Tempest, rationalise the unrealism and improbabilities typical of romantic comedy as miracles wrought by specifically magical intervention. The author also explores the ways in which playwrights justify structural discontinuity by the working of magic. This title will be of interest to students of English Literature, Drama and Performance.
Foire aux questions
Comment puis-je résilier mon abonnement ?
Il vous suffit de vous rendre dans la section compte dans paramĂštres et de cliquer sur « RĂ©silier lâabonnement ». Câest aussi simple que cela ! Une fois que vous aurez rĂ©siliĂ© votre abonnement, il restera actif pour le reste de la pĂ©riode pour laquelle vous avez payĂ©. DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Puis-je / comment puis-je télécharger des livres ?
Pour le moment, tous nos livres en format ePub adaptĂ©s aux mobiles peuvent ĂȘtre tĂ©lĂ©chargĂ©s via lâapplication. La plupart de nos PDF sont Ă©galement disponibles en tĂ©lĂ©chargement et les autres seront tĂ©lĂ©chargeables trĂšs prochainement. DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Quelle est la différence entre les formules tarifaires ?
Les deux abonnements vous donnent un accĂšs complet Ă la bibliothĂšque et Ă toutes les fonctionnalitĂ©s de Perlego. Les seules diffĂ©rences sont les tarifs ainsi que la pĂ©riode dâabonnement : avec lâabonnement annuel, vous Ă©conomiserez environ 30 % par rapport Ă 12 mois dâabonnement mensuel.
Quâest-ce que Perlego ?
Nous sommes un service dâabonnement Ă des ouvrages universitaires en ligne, oĂč vous pouvez accĂ©der Ă toute une bibliothĂšque pour un prix infĂ©rieur Ă celui dâun seul livre par mois. Avec plus dâun million de livres sur plus de 1 000 sujets, nous avons ce quâil vous faut ! DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Prenez-vous en charge la synthÚse vocale ?
Recherchez le symbole Ăcouter sur votre prochain livre pour voir si vous pouvez lâĂ©couter. Lâoutil Ăcouter lit le texte Ă haute voix pour vous, en surlignant le passage qui est en cours de lecture. Vous pouvez le mettre sur pause, lâaccĂ©lĂ©rer ou le ralentir. DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Est-ce que Enchanted Shows est un PDF/ePUB en ligne ?
Oui, vous pouvez accĂ©der Ă Enchanted Shows par Elissa Hare en format PDF et/ou ePUB ainsi quâĂ dâautres livres populaires dans Media & Performing Arts et Theatre. Nous disposons de plus dâun million dâouvrages Ă dĂ©couvrir dans notre catalogue.
Informations
Chapter V
Shakespeareâs dissolving magic: The Tempest
Critics often remark the compelling austerity of The Tempest. L.C. Knights attributes the playâs mysteriousness, and his own âdifficulty in saying simply and clearly where (he) feels the playâs greatness to reside,â to its âspare ... notation, that only gets its effect when the reader or spectator is prepared to collaborate fully to give apparently slight clues full weight.â1 Anne Barton traces The Tempestâs power to its extraordinary combination of density and openness:
Spare, intense, concentrated to the point of being
riddling, The Tempest provokes imaginative
activity on the part of its audiences or readers.
Its very compression, the fact that it seems to
hide as much as it reveals, compels a peculiarly
creative response. A need to invent links between
words, to expand events and characters in order to
understand them, to formulate phrases that can
somehow fix the significance of purely visual or
musical elements is part of the ordinary
experience of reading or watching this play.2
riddling, The Tempest provokes imaginative
activity on the part of its audiences or readers.
Its very compression, the fact that it seems to
hide as much as it reveals, compels a peculiarly
creative response. A need to invent links between
words, to expand events and characters in order to
understand them, to formulate phrases that can
somehow fix the significance of purely visual or
musical elements is part of the ordinary
experience of reading or watching this play.2
1 L.C. Knights, âThe Tempest,â Shakespeareâs Late Plays: Essays in Honor of Charles Crow, ed. C. Tobias and P.G. Zolbrod (Athens: Ohio Univ. Press, 1974), pp.15-17. I use the Arden edition (ed. F. Kermode) of The Tempest.
2 Anne Barton, ed., The Tempest (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1981), p. 19.
The play works its magic on our senses by depriving them,3 making us fill the spaces within its dramatic texture, enlisting our imaginations in the service of the playâs fabrication.
This chapter argues that magic and imagination are both put to work explicitly in the playâs silences, unexpected transitions, and structural discontinuities.4 The significant developments of The Tempest occur during interruptions of dramatic progress. Prosperoâs magic repeatedly inhibits the completion of action contemplated by other characters: he puts some to sleep, and stills the swords of others. Instead of action Prospero offers spectacular shows that appear out of nowhere and vanish just as abruptly: the tempest, banquet, and masque, all punctuations of action, are themselves interrupted.
The abruptness with which the shows materialize and dissolve into nothingness creates an effect of suspension between reality and illusion;5 our eyes are made to focus more and more on the instant of transition between substance and shadow, nature and art. It is the precise point at which ârealâ meshes with âunrealâ that is the focus of Shakespeareâs artistry in the shows of The Tempest, and that most eludes critical definition.6 Magicians habitually seek the point of conjunction between real and unreal: the practitioner of sympathetic magic who constructs an imitation of what he lacks and desires is not unlike the artist who tries to transmute base nature into gold by constructing a second nature that imitates and improves the familiar first, âmaking things better than Nature bringeth forth.â7 Prospero, at once artist and magician, aims to redeem his fellows and himself through a series of shows that, increasingly, transfigure as well as imitate natural objects: the banquet, masque and tableau of the lovers at chess are all images of plenty or peace.
3 So Coleridge, Ninth Lecture on Shakespeare and Milton, in Coleridge: Essays and Lectures on Shakespeare and Some Other Poets andDramatists (London: Dent, n.d.),p. 454, writes that The Tempest âdid not appeal to any sensuous impression ... of time and place, but to the imagination.â
4 For an interesting general discussion of structural discontinuity in the romances see Barbara Mowat, The Dramaturgy of Shakespeareâs Romances (Athens: Univ. of Georgia Press, 1976), e.g. pp. 98-99.
5 A.D. Nuttall, Two Concepts of Allegory (London: Routledge, 1967), p. 142, notes that everything in The Tempest is half one thing and half the opposite: âThis recurrent sense of ambiguity and suspension is extremely potent dramatically.â
6 Anne Righter, Shakespeare and the Idea of a Play (New York: Barnes and Noble, 1962), p. 192, finds this a unique and reprehensible confusion in Shakespeare, unlike Robert Egan, Drama Within Drama (New York: Columbia Univ. Press, 1975), pp. 1-14, who specifically disputes Righterâs pessimism about the play.
7 Philip Sidney, The Defence of Poesy, p. 108; C.L. Barber, Shakespeareâs Festive Comedy, is perhaps the best known critic to link magic and imagination, pp. 139ff.; Robert Egan, Drama Within Drama, pp. 93-95, also finds the link between magic and art in the âcontrol of reality through imitationâ and the presentation of a believable âmimetic vision of the idealâ; on believability of the playâs illusions see David Young, The Hartâs Forest: A Study of Shakespeareâs Pastoral Plays, (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 1972), p. 178.
I argue finally that the playâs magic is most fully exposed when what we see dissolves like the tempest into the calms of I.ii. . It is the disappearance of the banquet that gives the courtiers early warning of a lesson to be learned; it is when the masque collapses that the lovers begin to fulfil the prophecies of the masque. It is when the playâs magic dissolves that we are transformed into magicians.8 Prosperoâs abjuration of magic occurs only after its miracles have been contained in the new and better nature it has made. The renunciation of magic draws us into the world of the play, and empowers our imagination to reach beyond what we know, and to discover our better selves.
We cannot analyze how the playâs strong illusions work to integrate nature and art, without first recognizing the initially divisive strategy of magic. The magic of The Tempest divides in order to unite, as the rope in I.i. is both noose and salvation.9 Prospero and Ariel, indeed, always begin by interrupting some projected movement of events in time, or of bodies in space, arresting and redirecting the playâs temporal progress. Prospero puts Miranda to sleep in I.ii. after having at last recounted their past history up to the present moment. The mariners are also divided from their senses -- put to sleep -- this time by Ariel. They, unlike Miranda, remain asleep for the whole play. In II. i. Ariel puts to sleep all the courtiers but Antonio and Sebastian (their greater turpitude requires stronger and more direct magic, as we shall see).
8 For alternative, less positive views of the renunciation of magic see e.g. Andrew V. Ettin, âMagic into Art: The Magicianâs Renunciation of Magic in English Renaissance Drama,â TSLL, 19 (1977), 268-93; for a less consistently pessimistic reading see Howard Felperin, Shakespearean Romance, (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press, 1972), pp. 247 ff.
9 Neil Wright, âReality and Illusion,â p. 249, makes this point.
The essentially restorative purpose of sleep in the play, though functioning in the end like the reconstitutive sleep of Lear and Macbeth, works in The Tempest at first purely negatively: as always in this play, magicâs reintegrative purpose is initiated by an interruption. Time simply stops for the sleepers: magic creates not the heightened intensity of a dream state as in A Midsummer Nightâs Dream, but a temporary death to the world around them: the sleepers are subtracted for a time from the developing action, taken out of play time. Other characters exploit the time magically taken from the sleepers: Antonio plans to use the moment vouchsafed him by the sudden descent of the others âas by a thunder-strokeâ (II.i.199) into oblivion: âThâoccasion speaks theeâ (202), he advises Sebastian, and the opportunity solicits their attention. But their nefarious plans are in turn arrested by Ariel. Prospero, who âthrough his art foresees the dangerâ (292), sends Ariel, âFor else his project dies, -- to keep (the courtiers) living.â Ariel thus wakes the sleepers to the sight of Antonioâs and Sebastianâs drawn swords.
So far the interruptions of sleep are accounted for by Prosperoâs and Arielâs magic: even the more evil intentions of the wakeful are in turn inhibited by -- we have now been conditioned to assume -- magic. But closer examination reveals an unexplained curiosity in this scene. The villainsâ swords are halted a split second before Ariel works his magic: they pause, inexplicably, for âbut one wordâ as they draw swords. The Tempest abounds with interruptions not overtly magical in origin. Repeated and multiplied, they acquire a mysterious significance for which no theory of hasty composition will adequately account.10 Once we discover that these mysterious breaks in continuity are rationalized elsewhere in the play by magic (as when Ferdinandâs sword is halted), we begin to suspect that magic may occasionally work independently of the magician, and that Prosperoâs disrobing, âLie there my Art,â does not necessarily deprive magic of its power, but just denudes the magician of his.
When Prospero stills Ferdinandâs sword, he also charms him from moving: implicit in the arrest of time is the halting of movement in space, as swords and sword-bearers are transfixed. Other magical interventions, by Ariel particularly, break through the normal boundaries of place and person. In III.ii., for example, the lowest caste of villains, Caliban, Stephano and Trinculo, is repeatedly interrupted in its plotting by the invisible Ariel. Functioning like Puck in A Midsummer Nightâs Dream, III.ii., the spirit imitates in turn the voices of the conspirators. Caliban hears Arielâs âThou liestâ (44) and thinks Trinculo has spoken; similar interruptions occur twice more (61,73). Trinculo is threatened by Stephano with dire consequences should he âinterrupt the monster one word furtherâ (67), but of course he has not done so in the first place. Here the intrusion of the spirit Ariel into the private space of the villains is in truth an invasion and occupation of their persons. They are, as it were, not the same villains, their very physical integrity violated by the magic that reduces their power to act.
10 For a...